Take a photo of a barcode or cover
710 reviews by:
kaylaramoutar
3.9 - I'm docking the .1 away from a full 4 because I knew the "big reveal"/twist by page 45. The foreshadowing of it was quite obvious in my opinion - I don't know if that was on purpose. Did Meyer want us to know? Did she want us to watch the characters flounder their way there? Who knows.
Overall I enjoyed this; it has the basic premise of Cinderella but so much was changed that I enjoyed reading it. Sometimes retellings are so close to the original that it's boring AF, but this has enough fresh ideas re: the fairytale that it's not.
Also! Tell us more about this world? It's "new Beijing" so there has to be like, huge differences between our earth and their earth? They have androids and hover cars, cool, but what else?! World big! Tell me more!! Please!!
I've heard the rest of the series are better so I'm excited to get into them!!
Overall I enjoyed this; it has the basic premise of Cinderella but so much was changed that I enjoyed reading it. Sometimes retellings are so close to the original that it's boring AF, but this has enough fresh ideas re: the fairytale that it's not.
Also! Tell us more about this world? It's "new Beijing" so there has to be like, huge differences between our earth and their earth? They have androids and hover cars, cool, but what else?! World big! Tell me more!! Please!!
I've heard the rest of the series are better so I'm excited to get into them!!
Ahhh this series is so fun.
In Cinder I *knew* the surprise twist within 50 pages, but this one I guessed about halfway through. Well I guess technically there were two - one was obvious, the other was probable. This is vague, sorry lol. I liked that I didn't know for sure what the twist was going to be, or if there was even going to be one. I also don't necessarily think it's a twist, because these stories are all very loosely based on fairytales, so as long as you're familiar with the story you can probably guess what's going to happen. Saying that, though, there are still so many little things that are added in that you don't Feel like you're reading a retelling. This series is definitely new and fresh, and a lot better than most retellings out there.
I really liked Scarlet, she was feisty and fun. I'm glad that she didn't change much throughout the novel because sometimes I find that the main character changes TOO much to be plausible (especially because it takes place over like 2 days). I liked Cinder A LOT more in this novel, even though it's been like 4 days since the end of Cinder (the novel), she was just easier to understand and connect with. I guess it just comes down to Meyer writing her better.
I'm excited to get into Cress!
In Cinder I *knew* the surprise twist within 50 pages, but this one I guessed about halfway through. Well I guess technically there were two - one was obvious, the other was probable. This is vague, sorry lol. I liked that I didn't know for sure what the twist was going to be, or if there was even going to be one. I also don't necessarily think it's a twist, because these stories are all very loosely based on fairytales, so as long as you're familiar with the story you can probably guess what's going to happen. Saying that, though, there are still so many little things that are added in that you don't Feel like you're reading a retelling. This series is definitely new and fresh, and a lot better than most retellings out there.
I really liked Scarlet, she was feisty and fun. I'm glad that she didn't change much throughout the novel because sometimes I find that the main character changes TOO much to be plausible (especially because it takes place over like 2 days). I liked Cinder A LOT more in this novel, even though it's been like 4 days since the end of Cinder (the novel), she was just easier to understand and connect with. I guess it just comes down to Meyer writing her better.
I'm excited to get into Cress!
4.3
🗣 !!!!!! Cress (character) is great. Usually innocent and naive isn't my style re: heroine but she's written so well that I love her. She also has a little bit of sass (that I'm sure will come out more in Winter) and she's very handy to have on the team - hacker who knows things about the enemy?? V helpful.
Again, I liked Cinder even more than I did in 'Scarlet'. She was a begrudging hero (and still kind of is) and I really like that. She did it because she had to, not necessarily because she wanted to. And then in Cress you can tell she's doing because she has to AND because she wants to. She sees and knows what Levana can do to Earthens and she wants to help them. She's great. Also - Captain Thorne? Heck yeah.
🗣 !!!!!! Cress (character) is great. Usually innocent and naive isn't my style re: heroine but she's written so well that I love her. She also has a little bit of sass (that I'm sure will come out more in Winter) and she's very handy to have on the team - hacker who knows things about the enemy?? V helpful.
Again, I liked Cinder even more than I did in 'Scarlet'. She was a begrudging hero (and still kind of is) and I really like that. She did it because she had to, not necessarily because she wanted to. And then in Cress you can tell she's doing because she has to AND because she wants to. She sees and knows what Levana can do to Earthens and she wants to help them. She's great. Also - Captain Thorne? Heck yeah.
I know we're not supposed to like Levana by the end of the novel, and I didn't, but I also just... didn't care. I felt like the "reasons" she was evil were pretty not-great. I definitely think they could've been worse, but also a lot better. It's definitely sad that her sister was EVIL, especially/even as a child and thus forced Levana to live her life ~hidden, but everything else felt super underwhelming. Was it the unrequited love that made her this power hungry queen? No. She was always like that. She manipulated her husband before she was "power hungry"... I just genuinely think that she grew up wishing she had an iota of power and it consumed her. Nothing else meant as much to her as the power - babies, love, being a decent person... it never meant anything to her. All of that led me to be somewhat bored with the entire book and Levana as a person. Not sympathetic, not engrossed in her rise to power, nothing. I would've rather her just been evil to be evil, not some amalgamation of sad things that were somewhat/mostly her own fault.
What I did like about Fairest is the little snippets we get of Selene and Winter (and Jacin!). I'm really interested to see what happens in Winter between the three of them (do they reunite???? i hope so.) Truly though, it is a wonder that Selene is such a decent person because her mother is a goddamn TRIP, god, could she have been worse?! Even the scenes where she was mothering Selene were creepy and weird.
A review I saw for Fairest said "this book honestly didn't do much for me, other than confirming how terrible levana is." and that's exactly how I feel. That being said, I think it's worth reading because no matter what backstory is helpful/interesting, but I wouldn't say it's a Need-to-Read.
What I did like about Fairest is the little snippets we get of Selene and Winter (and Jacin!). I'm really interested to see what happens in Winter between the three of them (do they reunite???? i hope so.) Truly though, it is a wonder that Selene is such a decent person because her mother is a goddamn TRIP, god, could she have been worse?! Even the scenes where she was mothering Selene were creepy and weird.
A review I saw for Fairest said "this book honestly didn't do much for me, other than confirming how terrible levana is." and that's exactly how I feel. That being said, I think it's worth reading because no matter what backstory is helpful/interesting, but I wouldn't say it's a Need-to-Read.
I'm so happy.
Where do I start? Winter was the perfect ending to The Lunar Chronicles. I'm super sad it's over and I wouldn't be opposed to Meyer releasing more books in this universe. Please.
The title character was so great. She was the perfect amount of tragic and beautiful which made her POV compelling and fun. Her relationship with Jacin... be still my poor little heart. He was literally the world's best protector and you can Fight Me On That. (Wolf - I love him, a lot, but like... you know. I'm also scared of him.) You could literally Feel them yearning for each other and every nudge of their shoulders was like a kick in my gut. The scene by Ryu's pen....... y'all. Y'ALL :( but also <3 You know?
Cinder, my sweet brave cyborg. Even though I kept getting caught up in the stories and lives of the other character's I was still rooting for Cinder above all. She did her best and I needed to see her succeed. The short scene when she's in the lake and is just slowly accepting everything that's happening broke my heart.
Cress and her character arc was great. Someone mentions at one point "she didn't curl into Thorne like she usually did" (paraphrased) and I was like YES!!! SHE DIDNT!! YOU'RE RIGHT!! because she grew to love and trust these people and she wasn't scared to have opinions and be herself. It was truly character growth and it was incredible. When she yells at Thorne in that palace scene I was mentally cheering her on because yes, use that fire inside of you, girl. Don't... get me started on Thorne.
Just kidding.
THORNE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [pom poms, confetti, etc.] The suave, funny, sweet, criminal pilot. Would this series have been as good without him? Jury's still out.
His relationship with Cinder is my favourite friendship. Their banter was written extremely well. There was never* one iota of romantic love between them and I LOVED that. (*ignoring the first scene between them!) Whenever they were separated and found out the other was alive/unharmed you could feel the relief rolling off of them. They had gone through too much together to not have that type of friendship, that type of bond, and I'm glad Meyer wrote it into the series. Sometimes I find that a lot of YA - and adult fiction - friendships between a girl and a guy always has that sexual tension aspect and this (Cindorne? Thornder? hmm) friendship didn't and I'm super thankful about that. They are Best Friends and I want a whole book of them just like. Piloting around the system being best friends with no danger whatsoever.
Thorne scoffed. “Careful is my middle name. Right after Suave and Daring.”
“Do you even know what you're saying half the time?” asked Cinder.
The only other friendship - for me, personally - that could rival Cindorne's was Cinder and Iko. SISTERS!!!! I loved Iko and I was nervous any time she was in any danger. This isn't to say the other friendships lacked; in fact, they were all written well. They each had their own aspects as well so it made sense and wasn't just a copy/paste of another friendship. When Scarlet sees Cinder in the Lumber section and they just shout at each other and hug. Pure. Wolf and Cinder....... especially that scene with Aimery and Maha.. Heartbreaking but #real and I loved it. Kai and Cress. Cress and Jacin. WINTER AND SCARLET. Etc.
Shout-out to Kai who became a lovable, smart character throughout the series. I was hoping he would and I'm glad he didn't fall into a boring-prince-who-isn't-helpful-at-all. His quick thinking and diplomatic nature saved a lot of lives.
ANYWAY this book was so!!!!! good!!!! I'm so happy with it. And I'm sad it's over. I borrowed these from the library but I'm seriously contemplating buying them once I have some extra money because I think I'll need to reread them eventually.
Where do I start? Winter was the perfect ending to The Lunar Chronicles. I'm super sad it's over and I wouldn't be opposed to Meyer releasing more books in this universe. Please.
The title character was so great. She was the perfect amount of tragic and beautiful which made her POV compelling and fun. Her relationship with Jacin... be still my poor little heart. He was literally the world's best protector and you can Fight Me On That. (Wolf - I love him, a lot, but like... you know. I'm also scared of him.) You could literally Feel them yearning for each other and every nudge of their shoulders was like a kick in my gut. The scene by Ryu's pen....... y'all. Y'ALL :( but also <3 You know?
Cinder, my sweet brave cyborg. Even though I kept getting caught up in the stories and lives of the other character's I was still rooting for Cinder above all. She did her best and I needed to see her succeed. The short scene when she's in the lake and is just slowly accepting everything that's happening broke my heart.
Cress and her character arc was great. Someone mentions at one point "she didn't curl into Thorne like she usually did" (paraphrased) and I was like YES!!! SHE DIDNT!! YOU'RE RIGHT!! because she grew to love and trust these people and she wasn't scared to have opinions and be herself. It was truly character growth and it was incredible. When she yells at Thorne in that palace scene I was mentally cheering her on because yes, use that fire inside of you, girl. Don't... get me started on Thorne.
Just kidding.
THORNE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [pom poms, confetti, etc.] The suave, funny, sweet, criminal pilot. Would this series have been as good without him? Jury's still out.
His relationship with Cinder is my favourite friendship. Their banter was written extremely well. There was never* one iota of romantic love between them and I LOVED that. (*ignoring the first scene between them!) Whenever they were separated and found out the other was alive/unharmed you could feel the relief rolling off of them. They had gone through too much together to not have that type of friendship, that type of bond, and I'm glad Meyer wrote it into the series. Sometimes I find that a lot of YA - and adult fiction - friendships between a girl and a guy always has that sexual tension aspect and this (Cindorne? Thornder? hmm) friendship didn't and I'm super thankful about that. They are Best Friends and I want a whole book of them just like. Piloting around the system being best friends with no danger whatsoever.
Thorne scoffed. “Careful is my middle name. Right after Suave and Daring.”
“Do you even know what you're saying half the time?” asked Cinder.
The only other friendship - for me, personally - that could rival Cindorne's was Cinder and Iko. SISTERS!!!! I loved Iko and I was nervous any time she was in any danger. This isn't to say the other friendships lacked; in fact, they were all written well. They each had their own aspects as well so it made sense and wasn't just a copy/paste of another friendship. When Scarlet sees Cinder in the Lumber section and they just shout at each other and hug. Pure. Wolf and Cinder....... especially that scene with Aimery and Maha.. Heartbreaking but #real and I loved it. Kai and Cress. Cress and Jacin. WINTER AND SCARLET. Etc.
Shout-out to Kai who became a lovable, smart character throughout the series. I was hoping he would and I'm glad he didn't fall into a boring-prince-who-isn't-helpful-at-all. His quick thinking and diplomatic nature saved a lot of lives.
ANYWAY this book was so!!!!! good!!!! I'm so happy with it. And I'm sad it's over. I borrowed these from the library but I'm seriously contemplating buying them once I have some extra money because I think I'll need to reread them eventually.
I didn't like this.
There was hype around this book when it came out but I didn't pay attention to it. It seemed like another summer fling book that I didn't care about - a lesser version of a Sarah Dessen novel. I wasn't that wrong. I won't ruin it for anyone who does want to read it, but there are some things I'd like to address.
I read countless reviews that said the "ending was incredible" etc., and to be frank I didn't agree at all. Was the ending supposed to be surprising? (Sidenote: I went into this book assuming one of the Liars died. How is something supposed to be surprising when before even OPENING the book it's obvious?)
When Cadence was talking about her accident in the beginning of the book and when her mother is being very secretive about why she doesn't want her on the island... I instantly knew that Gat was dead. I operated most of the book assuming he was dead and everyone was pretending he wasn't. I assumed that Johnny and Mirren were as well once I remembered that they were also speaking to Gat and once Mirren showed her first sign of sickness. It seemed incredibly obvious to me. When the ending came, I felt nothing. I felt bad for Cadence - but also, like, arson, you know? - because to grieve multiple times like that sounds depressing and exhausting. But other than that, nothing really affected me.
Another reason I didn't enjoy this book was because I didn't like ANY of the characters. None of them. All four of the Liars annoyed me. Mirren was too loud and too bossy and it was obvious she was hiding something and I felt like she just came across badly written. Johnny was super bland to me except for when he was annoying; I felt he had no substance. At least until the scene when they're lying on the floor, he had some personality/feeling here but... no. Gat was pretentious but could've been a good character especially because he was a brown kid on this white island, but all his comments about race struck me strange. Cadence was... the rich version of manic pixie dream girl with some sadness thrown in. She could've been whatshername from Looking for Alaska. Oh her name is Alaska. Whoops. Anyway, I felt no connection to her and it's hard to enjoy a novel where I can't connect with the main character, not to mention anyone else. The aunts were all terrible people, maybe not down to their core, but from what we could see they weren't ... functional mothers. It makes sense why, but that doesn't mean I have to like them.
Last - the writing. I couldn't stand it. I used to write like that and because of that it was easy to read, but it was annoying as hell.
Unfortunately I'm not part of this book's hype machine. I think this idea/plot could've been executed a lot better than it was and I'm disappointed in it.
There was hype around this book when it came out but I didn't pay attention to it. It seemed like another summer fling book that I didn't care about - a lesser version of a Sarah Dessen novel. I wasn't that wrong. I won't ruin it for anyone who does want to read it, but there are some things I'd like to address.
I read countless reviews that said the "ending was incredible" etc., and to be frank I didn't agree at all.
When Cadence was talking about her accident in the beginning of the book and when her mother is being very secretive about why she doesn't want her on the island... I instantly knew that Gat was dead. I operated most of the book assuming he was dead and everyone was pretending he wasn't. I assumed that Johnny and Mirren were as well once I remembered that they were also speaking to Gat and once Mirren showed her first sign of sickness. It seemed incredibly obvious to me. When the ending came, I felt nothing. I felt bad for Cadence - but also, like, arson, you know? - because to grieve multiple times like that sounds depressing and exhausting. But other than that, nothing really affected me.
Another reason I didn't enjoy this book was because I didn't like ANY of the characters. None of them. All four of the Liars annoyed me. Mirren was too loud and too bossy and it was obvious she was hiding something and I felt like she just came across badly written. Johnny was super bland to me except for when he was annoying; I felt he had no substance. At least until the scene when they're lying on the floor, he had some personality/feeling here but... no. Gat was pretentious but could've been a good character especially because he was a brown kid on this white island, but all his comments about race struck me strange. Cadence was... the rich version of manic pixie dream girl with some sadness thrown in. She could've been whatshername from Looking for Alaska. Oh her name is Alaska. Whoops. Anyway, I felt no connection to her and it's hard to enjoy a novel where I can't connect with the main character, not to mention anyone else. The aunts were all terrible people, maybe not down to their core, but from what we could see they weren't ... functional mothers. It makes sense why, but that doesn't mean I have to like them.
Last - the writing. I couldn't stand it. I used to write like that and because of that it was easy to read, but it was annoying as hell.
Unfortunately I'm not part of this book's hype machine. I think this idea/plot could've been executed a lot better than it was and I'm disappointed in it.