710 reviews by:

kaylaramoutar

Filter

4.5 stars for Darcy's story - as someone in The Publishing Industry (do I owe Nisha a dollar?) it was fun to read about Darcy's entrance into the world. There were parts where I said "yep, true, that would happen" and other times I knew it was over-exaggerated. But I thought that was fun! A lot of reviews/reviewers were really upset about it, apparently because they were expecting something more of an Inkeart esq story. Afterworlds is nothing like Inkheart. And that's okay! It's two stories in one (Darcy's and the book she wrote), whereas Inkeart's is one big story. I also saw a reviewer say that "Darcy Patel is pretty white American despite the name and being brown/Indian" (paraphrased). First off - if she was born in America (she was), she's ~American. Second: what makes her "white"? I saw nothing that was ""inherently white"" that she liked. She just wasn't ~stereotypically brown~ and that bothered people. As a non-white person who's been told she isn't "brown" enough (or "white" enough), that's an annoying, and frankly lazy, review. Anyway!!!!

3.5 stars for Lizzie's story - I don't know if this was on purpose from Westerfeld but Lizzie's story was not super great. It was either because A) it was hard to fit two well rounded novels within in, or B) he wrote it like that because it was Darcy's first (published) novel and it wasn't going to be perfect. I tend to lean towards B because her agent/publisher (can't remember, soz) tells her near the end of her novel that this won't be her best book or her "most polished" writing, and that's okay. Agreed. I think if Westerfeld had written Lizzie's story as it's own novel from him, it would be a lot better because he's a great author.

So overall: 4 stars. If you're going into this hoping and looking for a great literary feat you're going to be disappointed. But if you're looking for a fun, well-written, satirical-at-times read, then this is for you.

I think it's time to reread the Uglies series!