Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
Bright Young Women
by Jessica Knoll
slow-paced
This book left me with a bad taste in my mouth. I want to just make gagging noises but I’ll try to be more diplomatic and eloquent than that.
For a book that purports to be about reclaiming victims’ narratives and undercutting the power and admiration feeding “The Defendant” through media and true crime fascination it’s still, above all, marketing itself on the fame of Ted Bundy and profiting from it. It’s feeding into that same frenzy, purposefully, and is probably going to make a lot of money from it too. Not naming him, but making it clear who it’s meant to be, and making fun of him/revealing him for the incel he is, isn’t enough to cancel that out. So, it was kinda gross to have the main POV go on and on about the ethics of this, knowing the author is doing the same damn thing.
Bright Young Women is about Pamela, a sorority sister that witnesses the man responsible for horrific assaults and murders leave her house—a key witness in the case, she attempts to find justice despite a bumbling police force. It’s also told through the POV of Ruth, a woman who becomes a victim of his as well—and her wife Tina who tirelessly searches for answers.
It should have been easy, in a story like this, to make me feel, and keep me turning pages. But I found this just incredibly boring. I thought I would love this book but I hated it. I found the characters so hollow, so tedious, and I kept plodding along thinking something might make it worth it for over 370 pages?! It was painful, to pick this book up, I so badly wanted to DNF but I knew I had to review this—I’ve only seen good reviews so far—and I can’t write a negative review unless I suffer through the whole thing.
The writing was good, that’s the crazy thing. But everything else was not. I don’t know what Jessica Knoll was trying to do with this novel and honestly it feels like her publishing team didn’t care either, they knew it would sell.
This might end up being my least favourite read of the year, which is wild.
If you loved this book I’m sorry, don’t hate me. 😂
For a book that purports to be about reclaiming victims’ narratives and undercutting the power and admiration feeding “The Defendant” through media and true crime fascination it’s still, above all, marketing itself on the fame of Ted Bundy and profiting from it. It’s feeding into that same frenzy, purposefully, and is probably going to make a lot of money from it too. Not naming him, but making it clear who it’s meant to be, and making fun of him/revealing him for the incel he is, isn’t enough to cancel that out. So, it was kinda gross to have the main POV go on and on about the ethics of this, knowing the author is doing the same damn thing.
Bright Young Women is about Pamela, a sorority sister that witnesses the man responsible for horrific assaults and murders leave her house—a key witness in the case, she attempts to find justice despite a bumbling police force. It’s also told through the POV of Ruth, a woman who becomes a victim of his as well—and her wife Tina who tirelessly searches for answers.
It should have been easy, in a story like this, to make me feel, and keep me turning pages. But I found this just incredibly boring. I thought I would love this book but I hated it. I found the characters so hollow, so tedious, and I kept plodding along thinking something might make it worth it for over 370 pages?! It was painful, to pick this book up, I so badly wanted to DNF but I knew I had to review this—I’ve only seen good reviews so far—and I can’t write a negative review unless I suffer through the whole thing.
The writing was good, that’s the crazy thing. But everything else was not. I don’t know what Jessica Knoll was trying to do with this novel and honestly it feels like her publishing team didn’t care either, they knew it would sell.
This might end up being my least favourite read of the year, which is wild.
If you loved this book I’m sorry, don’t hate me. 😂