birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

Pageboy by Elliot Page
3.5
challenging emotional informative sad medium-paced

FYI, I know a lot of people don’t like rating memoirs, but I see it as a rating of the narrative, book structure and writing, which the writer has packaged for consumption, not of the person or life itself. 

I’m a long time fan of Elliot Page, he’s originally from my hometown Halifax so us Haligonians definitely claim him as our hometown ⭐️—so I was highly anticipating his memoir, and while a compelling read there were definitely some things that made this book as a whole difficult to love and others that I found fascinating and couldn’t put down.

Elliot exposes so much of what goes on in the industry to placate and control queer actors in order to market them in the way the studio desires. His experiences dealing with being silenced, ignored and pushed into a box while simultaneously dealing with his own identity and sexuality struggle was so sad and obviously also so widespread. It was frustrating as a reader to watch him deal with mistreatment at every turn—his family who should love and protect him but do the opposite, the multitude of sexual assaults and harassment, vitriolic homophobia and his own self-hate and bullying. It’s a lot of trauma to read about let alone live through so I’m glad he’s found peace, now. 

My main issue with this memoir, because I found it compulsively readable for the most part, was that the narrative structure was a mess bouncing through time (he explains this away by saying it’s an untangling of his own story much like how it felt to him but it just ended up being confusing to navigate) addressing people by first names and not explaining who they were or why we should care, there’s a LOT of talking about shitting 💩 (ew why?), and the spice level was startling high—I don’t know why he felt the need to show us so graphically how much ass he gets but ok go off. There also seemed to be stories that felt unnecessary or left as half finished thoughts (blame the editor) and in the end I don’t feel I know him any better than I did before. It feels like this memoir was rushed and not as deep and self-reflective as I expected. He gives me the vibe he didn’t really know what he was writing towards either.

Good, not great