Ever read a plot hole so small but it's all you can think about? And after hearing what the author meant for this book, I don't think it hit the target. It should've focused on Zeke. And I really don't think the title works for the book.

I'm biased because I'm obsessed with this series. This book was just as fun as the others, and the mystery was exactly what I wanted. Great pacing and great characters. This book just made me so happy.

This book was great. I loved that the main character felt young. She didn't come off as an adult writing a child. The cringe was so relatable.

I don't know how to recover from this. I'm truly obsessed with this series. I felt it did get a little slow, but the mystery and the details were so good. I could live in this world forever.

This was so good! The twists and turns, the creepiness, the writing! I couldn't stop reading! I hope there's more to this series.

I'm so amazed that I enjoyed this just as much as the first. Usually the 2nd book is so weak, but I didn't find this weak at all. I did find it slow in parts, but my love for the characters and world only grew. I could live in these books forever.

I loved the writing of this book, the mental health rep, the mystery, and the characters. Some of the red herrings got a bit much, but everything else was lovely.

Loads of great stories. I'm really surprised I really liked most of them and none were less than a 4. Some even made me cry.

Great world and magic system, but it did drag in the middle. Still worth a read though.

This book was really cute but not really for me. I didn't love the characters. They were charming and likeable, but not my cup of tea. Fun plot too.