You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
chrisssl 's review for:
Pastoralia
by George Saunders
dark
funny
sad
Generally, I expect a collection of short stories to not only wow on an individual story level, in that brief, compact way that only these short-form narratives can, but also impress on a collective level, with a great diversity of tone or creativity. This collection works on the first level but falters on the second. The author's writing is incredibly intentional and specific, and will floor you with a perfect oppressive, rote and occasionally hilarious style of prose that raises the story to fantastic heights. Of these, Pastoralia, Sea Oak, and The End of FIRPO In the World are the standout stories. Pastoralia is a powerful story on the numbing, euphemistic cruelty of management, and doing-the-job, in the face of harrowing personal struggles, uncaring corporate bosses and the tension of class solidarity. Sea Oak is devastating in its portrayal of sad people born into sad circumstances, unable to escape the gravity of their tragic situation and a horrifying perversion of those who pass through life and back again unthanked and unfulfilled. The End of FIRPO In The World is a wild ride in the mind of a spastic kid, the prose is just hilarious and perfectly matching that preadolescence without being overbearing, tiresome or patronizing.
On the other hand, George Saunders has a talent for richly and unreservedly describing the neuroses and invasive imaginations of maladjusted, self-absorbed old men with a lack of sexual confidence and unexamined misogyny. This is depressing but a fine enough story...once. But this same archetype is repeated in more than half of the stories and not with a great deal of variety. I don't mind the portrayal or the sadness and lack of transformation, but it feels very repetitive; and in a collection as short as this, that's definitely not a good thing.
On the other hand, George Saunders has a talent for richly and unreservedly describing the neuroses and invasive imaginations of maladjusted, self-absorbed old men with a lack of sexual confidence and unexamined misogyny. This is depressing but a fine enough story...once. But this same archetype is repeated in more than half of the stories and not with a great deal of variety. I don't mind the portrayal or the sadness and lack of transformation, but it feels very repetitive; and in a collection as short as this, that's definitely not a good thing.