You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
kaylaramoutar 's review for:
We Were Liars
by E. Lockhart
I didn't like this.
There was hype around this book when it came out but I didn't pay attention to it. It seemed like another summer fling book that I didn't care about - a lesser version of a Sarah Dessen novel. I wasn't that wrong. I won't ruin it for anyone who does want to read it, but there are some things I'd like to address.
I read countless reviews that said the "ending was incredible" etc., and to be frank I didn't agree at all. Was the ending supposed to be surprising? (Sidenote: I went into this book assuming one of the Liars died. How is something supposed to be surprising when before even OPENING the book it's obvious?)
When Cadence was talking about her accident in the beginning of the book and when her mother is being very secretive about why she doesn't want her on the island... I instantly knew that Gat was dead. I operated most of the book assuming he was dead and everyone was pretending he wasn't. I assumed that Johnny and Mirren were as well once I remembered that they were also speaking to Gat and once Mirren showed her first sign of sickness. It seemed incredibly obvious to me. When the ending came, I felt nothing. I felt bad for Cadence - but also, like, arson, you know? - because to grieve multiple times like that sounds depressing and exhausting. But other than that, nothing really affected me.
Another reason I didn't enjoy this book was because I didn't like ANY of the characters. None of them. All four of the Liars annoyed me. Mirren was too loud and too bossy and it was obvious she was hiding something and I felt like she just came across badly written. Johnny was super bland to me except for when he was annoying; I felt he had no substance. At least until the scene when they're lying on the floor, he had some personality/feeling here but... no. Gat was pretentious but could've been a good character especially because he was a brown kid on this white island, but all his comments about race struck me strange. Cadence was... the rich version of manic pixie dream girl with some sadness thrown in. She could've been whatshername from Looking for Alaska. Oh her name is Alaska. Whoops. Anyway, I felt no connection to her and it's hard to enjoy a novel where I can't connect with the main character, not to mention anyone else. The aunts were all terrible people, maybe not down to their core, but from what we could see they weren't ... functional mothers. It makes sense why, but that doesn't mean I have to like them.
Last - the writing. I couldn't stand it. I used to write like that and because of that it was easy to read, but it was annoying as hell.
Unfortunately I'm not part of this book's hype machine. I think this idea/plot could've been executed a lot better than it was and I'm disappointed in it.
There was hype around this book when it came out but I didn't pay attention to it. It seemed like another summer fling book that I didn't care about - a lesser version of a Sarah Dessen novel. I wasn't that wrong. I won't ruin it for anyone who does want to read it, but there are some things I'd like to address.
I read countless reviews that said the "ending was incredible" etc., and to be frank I didn't agree at all.
When Cadence was talking about her accident in the beginning of the book and when her mother is being very secretive about why she doesn't want her on the island... I instantly knew that Gat was dead. I operated most of the book assuming he was dead and everyone was pretending he wasn't. I assumed that Johnny and Mirren were as well once I remembered that they were also speaking to Gat and once Mirren showed her first sign of sickness. It seemed incredibly obvious to me. When the ending came, I felt nothing. I felt bad for Cadence - but also, like, arson, you know? - because to grieve multiple times like that sounds depressing and exhausting. But other than that, nothing really affected me.
Another reason I didn't enjoy this book was because I didn't like ANY of the characters. None of them. All four of the Liars annoyed me. Mirren was too loud and too bossy and it was obvious she was hiding something and I felt like she just came across badly written. Johnny was super bland to me except for when he was annoying; I felt he had no substance. At least until the scene when they're lying on the floor, he had some personality/feeling here but... no. Gat was pretentious but could've been a good character especially because he was a brown kid on this white island, but all his comments about race struck me strange. Cadence was... the rich version of manic pixie dream girl with some sadness thrown in. She could've been whatshername from Looking for Alaska. Oh her name is Alaska. Whoops. Anyway, I felt no connection to her and it's hard to enjoy a novel where I can't connect with the main character, not to mention anyone else. The aunts were all terrible people, maybe not down to their core, but from what we could see they weren't ... functional mothers. It makes sense why, but that doesn't mean I have to like them.
Last - the writing. I couldn't stand it. I used to write like that and because of that it was easy to read, but it was annoying as hell.
Unfortunately I'm not part of this book's hype machine. I think this idea/plot could've been executed a lot better than it was and I'm disappointed in it.