506 reviews by:

thoughtsfromtheafro

Filter

This was...hard. Clear, detailed, and full of some of the heartbreaking reality that lies in Syria. I cannot fathom having to adhere to a parent’s deathbed wish in a place you have loose ties to/are a generation removed from, amidst a war.

If you had a hard time reading The Beekeeper of Aleppo, this will be a much more difficult read.

Part 5 and part 6 are pretty much the only decent sections of this book.

It’s clear that Lee wrote this before TKAM, and then decided there should be a background story/context for her upbringing. What she clearly didn’t do, was update this/make it better after it.

“Jean Louise” aka adult Scout, is not how the Scout from To Kill a Mockingbird would’ve (should’ve?) grown to be. Especially as someone who has been spending a copious amount of time in New York. She’s too naive, very “I don’t see color,” and is essentially a white feminist. It likely could’ve been done in a way that added some layer of complexity, but this doesn’t. Her uncle says that it takes a certain kind of humility to live in the south (in the timeframe), but in reality, it takes a certain kind of patience.

The context and personality given to other characters (referenced and interacted with by Scout) was nice though.

This came across as a YA book to me. Somewhere around late teens. The writing is quite solid, and all of the black female characters are very dimensional, which I appreciated.

The fragility of the white woman she works for is a bit flat in a way until the last third of the book. This wasn’t as gripping of a story as I anticipated from the summary, but it’s probably better to read it than to listen.