You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
710 reviews by:
kaylaramoutar
Nothing happened in this book until maybe 3/4 in and even then it was still a slow drag to the end. The ending is, of course, a breath instead of a period - ie, a cliffhanger - meaning I will be picking up the next book because nothing was Really resolved, and since I've read two books I might as well read the third. We got one teeny answer about the mystery and if I'm being honest, it wasn't shocking or interesting. In fact I found it slightly boring. I don't really connect with any of the characters on a personal level and that always makes it hard for me to enjoy a novel thoroughly.
What.
What.
This book hurt my brain but in a super good way. I had absolutely no idea what was going on for most of the novel (read: all of it? Whom knows.) but I loved that? Not to Toot My Own Horn but I figure out plots/twists pretty easily sometimes (a curse) but in AMERICAN ELSEWHERE... I had no idea. I mean, obviously there are hints and I knew what way it was going, but when we got there it was still like... what!! WHAT!! It was good.
Keeping this book from a 5 star rating is the fact that it genuinely did not need to be this long. There were a few scenes that I felt could have been cut simply because something very similar had already happened. RJB's writing was gorgeous though and I sincerely look forward to diving into his other books.
ALSO MONA IS A BADASS AND I LOVE HER.
(Fun little tidbit: about 30 pages of my book was reprinted. As in, at page 442/443 Chapter Thirty-Six is there. Except... I had already read Chapter Thirty-Six on page 411. And its WORD FOR WORD the same. So I thought, hmm maybe this is a stylistic choice because of the subject matter? Except no, because the page numbers regressed. So I was on page 442 and then suddenly 411. What? Anyway so I skimmed it to make sure it was literally all the same and then when I got to page 442 (again) it just... kept going. Properly. Both in words/plot/page numbers. It was VERY confusing to my brain which was already working on overdrive trying to figure this book out.)
What.
This book hurt my brain but in a super good way. I had absolutely no idea what was going on for most of the novel (read: all of it? Whom knows.) but I loved that? Not to Toot My Own Horn but I figure out plots/twists pretty easily sometimes (a curse) but in AMERICAN ELSEWHERE... I had no idea. I mean, obviously there are hints and I knew what way it was going, but when we got there it was still like... what!! WHAT!! It was good.
Keeping this book from a 5 star rating is the fact that it genuinely did not need to be this long. There were a few scenes that I felt could have been cut simply because something very similar had already happened. RJB's writing was gorgeous though and I sincerely look forward to diving into his other books.
ALSO MONA IS A BADASS AND I LOVE HER.
(Fun little tidbit: about 30 pages of my book was reprinted. As in, at page 442/443 Chapter Thirty-Six is there. Except... I had already read Chapter Thirty-Six on page 411. And its WORD FOR WORD the same. So I thought, hmm maybe this is a stylistic choice because of the subject matter? Except no, because the page numbers regressed. So I was on page 442 and then suddenly 411. What? Anyway so I skimmed it to make sure it was literally all the same and then when I got to page 442 (again) it just... kept going. Properly. Both in words/plot/page numbers. It was VERY confusing to my brain which was already working on overdrive trying to figure this book out.)
2.5
The thing about this book is that it touches on a lot of "issues" but never dives deeper into them, and that missing nuance is what makes it lack, to be honest, a point. I know the Point is supposed to be the mystery of Alice and Jack Munro, but honestly it's quite obvious from the beginning what happened to the Munro's. I think the book would have been much better if even one of the issues had been fleshed out more.
The main character, Sophie, is... not Moriarty's best MC. She's bratty and super into herself to a point where it's not endearing, and just when she gets close enough to being endearing she says something terrible or the chapter switches POV and you lose the connection to her.
I would have been much happier if this book had nothing to do with the mystery and instead focused on Grace's life post-partum. I think her story was the most interesting and I would have loved to see her interactions with more of her family, especially her mother and Rose. I think a book about her and her post-partum depression (and maybe sometime in the background finding out the truth about the Munro baby) would have had that nuance and integrity that this book lacked.
The thing about this book is that it touches on a lot of "issues" but never dives deeper into them, and that missing nuance is what makes it lack, to be honest, a point. I know the Point is supposed to be the mystery of Alice and Jack Munro, but honestly it's quite obvious from the beginning what happened to the Munro's. I think the book would have been much better if even one of the issues had been fleshed out more.
The main character, Sophie, is... not Moriarty's best MC. She's bratty and super into herself to a point where it's not endearing, and just when she gets close enough to being endearing she says something terrible or the chapter switches POV and you lose the connection to her.
I would have been much happier if this book had nothing to do with the mystery and instead focused on Grace's life post-partum. I think her story was the most interesting and I would have loved to see her interactions with more of her family, especially her mother and Rose. I think a book about her and her post-partum depression (and maybe sometime in the background finding out the truth about the Munro baby) would have had that nuance and integrity that this book lacked.
I know I say this a lot, but I enjoyed this more than my rating suggests. I liked it more around a 4. But looking at it as a novel and taking my feelings out of it, it's more of a 2.5/3.
I think the biggest problem with ROMANOV is that it is neither entirely historical accurate or fantasy-driven. It tries to be both and unfortunately I think that Brandes missed that sweet spot. I know a little about the Romanov's and their downfall, but not much about their reign (I will eventually get to it but I want to find the Perfect book, you know?). So some of the information that we're given in passing is lacking; the book assumes readers know more about the history well and for people that don't I think that it's hard to understand the stakes. I think this could have been solved by starting the novel in a different place, but again - I don't know the history in-depth but that's my feeling.
What I loved about this book was that it wasn't about the history, really. Or the fantasy aspect. It was about love and kindness. The relationship between Nastya and her family were written very well; I believed it. A decent chunk of the novel Nastya thinks about romance, but it doesn't really rear its head much. I liked that, I think the love between Nastya and her family, and the love that Tsar had for his people, were the better story and I'm glad Brandes focused more on that. That being said, I didn't mind Zash... but that romance was laughable to me. I'm sorry. I wished I had liked it more because I loved Nastya and Zash had potential.
I think that if you go into this book expecting a good, solid historical fiction... you'll be disappointed. Same with if you go in thinking it's superior magical realism. I think if you're looking for something quick that has a little bit of this (historical fiction) and a little bit of that (magical realism), then this might be for you, but don't expect it to knock your socks off.
(I received a complimentary copy of this book from Thomas Nelson through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
I think the biggest problem with ROMANOV is that it is neither entirely historical accurate or fantasy-driven. It tries to be both and unfortunately I think that Brandes missed that sweet spot. I know a little about the Romanov's and their downfall, but not much about their reign (I will eventually get to it but I want to find the Perfect book, you know?). So some of the information that we're given in passing is lacking; the book assumes readers know more about the history well and for people that don't I think that it's hard to understand the stakes. I think this could have been solved by starting the novel in a different place, but again - I don't know the history in-depth but that's my feeling.
What I loved about this book was that it wasn't about the history, really. Or the fantasy aspect. It was about love and kindness. The relationship between Nastya and her family were written very well; I believed it. A decent chunk of the novel Nastya thinks about romance, but it doesn't really rear its head much. I liked that, I think the love between Nastya and her family, and the love that Tsar had for his people, were the better story and I'm glad Brandes focused more on that. That being said, I didn't mind Zash... but that romance was laughable to me. I'm sorry. I wished I had liked it more because I loved Nastya and Zash had potential.
I think that if you go into this book expecting a good, solid historical fiction... you'll be disappointed. Same with if you go in thinking it's superior magical realism. I think if you're looking for something quick that has a little bit of this (historical fiction) and a little bit of that (magical realism), then this might be for you, but don't expect it to knock your socks off.
(I received a complimentary copy of this book from Thomas Nelson through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
History, huh?
Image: me, fetal position, crying about how much I loved this book. I am basically the crying emoji with heart eyes.
Hello, world, please write more books like this. I will eat each and every one of them up as fast as I can.
A quick summary of the plot before we get to My Feelings™: First Son of the United States of America, a biracial young man named Alex is not a fan of His Royal Highness Prince Henry of Wales and he is not a fan of Alex. It's mutual, they've basically discussed it. Alex and Henry get into a little spat at Henry's brother's wedding and suddenly there's a transatlantic scandal. They're sent to do damage control AKA pretend to be BFFs who got into a friendly "homoerotic frat boy mishap" - and they do, because they were raised by their countries. At first it's a boring, Why-Do-I-Have-to-Do-This? and I-Really-Hate-This engagement, but somewhere along the way it becomes apparent that Alex and Henry have things in common, and they're friends, and they talk all the time, and oh shit we like each other? Classic trope of enemies to lovers, says you. GIVE ME THIS TROPE UNTIL THE DAY I DIE, says I.
My Feelings™: [me, clutching this book, weeping] It's just that these feelings, these boys, feel so real. I don't know how Casey McQuiston manifested these boys into physical Beings but somehow she did. They are real, they are fleshed out. They are FLAWED. They are everything I ever want in a character. And it's not just Alex and Henry who are full bodied humans. The entirety of The Super Six were all A+'s. There was no weak link! I saw another blogger say that she would read a standalone/solo book of each of them, and um, yes, please.
McQuiston did an incredible job of navigating the underlying issues in the book (sexuality, race, class, and gender and how they are affected when there's two of them, ie: being a gay prince [sexuality and class]) and I commend her for it. It all felt so goddamn authentic. Alex's musings over his bisexuality and how it had always been apart of him, just like him being biracial, felt so real and, just, god. Heartbreaking and uplifting all in one.
I'm really a mess over this book. So here's a list of some other things I loved.
- Alex and Henry's banter. To be quite honest, everyone's banter with everyone. It was fun, and funny, and I don't care if that's not how people speak in real life because it made me smile.
- ZAHRA. A queen.
- The aforementioned Super Six. Pez! Nora! JUNE!!! Bea! Gosh. Give me a whole novel of The Super Six on a cruise ship or backpacking vacation! Anything! I want it!!!
- The amount of (queer) history and literature included in the emails. So interesting, and such a good way to have their emails have substance instead of just lame "I Miss You" texts that you see in some contemporary novels.
- The speeches nearing the end? Especially Alex's? Cry-fest city.
- A President who is competent, and who seems like someone who actually cares and loves her country and ALL of its people.
(- This quote:
"'Nah. Come on. I don't think this election is gonna hinge on an email server.'
Alex arches a brow. 'You sure about that?'" [upside down smiley emoji])
Please read this book when it comes out. And please shower Casey McQuiston in compliments and adoration because I need her to keep writing.
Big thanks to St Martin's Press for sending me an ARC!!