HEARTWRENCHING. and that ending.......i needed more closure!!!!! im just so in love with the characters. im so sad to see this story come to an end and i will miss the characters, whether i have been with them for all 7 books or for just a few, SO much.

A whimsical, unique, suspenseful, romantic, and beautifully woven story that i wish i could experience for the first time again. It can be confusing at times, but when all the pieces fall together, it is truly magical.

Cute, thought-provoking, but also very sad at some points. I liked the ending, even though normally when books end the way this one did, I don't like it.

I don’t really know what to say. It was pretty good, but the writing wasnt my favorite and neither was the ending.

A lot sadder than I thought it would be. The relationship also didn't progress as much as I wanted it to, so I'm excited to pick up the sequel(s).

it was pretty good. there’s really not much to say. its not dark and emotional, but not exactly light and fluffy. i didn’t think it was very realistic, but it still wasn’t bad. i think it would be impossible for e. lockhart to write a completely bad book.

not perfect, but pretty close. i cannot believe it has taken me so long to read a huntley fitzpatrick novel. i was not a fan of the plot twist, however. i truly loved this book. it gave me all the butterflies, and cass is so swoon worthy.

1st reread (2nd read): why was this book so SAD??