Take a photo of a barcode or cover
506 reviews by:
thoughtsfromtheafro
I came across this book randomly on Libby/Overdrive and was so intrigued by the summary. Somehow, the summary was better than the book.
It isn’t gripping at all. I essentially had my eyebrows scrunched the whole time. And though it’s written as the main character reflecting on what he went through as an adolescent slave who was purchased as a slave from Barbados and taken to the Arctic, it has so much missing. There’s also an element of white savior behavior and naïveté, which would have come across better if it weren’t for the oddly formatted dynamic between Wash and Wilde.
It isn’t gripping at all. I essentially had my eyebrows scrunched the whole time. And though it’s written as the main character reflecting on what he went through as an adolescent slave who was purchased as a slave from Barbados and taken to the Arctic, it has so much missing. There’s also an element of white savior behavior and naïveté, which would have come across better if it weren’t for the oddly formatted dynamic between Wash and Wilde.
I wanted to love this. I really did. If for no reason other than Coates being the author.
This just didn’t do it for me. At all. It was hard for me to find the desire to keep reading. Somewhere after about 1/6 of the book, I just continued to get more disinterested.
I did, however, love Joe Morton as the narrator (and singer).
This just didn’t do it for me. At all. It was hard for me to find the desire to keep reading. Somewhere after about 1/6 of the book, I just continued to get more disinterested.
I did, however, love Joe Morton as the narrator (and singer).
The content was an immense letdown and I had to push myself to finish it. And to top it all off, the narrator’s voice is not a good fit for the content.
The author starts her memoir jumping right into stories –giving no background about herself or life context. She does a better job of describing other people’s lives/context around reporting (which is most of it) than she does talking about her career. With very few exceptions, doesn’t include herself in the “we” when talking about Black and POC experiences in journalism overall. She occasionally does it when talking about her and other Black journalists at whatever paper at which she’s working in that point in time. She also uses “Blacks;” it could be argued that it’s a sign of her generation, but there ain’t an elder alive or dead that I’ve known that has referred to us as “Blacks.”
Her experience with/at NABJ at the very end was the most interesting of it all, and I very much appreciate and respect her desire to invest in future journalists.
The author starts her memoir jumping right into stories –giving no background about herself or life context. She does a better job of describing other people’s lives/context around reporting (which is most of it) than she does talking about her career. With very few exceptions, doesn’t include herself in the “we” when talking about Black and POC experiences in journalism overall. She occasionally does it when talking about her and other Black journalists at whatever paper at which she’s working in that point in time. She also uses “Blacks;” it could be argued that it’s a sign of her generation, but there ain’t an elder alive or dead that I’ve known that has referred to us as “Blacks.”
Her experience with/at NABJ at the very end was the most interesting of it all, and I very much appreciate and respect her desire to invest in future journalists.
There’s so much to this, and I loved it. It was a wonderful read for Ramadan.
A seamless weaving of personal narrative, cultural differences (American vs. Pakistani, Pakistani-American vs. Pakistani), family dynamics, different layers of community, interactions with other “People of The Book,” etc...all without coming across political.
A seamless weaving of personal narrative, cultural differences (American vs. Pakistani, Pakistani-American vs. Pakistani), family dynamics, different layers of community, interactions with other “People of The Book,” etc...all without coming across political.
Reading this is a different type of gut punch when you think about the fact that immigrants still (and especially so in this time of coronavirus) are still toiling fields to produce crops for greater society. Going unnoticed, undervalued, unserved, and unappreciated.
This is an amazing book that could easily be used to introduce the following topics to children: poverty, immigration, the importance of a living wage, labor unions, quality of life, medical care disparity, classism, and work ethic.
The last line of the book is powerful in so many ways. I now understand why when I told people I was reading this, raved about how much they loved it when they read it years ago.
This is an amazing book that could easily be used to introduce the following topics to children: poverty, immigration, the importance of a living wage, labor unions, quality of life, medical care disparity, classism, and work ethic.
The last line of the book is powerful in so many ways. I now understand why when I told people I was reading this, raved about how much they loved it when they read it years ago.