I liked this second book in the Barchester series much better than the first book, The Warden! The characters were more developed, the writing was funnier, and the plot more fleshed out. The beginning is slow, as in most classic books, because new characters are being introduced and the setting established; but then the action kicks in and the plot moves forward more.

I loved the comic and sarcastic writing! I fell in love with Mr. Arabin and Eleanor, and I absolutely adore Mr. Harding, the dear, sweet man! I chuckled and laughed, and there might have been a small tear or two.

Love this series! I devoured this book, but it has left me a little.... upset, I guess. Emotional. This last book was just heartbreaking all through! So sad to see the Cutters struggling and hurting themselves and each other, and the sense of loss, guilt, and confusion in Tally's mind is awful to read.



The plot just got too complicated with the back and forth and never knowing who's a good guy and who's a bad guy. First they're caught, then they're free, then they're caught again, Oh no, wait actually they're still free.... maddening after awhile.



And it seems like there's never a single scene where people are happy. Is anyone ever happy in this book? Not really, no.

Still a wonderful book, and a fitting end to the Tally part of the series. (Although actually there is another one with her in it.)

Simple straight-forward spy/ murder fiction. Enjoyable, but not particularly memorable.

I adore these Aunt Dimity books! My heart gets all cozy and warm when I read one, despite by brain telling me that they aren't THAT great, just silly little fluff reads with mediocre writing and plot. I can't help it! Lori's world draws me in, and I love every character in the village of Finch. This one was especially sweet, b/c it is set at Christmas time.