710 reviews by:

kaylaramoutar

Filter

Demi-Gods is a coming of age novel starring Willa. At the beginning of the novel she's nine years old and it's 1950, and her family - mom, older sister, younger brother - is settling down at the beach house for the summer. This is where she meets her step-brothers for the first time. Let me say that they're not technically her step-brothers because her mom and their dad aren't married, but they're still considered a family as the boys call Willa's mom Aunt Dolly. Patrick is two years older than Willa and Kenneth is a few years older than Willa's sister, Joan.

The problem with this novel is that it's trying too hard to be edgy. It's 'edgy' to be edgy, it's not edgy because it is. Every moment of shock-value felt forced and not at all melded into the narrative. The shock-value itself was uninspiring and often quite disturbing. Shock-value doesn't have to be disturbing to be shock-value, you know? More on that later.

There was no plot to Demi-Gods. This can be completely fine within a novel if it's the novel's purpose, but this novel felt like it should've had one. I think Robertson was going for a literary novel, but I felt it fell short of the mark. The lack of quotation marks was obviously a stylistic choice, as well as a literary device in my opinion, but it, again, felt forced and unnecessary.

If this novel was about Willa, then it failed. She had become such an interesting girl and we only ever got a glimpse of her. It was the late 50s and she was in college! Tell me about her in college. Don't tell me about Patrick rubbing her nails raw. If this novel was about Willa in relation to Patrick, it still failed. The entire last chapter or so didn't feature or mention him (except once in passing about his son), and instead focused on Willa and her mother. So was the story about Willa and her mother? Her attempting to not turn into her mother? I honestly don't know, and I can't be the only one.

Every single character felt unrealistic and forced, especially Willa's mother, and eventually her sister. The only one who felt semi-real was Willa and that was when she was nine and again in the later sections for a split-second here and another one there.

Was the relationship with Patrick supposed to be sexy? Was I supposed to root for them? I didn't. His sexual attraction to her came with degradation and abuse and I found it disturbing rather than interesting. We never got any explanation as to why he was that way; the only thing we got was that he was being punished for "something to do with a dog" and that's why he was sent to the beach house when Eugene was away. Um, what? So is he a psychopath then? Was there a point of mentioning an "incident" with a dog? The only thing I can think of is that were to supposed to assume he was psychotic, but again we never got any explanation. The scene between them on the yacht with the clothesline pins... I don't know where to begin to unpack that and I don't want to. Again, it was disturbing and it made me consider DNFing this book. I pushed through because I figured there was going to be an ending, a plot-finisher, anything... nope.
And then he died and we got 25 words about it?? That's it?
WHAT was the point?!

Super quickly - the cover is misleading and far too cutesy for this novel and whoever a-okayed it didn't really think it through.


(*I got this book from the publisher through a Goodreads Giveaway*)

3.5/ I liked this book, but would've loved it if more of it was set in 1916. That's where the real story was and that's what pulled me in, so I didn't really care for the modern day parts.

God. This book destroyed me in all the right ways. I cried multiple times and I don't regret it.

Each of the three main characters were incredibly written. They all had their own personalities but you could see where their personality bled into one or both of their siblings. Their voices were distinct and clear, and they sounded like teenagers. They weren't dumbed down like some YA authors make teenagers sound and they weren't pretentious to a point where they literally don't emulate a real human teenager (J*hn Gr**n). They reacted like real people who had been through hard times and they spoke like how teenagers/young adults speak. Even though it's such a little detail it really made the novel better for me. Benway really got the feel for these characters and I think she told their story excellently.

All three of them broke my heart. Joaquin and the way he can't commit for fear of himself/the fall-out was so, so sad. I could feel the desperation in him and I was yearning for him to see that Mark and Linda just wanted him to be happy + happy with them. Me too. Grace and Peach... don't.. get me started. She was so sad but she was so brave. My brave, sweet, sad girl. Every time Adam or Max was mentioned I got white-hot angry and that scene in the mall with the siblings + them was incredible. Maya was the firecracker and I loved her. Her humour wasn't too dark to be macabre, which I think would've felt forced, and I enjoyed her nervous ramblings a lot. You could feel her love for her siblings - Lauren, too - and her need for them to love her too. Any scene with the three of them was my favourite scene. I think leading the way is the mall scene and the scene in Maya's kitchen.

Lastly, the families. I am so happy that none of them that were shown were terrible. They had problems, obviously, but they were navigating this adoption/foster situation just like the kids were. I could see why Grace was so insistent that she didn't want to be the one to ask about things, but I could also see why her parents chose to do it that way. Sometimes in YA I find that the parents are written so terribly. Yes, sometimes the parents are supposed to be the "bad guys", but other times it feels like the writing just got lazy with them. These parents had personalities that were filled with quirks and faults which made them real people. I appreciate that Benway didn't write them to be passive characters because I think the interactions between parents/kids really added to the story.

I just really loved Far From the Tree and I can't wait to check out Benway's other novels.