birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

A Council of Dolls by Mona Susan Power
4.0
challenging emotional slow-paced

Bookclub tackled A Council of Dolls by Mona Susan Power, and I think most of us really liked it, even if some of us felt abiding to the structure surrounding the dolls and their role in the story sometimes did it a narrative disservice. 

A Council of Dolls is a beautiful generational story of the Dakota girls in one family lineage and the dolls they had as children that helped them make sense of the trauma in their world and weather its storms. We begin with Sissy in the 1960s who with the help of her doll Ethel is coping with the unpredictable and abusive nature of her charismatic mother, we then meet her mother Lily as a girl in the 1930s and begin to understand her, from there we go to Cora in the 1890s during the “Indian Wars,” the murder of Sitting Bull and her subsequent education. 

The idea of telling this story through the experiences of the girls and their dolls is so clever, and I love how ambiguous it is—are the dolls magical or are they the product of imaginative and necessary comfort? Mona Susan Power is a beautiful writer, the first story was based on a short story she wrote and it is profound, immersive and compelling. For me, each girl’s story was emotional, touching and interesting but the end kind of summing it all up through the eyes of the dolls themselves I didn’t particularly enjoy. Though that end was the favourite part of at least one other bookclub member.

All in all, a great start to our new bookclub season and I’ll definitely be picking up some of Power’s backlist.