710 reviews by:

kaylaramoutar

Filter

Better than the first one but not by much. Where's the action I was promised? Sure, there's a bit here and a bit there, but it's not as... murder-y as it should be for such a dark plot.

Also I love how most readers hated [redacted] and didn't even care when that person died... Same though.

This was supposed to be a duology. I'm torn on my feelings about hearing that it's being extended to four books. On one hand, I'm excited because maybe Blake will take the criticism from the first two books and ensure that the last two will be better. On the other hand, the ending was ... alright enough to have left it at two. There was somewhat of a cliffhanger but it could've been left alone. I for sure have a lot of questions though, so we'll see if Blake answers them in the upcoming novels.

3.5

This book is very relatable. Elise's life in elementary and middle school was my life in elementary and middle school. I thankfully didn't go to high school with the people I grew up with, because if I did I might've found this book even MORE relatable.

Like Elise, I also found solace in music. It wasn't an underground club but it was music. I found people there who were kind and friendly, and who had the same hobbies and likes/dislikes as me. I don't know if I would say that music saved my life - there is at least an album or two specifically that might've helped, though - but I liked that it was so helpful to Elise.

Book stuff: I really enjoyed Elise's characterization. At first I found her somewhat annoying but once I got to know her I realized she was just.... me. And every other girl who wasn't the popular one, you know? I liked her relationship with her siblings, especially Alex, and I like that her parents weren't made out to be "bad guys". Vicky was pretty great too. Char was dumb from the beginning but I feel like we weren't supposed to be duped by him, so it worked.

For a quick read with some #real issues (and talent! Btw I loved Mel) this was an enjoyable book.


I LOVED this!! It was so much fun. The main characters were really complex, more than usual for a YA novel I found, and I really liked where they all ended up at the end. To call this a "retelling of the Breakfast Club" is to diminish the story. Their detention lasts all, what, one chapter? Through multiple POVs? The rest of the story is how they have to beat the clock to unravel the mystery surrounding Simon's death before their own li(v)es unravel first.

This review is far more eloquent and touches on everything I liked and disliked if you want more in-depth thoughts.