Take a photo of a barcode or cover
710 reviews by:
kaylaramoutar
3.9
I liked this more than the first one but I still can't get over the hump of the Avery/Atlas thing. It was more manageable in this novel because of what happens, but it's still a no from me.
The good: I enjoyed the POVs a lot. It seems as though the characters have grown up since the first book despite it being only a few months(? weeks? not sure) later. I enjoyed Leda's POV which surprised me, all things considered. Watt and Rylin were good as well and I liked seeing into their lives a bit more, re: Cynthia/college for Watt and Cord/Rylin's other friends for Rylin.
The bad: Avery. Girl... I can't do this. Things happened that allowed me to - for lack of a better word - stomach the relationship with Atlas. Avery's chapters that didn't feature Atlas (in person) were A LOT better than the ones that did - in the beginning. By the end I didn't care if he was in the chapter because I was interested to see what happened between them. #angst Avery's chapters also allowed a little bit of insight into Cord which I liked.
The ???: Calliope. I have no idea how I feel about this girl except for the fact I was rooting for her and Atlas for obvious reasons.
The great: character's talking! Character's sharing information!!!! yes!!!! That's what I LOVE to see. It makes me really excited for the next book because there's an alliance and that always makes books better.
Also:Can we stop with the Bury Your Gays trope now.... thanks.
I liked this more than the first one but I still can't get over the hump of the Avery/Atlas thing. It was more manageable in this novel because of what happens, but it's still a no from me.
The good: I enjoyed the POVs a lot. It seems as though the characters have grown up since the first book despite it being only a few months(? weeks? not sure) later. I enjoyed Leda's POV which surprised me, all things considered. Watt and Rylin were good as well and I liked seeing into their lives a bit more, re: Cynthia/college for Watt and Cord/Rylin's other friends for Rylin.
The bad: Avery. Girl... I can't do this. Things happened that allowed me to - for lack of a better word - stomach the relationship with Atlas. Avery's chapters that didn't feature Atlas (in person) were A LOT better than the ones that did - in the beginning. By the end I didn't care if he was in the chapter because I was interested to see what happened between them. #angst Avery's chapters also allowed a little bit of insight into Cord which I liked.
The ???: Calliope. I have no idea how I feel about this girl except for the fact I was rooting for her and Atlas for obvious reasons.
The great: character's talking! Character's sharing information!!!! yes!!!! That's what I LOVE to see. It makes me really excited for the next book because there's an alliance and that always makes books better.
Also:
I have never been so angry while reading a book. The Nowhere Girls is hard to read, but important to read. I had some issues with it, but I think overall it's still a novel that deserves to be read.
The Afterlife of Holly Chase was a fantastic 'retelling' of A Christmas Carol. It was light and surprisingly quite heavy all at the same time. Holly was such a likeable unlikable-character that I found myself drawn to her and rooting for her. There was one twist that I saw coming, but others that surprised me. Hand's writing was good; it sounded like a seventeen year old girl talking. It didn't sound too young, but it had the delightful sound of being a teenage girl who sees a cute guy. I actually really enjoyed the ending. Usually I don't enjoy endings because 1) I don't want it to end, 2) it's rushed, or 3) it's not a satisfactory ending. The ending to this novel wasn't rushed, it was good, and it felt like the right place to end it. A good novel to kick your holiday butt into gear - aka, go do something kind for someone!
Turtles All the Way Down was hard to rate. At the beginning of writing this review I have no idea what the star-rating will turn out to be.
I'm trying not to be overly cynical about this, but part of me feels as though Green wrote this novel, but mostly Aza, to have an "excuse" as to why his teenagers sound so pretentious. That's all I could think about in the first couple pages when Aza is talking in the cafeteria.
Green wrote Aza's mental illness well, I thought. He had a good grip on how your thoughts can spiral out of control even if half your brain knows what's going on. I think overall Aza was an okay character. She wasn't written the best - there were multiple times she did something out of character (ooc) and it was jarring. I don't think it was on purpose. There were times where she was in her head, and times where she was "living her life", which is great. He showed that she wasn't just her illness. But there were times she'd say something and it felt like she was being possessed by some new character. I just feel like the novel could have done with some more editing.
I also wish that the novel had just been about Aza. I didn't give a single shit about the missing billionaire. I wish this novel had just been a book about Aza and how she was dealing with her mental illness. We don't have enough introspective novels in YA and this could have been one.
I don't really know what else to say about this. I didn't dislike it, but I also didn't...like it? It fell somewhere in the middle.
2.7-3
Paper Towns continues to be the superior John Green novel.
I'm trying not to be overly cynical about this, but part of me feels as though Green wrote this novel, but mostly Aza, to have an "excuse" as to why his teenagers sound so pretentious. That's all I could think about in the first couple pages when Aza is talking in the cafeteria.
Green wrote Aza's mental illness well, I thought. He had a good grip on how your thoughts can spiral out of control even if half your brain knows what's going on. I think overall Aza was an okay character. She wasn't written the best - there were multiple times she did something out of character (ooc) and it was jarring. I don't think it was on purpose. There were times where she was in her head, and times where she was "living her life", which is great. He showed that she wasn't just her illness. But there were times she'd say something and it felt like she was being possessed by some new character. I just feel like the novel could have done with some more editing.
I also wish that the novel had just been about Aza. I didn't give a single shit about the missing billionaire. I wish this novel had just been a book about Aza and how she was dealing with her mental illness. We don't have enough introspective novels in YA and this could have been one.
I don't really know what else to say about this. I didn't dislike it, but I also didn't...like it? It fell somewhere in the middle.
2.7-3
Paper Towns continues to be the superior John Green novel.
3.5
I enjoyed I'll Give You the Sun more than I thought I would but it still fell short of the mark for me. The style it was written in - especially Noah's sections - was too much for me. I think if it had been a little less metaphorical I would have enjoyed it more. I really enjoyed the story line, even if the ~reveal~ was a bit obvious to me, and I really liked Jude.
I wish I could have rated this higher but Noah's section really took me out of the story instead of bringing me in, which is what I think it was supposed to do.
I enjoyed I'll Give You the Sun more than I thought I would but it still fell short of the mark for me. The style it was written in - especially Noah's sections - was too much for me. I think if it had been a little less metaphorical I would have enjoyed it more. I really enjoyed the story line, even if the ~reveal~ was a bit obvious to me, and I really liked Jude.
I wish I could have rated this higher but Noah's section really took me out of the story instead of bringing me in, which is what I think it was supposed to do.