You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

kaylaramoutar's profile picture

kaylaramoutar 's review for:

American Elsewhere by Robert Jackson Bennett
4.0

What.

What.

This book hurt my brain but in a super good way. I had absolutely no idea what was going on for most of the novel (read: all of it? Whom knows.) but I loved that? Not to Toot My Own Horn but I figure out plots/twists pretty easily sometimes (a curse) but in AMERICAN ELSEWHERE... I had no idea. I mean, obviously there are hints and I knew what way it was going, but when we got there it was still like... what!! WHAT!! It was good.

Keeping this book from a 5 star rating is the fact that it genuinely did not need to be this long. There were a few scenes that I felt could have been cut simply because something very similar had already happened. RJB's writing was gorgeous though and I sincerely look forward to diving into his other books.

ALSO MONA IS A BADASS AND I LOVE HER.


(Fun little tidbit: about 30 pages of my book was reprinted. As in, at page 442/443 Chapter Thirty-Six is there. Except... I had already read Chapter Thirty-Six on page 411. And its WORD FOR WORD the same. So I thought, hmm maybe this is a stylistic choice because of the subject matter? Except no, because the page numbers regressed. So I was on page 442 and then suddenly 411. What? Anyway so I skimmed it to make sure it was literally all the same and then when I got to page 442 (again) it just... kept going. Properly. Both in words/plot/page numbers. It was VERY confusing to my brain which was already working on overdrive trying to figure this book out.)