Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
Remarkably Bright Creatures
by Shelby Van Pelt
lighthearted
mysterious
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
Books and snacks and coffee and crafts club returns! This month we read Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt which I really liked but had some issues with, and the rest of bookclub was a range from a few 2 stars to lots of 3 and 4 stars. Most of us had the same issues—it was slow to get into, the characters either weren’t relatable or overly stereotypical or completely unnecessary to the story (Ethan), somehow the plot was both tied up too neatly but also left two large questions in our mind, and there was just not enough octopus for our liking. Also everyone who listened to the audiobook rated it lower than everyone who read the physical book in part maybe because the voice for the octopus was some kind of AI sounding bot. Terrible.
Here’s what I thought:
I loooooved Marcellus the octopus’s POV. I could have read forever about him roaming the Aquarium after hours, and I found the story of him befriending and helping the aging cleaner Tova solve a family mystery really heartwarming if a little too neat plot-wise for me. An impressive and cinematic debut that moved me to tears and made me really love giant pacific octopuses. I didn’t love the male characters, I think Ethan and the forced love story between him and Tova was boring and kind of annoying, I could have done without him entirely. The other POV in the book belonged to 30 year old man child Cameron, also not a fan, but I enjoyed his character development and plot wise he was necessary, I guess. 😂
As a whole I can see why this is so beloved. I’d have liked to see more Marcellus, a shorter sharper edit, and maybe not have everything tied up in such a neat bow at the end for it to hit 5 stars for me. The writing was really lovely though. Definitely recommend.
Here’s what I thought:
I loooooved Marcellus the octopus’s POV. I could have read forever about him roaming the Aquarium after hours, and I found the story of him befriending and helping the aging cleaner Tova solve a family mystery really heartwarming if a little too neat plot-wise for me. An impressive and cinematic debut that moved me to tears and made me really love giant pacific octopuses. I didn’t love the male characters, I think Ethan and the forced love story between him and Tova was boring and kind of annoying, I could have done without him entirely. The other POV in the book belonged to 30 year old man child Cameron, also not a fan, but I enjoyed his character development and plot wise he was necessary, I guess. 😂
As a whole I can see why this is so beloved. I’d have liked to see more Marcellus, a shorter sharper edit, and maybe not have everything tied up in such a neat bow at the end for it to hit 5 stars for me. The writing was really lovely though. Definitely recommend.