328 reviews by:

birdykinsreads

Filter
challenging emotional informative sad medium-paced

FYI, I know a lot of people don’t like rating memoirs, but I see it as a rating of the narrative, book structure and writing, which the writer has packaged for consumption, not of the person or life itself. 

I’m a long time fan of Elliot Page, he’s originally from my hometown Halifax so us Haligonians definitely claim him as our hometown ⭐️—so I was highly anticipating his memoir, and while a compelling read there were definitely some things that made this book as a whole difficult to love and others that I found fascinating and couldn’t put down.

Elliot exposes so much of what goes on in the industry to placate and control queer actors in order to market them in the way the studio desires. His experiences dealing with being silenced, ignored and pushed into a box while simultaneously dealing with his own identity and sexuality struggle was so sad and obviously also so widespread. It was frustrating as a reader to watch him deal with mistreatment at every turn—his family who should love and protect him but do the opposite, the multitude of sexual assaults and harassment, vitriolic homophobia and his own self-hate and bullying. It’s a lot of trauma to read about let alone live through so I’m glad he’s found peace, now. 

My main issue with this memoir, because I found it compulsively readable for the most part, was that the narrative structure was a mess bouncing through time (he explains this away by saying it’s an untangling of his own story much like how it felt to him but it just ended up being confusing to navigate) addressing people by first names and not explaining who they were or why we should care, there’s a LOT of talking about shitting 💩 (ew why?), and the spice level was startling high—I don’t know why he felt the need to show us so graphically how much ass he gets but ok go off. There also seemed to be stories that felt unnecessary or left as half finished thoughts (blame the editor) and in the end I don’t feel I know him any better than I did before. It feels like this memoir was rushed and not as deep and self-reflective as I expected. He gives me the vibe he didn’t really know what he was writing towards either.

Good, not great
mysterious tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Ashley Audrain does it again. Pre-bookstagram I completely fell in love with her debut novel The Push which is an amazingly well done psychological thriller that I still think about. This is definitely a worthy follow up though not a compulsive read for me in the same way. I picked up and put the ebook down several times before I finally purchased a paper copy and powered through to the end. 

The Whispers follows four neighbourhood women and their different struggles and approaches to marriage and motherhood. One day a terrible incident occurs and one of their sons falls from a window and lands in intensive care. The whole book feels like the whispers, the gossip, the hunches of what we think might have happened, what goes on between closed doors, who the people we live next to actually are. It’s a domestic neighbourhood drama with a tense undercurrent and a lot of blunt depictions of the underbelly of motherhood—those who are battling with infertility, miscarriages and loss; those who struggle connecting or showing affection to their kids, maybe regret becoming a mother at all; those scared they’re replaying the sad stories of their own parents lives; those dealing with the emptiness of loss and guilt—Audrain is so powerful in her ability to once again show us how many different ways there are to be a mother, all the things we can be struggling with, how the grace we give to each other might save us in our darkest moments and just how deeply truly unknowable we are from our even our closest friends, partners, even ourselves. 

She’s such a talented writer, I find myself so drawn into her stories, they’re always so beautifully plotted. And I think everything she has to say about motherhood is true and cutting and right. 

Auto-buy author for sure.
challenging dark informative mysterious tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

This was such an interesting story. 

Millennial Lena is struggling financially after her beloved grandmother dies and she’s left as the sole caretaker for her mysteriously-ill mother when she receives a letter in the mail inviting her to partake in a paid program for clinical studies. 

Lakewood is the secret program she signs up for, there things get steadily creepier and more unsettling with each study she takes part in, almost all her fellow participants are also black and they’re being constantly watched by a team of all-white “observers” when Lena begins to lose time and her grip on what’s real and what’s not loosens. The plot thickens as Lena attempts to suss out the truth of what’s happening at Lakewood without putting her position at risk.

By the end, there’s a lot left unresolved and we aren’t entirely sure what’s happened or why even. There is so much strangeness in this book and a lot of unanswered questions which understandably might leave readers frustrated. But, I think there’s a sense of truth to that, too, if not narratively completely satisfying.

Overall, I found the commentary on the history of experimentation on black people and dehumanization of people of colour under the name of science really compelling. I don’t think I needed all the answers but I’d have liked something a little more concrete than what we got. I did really love the twist though, I did not see it coming. 

I feel like this is the same issue I had with Megan Giddings’s other book—really interesting, great ideas and intriguing hooks with slightly lacklustre execution. I really do enjoy them but they always leave me with unanswered questions, plot holes and a wish for more in the end. 

I’ll still read whatever she writes next!
challenging emotional reflective sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

This book was so beautiful and heartrending. Set in Newfoundland, The Remembering follows three generations of women (matriarch Liz, her daughters Ginny, Carlie and Eve, and Eve's daughter Rosie) over two decades as they navigate the trials and tribulations of life. 

At the start of the novel, you meet this family at such a vulnerable time—there's a content warning for this—Eve has just returned home from Mexico where she suffered a harrowing sexual assault and her mother Liz is the first and only person besides her husband to learn of this and the following pregnancy that may or may not be a result.

It is such a difficult and devastating situation that Sinnott handles with such care, and so much of the book itself is centred around this one experience, their reactions to it, and how it shapes the rest of their lives. 

How one violent act can echo for years. 

The delicate way this book handles trauma is like the deft cracking of an egg, exposing all of the love, shame, family secrets and messiness of relationships that are always right there under the surface. 

It's also about the ways in which memory can bolster or bury you, and what happens to a family when its beloved matriarch faces the endless mind-eroding disease of dementia. Sinnott does an amazing job of expressing the idea of memory and the way we are always recalibrating and reframing our own choices and experiences as we look back throughout our lives. 

I really loved the way this book moved me, I was so invested in the Wallace family and I think this is a story that really longs and deserves to be read.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark funny mysterious tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Gosh I love when a book lives up to the hype for me! I can sum this book up pretty succinctly: THE SHEER AUDACITY.

I’m sure you already have heard all about this dark horse publishing industry expose/thriller/con so I’ll just say the skill it takes to write a character so out of touch, so unbelievably frustrating, so willingly cutthroat and yet somehow still naive and incapable of holding herself even a little bit accountable while still somehow making her as compelling and addictive that you simply cannot look away, must continue, completely rapt..?!.. just wow. 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 well done.

The plot for this book—a struggling white writer steals her late Chinese-American friend’s brilliant manuscript and publishes it under a racially ambiguous pseudonym, chaos both predictable and not ensues—is just so cleanly up my alley. I’m deeply interested and invested in the dialogue around who should be able to tell a story and I am very much team #ownvoices. I think Kuang illustrates this so well in Yellowface because her MC insists anyone should be able to write any story with the right amount of research and yes, of course anyone CAN write anything, the point has always been who we give the platform to, whose voice has historically been amplified and do we really need anymore of it? And at moments in the novel she is soooo close to getting it but I love how well she misses the point because it’s exactly how so many people do react to being called out in this way. (Cough American Dirt cough) and the neverending line of people being exposed for claiming an indigenous identity and connection they do not have 🙄 it’s exhausting and like our MC, they never seem to be held accountable to a satisfactory degree. 

Fascinating darkly funny page-turner. Couldn’t put it down. 
mysterious medium-paced
Diverse cast of characters: Yes

On the one hand, I tore through this book pretty quickly once I got into it. On the other, I’m not sure I ever fully bought into the premise and I definitely didn’t love the ending.

Advika and the Hollywood Wives is about a 20-something aspiring screenwriter who meets and is charmed by an Oscar-winning producer in his 60s at the Governers Ball she’s bartending at. They fall into a quick and steamy romance that escalates to a quickie marriage after a few months when she receives word that one of his many ex-wives is willing to gift his newest “child bride” a million dollars and an unseen film roll if she files for divorce. This opens up the can of worms that is his past as she realizes the man she knows isn’t the man she married. Domestic mystery and true assery unfolds.

I enjoyed reading this book, it’s true. I thought there was a good amount of domestic tension built up and I was looking forward to unearthing the mystery. But, I feel like this was a bit squandered with the reveal being a bit out of left field and the ending just… 😒. I did not like it. Booo boooooo to the ending. 

That said, I did enjoy the reveals of each wife and the relationship they had with director/creep/asshole Julian. I thought it was a fun way to uncover his story, each being told through interviews or album notes, etc. I believed in his past but I just didn’t buy the relationship they were selling between him and Advika. She was working overtime to try and convince us he wasn’t gross-old… the author: “no he’s like hot-old, I swear.” But no. I don’t believe it for a second. Ew. This man gave me the ick from the first page, so. I just didn’t believe it for a second. 

I’m sorry but if a man asks you not to Google him on the first date, you best believe that closet is full of skeletons and also, clearly, Google him immediately you idiot.

Also the main character Advika was kind of the worst so I don’t really know why anyone wanted to help her at all. I found her a bit obtuse, willfully ignorant, overly naive and annoying. 🤷🏻‍♀️

It was a fun read I just felt it didn’t quite reach the potential of its premise and the ending felt like a bit of a fumble. Might still recommend if you’re into Hollywood drama and who the F did I just marry?! vibes.
informative reflective tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
lighthearted mysterious slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

Books and snacks and coffee and crafts club returns! This month we read Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt which I really liked but had some issues with, and the rest of bookclub was a range from a few 2 stars to lots of 3 and 4 stars. Most of us had the same issues—it was slow to get into, the characters either weren’t relatable or overly stereotypical or completely unnecessary to the story (Ethan), somehow the plot was both tied up too neatly but also left two large questions in our mind, and there was just not enough octopus for our liking. Also everyone who listened to the audiobook rated it lower than everyone who read the physical book in part maybe because the voice for the octopus was some kind of AI sounding bot. Terrible. 

Here’s what I thought:

I loooooved Marcellus the octopus’s POV. I could have read forever about him roaming the Aquarium after hours, and I found the story of him befriending and helping the aging cleaner Tova solve a family mystery really heartwarming if a little too neat plot-wise for me. An impressive and cinematic debut that moved me to tears and made me really love giant pacific octopuses. I didn’t love the male characters, I think Ethan and the forced love story between him and Tova was boring and kind of annoying, I could have done without him entirely. The other POV in the book belonged to 30 year old man child Cameron, also not a fan, but I enjoyed his character development and plot wise he was necessary, I guess. 😂

As a whole I can see why this is so beloved. I’d have liked to see more Marcellus, a shorter sharper edit, and maybe not have everything tied up in such a neat bow at the end for it to hit 5 stars for me. The writing was really lovely though. Definitely recommend.

This was such a fun world-building, con artist, fantasy trip. In Book of Night Holly Black creates a world where shadows quicken and can become magic, be convinced to do a person’s bidding, be cut and sewn to someone new. Here, people would kill to harness this magic, and others will do almost anything to understand it. 

Our story begins with Charlie Hall, maybe the greatest thief and con-artist of her time, but she’s retired and trying to make a life with her shadowless boyfriend Vince when people start turning up dead around her bar, killed in unusual ways, and she’s drawn into the search for a stolen book that might have secrets in it that very powerful people would do anything to get. I really enjoyed the mystery and the world Holly Black created here, I love a good con and Charlie is someone I enjoyed rooting for. I think the twists in this were well done, I’m just not sure I was totally convinced by the end. But, if this is a series, I’m on board for book two. 

I didn’t love the narration in this one, the voices she put on were a bit comical, so that may have been part of why it’s a 3.5 middle of the road for me.