505 reviews by:

illustrated_librarian

Filter
funny hopeful reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Where do the weird girlies from the sad-girl trauma-plot books all end up, do you reckon? Well, maybe it's where Sylvie is: living a small life in a seaside town with her little brain-damaged dog, Curtains. She's sort of unconvinced she's a real person, unsure how to be in the world, and another small thing: she's devastatingly obsessed with her therapist. 

You know what, this really grew on me. I was expecting something more out-and-out weird, which given the therapist obsession premise I wasn't sure I'd like, but what unfolded was a strangely sweet, offbeat story about longing and attachment. 

Through her therapy sessions we gradually learn that Sylvie's been through some things, a coercively controlling relationship among them. Her past is handled lightly though, not a weighty presence in the story but rather simple facts of her life that occasionally surface. Sylvie's narrative voice is quite child-like, and Faith's direct, crisp style belies the emotional complexity of her story. Her musings on how much she adores the therapist can err towards whimsy, but they're always grounded in how much she wants to feel happy, loved, and cared for by someone she sees as safe and, importantly, a proper person. 

I was unexpectedly touched by her observations on not feeling part of the real world, proceeding like an actor without really connecting to what she does. It hits on how trauma, especially relationships where your entire existence is controlled, can empty us out, leaving a husk that needs to gradually regrow into a person with their own desires and opinions. 

By the third part the therapist adoration does start to get a little repetitive, and the lack of central strife driving things forward might not appeal to some. This feels more like an aftermath; it's gentle and vibes-based, very much rooted in the mundane. Still, it speaks to contemporary anxieties around attachment and the commodification of care in our lonely societies in a quirky, heartfelt way. 

Thank you to 4th Estate for my gifted proof! 
emotional hopeful reflective sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

Something happened to Mary Lohan. Twenty years ago she fled her Buenos Aires suburb never, she thought, to return. She's got different hair now, different coloured eyes, even a different voice. But as she sets out from Boston, the place she's headed to is the same one from all those years ago. Fate has intervened to bring her past and present together. Fate, or maybe a little luck. 

Mary's story revolves around a central incident. Or was it an accident. Or maybe simply: a tragedy. 

The beginning builds slowly, establishing her deep emotional pain and resignation to it. The way the reveal is worked into the text, gradually fleshed out between present chapters until a full, harrowing picture emerges, had me fixed in place and speaks to Piñero's background in crime fiction. What follows is a journey through guilt, regret, and judgement, but with a kernal of hope. Mary is alone, she's made an impossible choice, but she survived. She has only a little luck: not the lottery-winning, flashy kind, but the sort that crosses her path with that of kind strangers. 

There's a brilliantly conceived thread of redemption and healing through storytelling running alongside the central theme of fate, luck, or lack of it. Robert, one of her kind strangers, presses into Mary's hands writers who know humanity and pain — Alice Munro, Simone de Beauvoir, Tennessee Williams — and allow her a safe space to see her own reflected. But also to see that articulating her story isn't the same as dodging blame or even asking for forgiveness, it's a way to excise the rot, to stop living under the heel of one decision. 

Mary asks: 

'Do I deserve to explain why? What I mean is do I have that right? The right to unburden myself and expect someone to listen?' and the truth is that yes, she does. Her tale is heartrending, one of bad luck or bad decisions, of the ripples one action can have, and how a person can never be defined by one moment when moments are built on so much more. 

This is a beautifully written story of a woman damaged, but not beyond repair, and never beyond kindness. A woman damaged, but not destroyed.
challenging dark mysterious slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

A boy comes of age in a remote Catalan village, high in the mountains and cut off from the outside world. Blindly following their strange rituals, any dissent swiftly quashed, the villagers exist in a dark and dream-like world. Following his father's death, the boy must learn to navigate life here alone. 

Rodoreda wrote this book in exile, having fled Franco's Spain, and it's seen as an allegory for life under dictatorship. I'd suggest more specifically: the erosion of empathy under such a regime. 

Under Franco the language she spoke and wrote in, Catalan, was effectively suppressed from the public sphere, relegated to privacy and secrecy. The experience of this alienation, the suppression of language and therefore a route to express and create personal realities, feeds into the uncanny world Rodoreda creates here. 

The experience of reading this is profoundly strange and unsettling. Lush details of spring imagery — bees, a river, trees, wisteria — become lurid and alien through their repetition. They reoccur throughout the text like symbols but meaning slips away, what should feel concrete becoming divorced from reality. The narrative tone is dry and factual even as it relays bursts of cruel violence: villagers decomposing in trees, dying people being filled with cement to stop their souls escaping, prisoners descending into animals, faceless men roaming the streets. 

The overall experience is of an inescapable bad dream you almost understand — if you've read Supplication, or Untold Night and Day, you might know what I mean. Personally, I feel like it doesn't need to be understood on a line-by-line level (though there are some beautiful sentences), but rather felt, like poetry.
mysterious reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

A cataclysm split the city of Fairharbour into two mirrored versions — one in perpetual winter, one in eternal summer, both now under the sway of oppressive powers. Cousins Esther and Jamie Pike are stuck on either side, presuming the other lost, until they find a way to glimpse each others' realities. Finding ways to communicate across the divide, they try to solve what split their city and what, if anything, can unite it again. 

This is an imaginative, contemplative read that slowly gathers steam as it builds its dual perspectives up. It did take me a while to sink into but the writing is lovely — smooth and slightly melancholy — and the central mystery kept me engaged throughout. 

It's described as science-fantasy, but I think it'll appeal to speculative fiction readers most as it's definitely vibes over detailed magic systems or science elements. The story asks you to take quite a few leaps of faith where plot and magic are concerned, but for the most part I was happy to buy in and see where it took me. 

The worldbuilding is still rich and atmospheric, with the authors exploring how the season-bound cities have gradually shaped their inhabitants as well as the shadow cast by Fairharbour's history before the split. I did think the past was leaned on a little too heavily as this came at the expense of developing Jamie and Esther more fully as characters, but the constantly unfolding worldbuilding made the city a character of its own. 

It's ultimately a story about resilience, connection, and understanding. Langmead and Whitely have also worked in a through-thread about making and creating for its own sake that I thought was so beautiful. Several of the central characters communicate in various ways through their art, and there's a subtle exploration of how you lose control of meaning when you put art into the world. But, meaning you hadn't known was held there can be found too, because looking at something another person has wrought might be the closest you can come to understanding them.

Thank you to Titan Books for sending me an ARC of this! 
emotional funny reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
emotional funny reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

It's seventeen-year-old John Masterson's final summer on the small island he's grown up on — perhaps a blessing on account of his mother's nude having made its way round the entire pupulation. He's got mind-numbing shifts at the local hotel, a budding relationship with slightly older Amber he's both proud and ashamed of, parties, and football to keep his mind off things. But he's also got choices to make: stay or leave, fit in or stand out, and who and how to love. 

McHugh has an immediate way of writing that catches you up in John's perspective right away, sentences tumbling one after another. He fully inhabits the sheer arrogance and crippling self-loathing that nonsensically coexist in teenage boys, sees their fumbles and stabs at masculinity, authentic in their imperfection, with a wry tenderness. He's also got range: being a teenager is objectively, constantly, both tragic and hilarious and the whole novel is alive to the feverish pitch of emotions at this transitional age. It handles them with a deftness, humour never getting in the way of poignancy. 

Be assured there's fun, for John and the reader. Games too, both physical (though as someone who neither knows nor cares anything about sportball I must admit the extended football scenes did nothing for me) and psychological (does anyone else remember the arbitrary rules of texting a crush we bent ourselves out of shape over??), and a heady hit of summer break nostalgia too. 

What worked about John is that he's not an especially deep or poetic thinker, he's not overly sensitive or unusual in any way. He's just a regular boy, trying to figure out his early steps into adulthood, worrying about his place among his friends and the wider world. The boot of social rank is on the neck of every interaction John has, but sometimes his earnestness escapes in a gasp that gives you pause. McHugh leaves him at a point where his future remains open, but you get the sense he'll find his way to the right path even if he stumbles. As his dad says: he's well able. 

Thanks to 4th Estate for my proof copy! 
reflective sad fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

'I am of faerie blood and I have faerie sight. You shame me for my faerie ways. But I cannot be other than I am.'

The shepherd Owain captures the heart of Salka, the faerie Lady of the Lake and she can't help but break tradition and appear to him. Her people allow her to wed a mortal on the condition that if he strikes her three heart-blows, she returns to the lake forever. Their marriage is blissfully happy to begin with, but gossip and fearmongering begin to turn their village against Salka. Owain wishes she'd try harder to fit in, but what is more of a strike against a heart than to question its very nature? 

Simon's prose is spare but rhythmic, using a chorus of voices to spin a tale of doomed love and faerie magic, while bringing forth the ways small communities often treat the Other. From the beginning the villagers project their fear, anger, and longing onto Salka, who disrupts their way of life by being different. You know from the start things are bound to go wrong, but my heart still ached for Owain as he bent to the judgement of others before trying to understand his ethereal bride. 

Something this got right was the use of motif, which often in stories aiming for a folktale feel ends up coming off as repetition. Certain refrains — when Salka and Owain think of each other, when Salka rebukes Owain, or when Owain's mother Angharad worries for her son — give rhythm and structure to the story as well as adding a timeless quality, mimicking oral storytelling traditions. 

In a market overcrowded with Greek myth retellings, I found this new take on a Welsh myth refreshing. It's a beautiful, sorrowful springtime fable for the folktale fans among us.

Thanks to Faber for sending me a proof! 
dark emotional hopeful sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

At 12, Neef's mother Chrissy moves them out of Leeds and into her new boyfriend's pub miles away. Unwelcome in the small Yorkshire town, Neef befriends Danny, another outsider. They cling to each other and their imagined future in London, far away from the poverty, racism, and substance abuse around them. Fifteen years later, Danny's father tracks Neef down and her buried past, the decisions she made and the person she became, rises back to the surface. 

What a beautiful debut, tender yet hard-hitting. Every scrap of hope Neef and Danny win is fought for tooth and nail, but the lows are plentiful and crushing. They're both frustrating, often selfish and irresponsible, but Usher writes them with such grace. You can't forget that they're just two kids trying to break the cycles keeping their families hostage, with zero tools and the odds stacked against them. 

Usher examines cycles of addiction, absent and failed parents, sexual assault, and how these intersect with poverty and racism. The prose is often gritty, unflinching in its depiction of the mundane horrors the luckier among us are insulated from, but empathetic and humane too. Though both teenagers are on a downward spiral, it isn't the same for Neef as it is for Danny — as a mixed-race boy he won't be afforded the same chances at reinvention in a world already poised to see him as a problem.

Part of Neef's journey is decentering herself from Danny's story, as gut-wrenching as that new void feels. Something that was done so well here was the exploration of love's many forms and faces, how it can help and heal when the conditions are right but it can also suffocate. The violence of first love, the sheer blistering intensity of those emotions, blazes through the book, but one person alone cannot be a fix or that need becomes as damaging as any other addiction.

Love isn't enough when the structures of our unequal world are bearing down, but it can hold you as you work to find your feet again, if you let it. 

Thank you to Serpent's Tail for sending me a paperback copy to review! 
informative

In our digital age, endless images and videos of perfectly clean, organised homes flood our feeds. The influences behind these accounts promote cleaning and tidying as a foundation for a happy, fulfilling life of order, the home as a sanctuary in our ever more stressful world. This look at the online phenomenon of the 'cleanfluencer', specifically in British contexts, asks why the burden of domestic labour still falls disproportionately on women.

Emma Casey situates cleanfluencers in the long history of women's domestic labour while recognising the new hyper-visibility of housework when it becomes social media content and the socioeconomic contexts that have made Britain so receptive to it. 

Particularly fascinating to me was the articulation of how cleanfluencers have successfully repackaged domestic labour as an act of self-care and empowerment. This flies in the face of Second Wave feminism's focus on the mindless drudgery foisted upon housewives, whose unending work was invisible and underappreciated by their families and society alike. Instead, cleanfluencers fall into a kind of 'girlboss' feminism where housework is a choice, an act of selfmaking with glamorous connotations. 

This intersects with neoliberal wellness understandings of mental health and personal responsibility, whereby unhappiness is an individual's duty to fix from within. Casey highlights how cleanfluencers subtly sell the transformational power of domestic work as a kind of therapy, but remain suspiciously silent on the structural inequalities that cause and exacerbate mental ill-health. 

This is a meticulously researched book packing in a lot to digest, so I found the recap sections summing up the key arguments made in each chapter extremely useful. However, the language is very accessible and the line of argument clear, so I'd highly recommend this for your feminist tbr if you're interested in why women have been unable to shake the unequal burden of housework. 

Thank you to Manchester University Press for sending me a proof of this in exchange for an honest review! 
emotional reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Our unnamed Iranian-Indian American narrator is two years out from her PhD and still broke, still in adjunct professor limbo, and feeling stuck. She decides to pack in her principles and devise an experiment: go on 100 dates with people of all genders, with the aim of securing a marriage proposal by the end of summer. Oh, and they have to be rich. Midway in her project some tragic news arrives and she must return to Tehran, forcing an overdue reckoning with questions of family, connection, and love. 

The first half dives into the narrator's chaotic dating experiment, humour and plenty of cutting satire refracted through the pretentious academic lens she has. There's something both funny and vicious about reading a smart woman ruthlessly try and hack the system she's ended up in — it's a literary brat summer with some Otessa Moshfegh ennui thrown in as a garnish. 

Then, there's an abrupt tone shift in part two. Following devastating news, the narrator is forced into a family drama that unpacks immigrant experiences in America, colourism in Iran, the pitfalls of marriage, values in Islam, patriarchy, and more. It does get a little breathless with the urge to fit so much in, but I think for the most part this commentary is layered successfully. There's an undercurrent of feminist bite to this section, especially as the narrator's mother's story unfolds. There's a scene in an icecream parlour I don't want to spoil but it was... perfection 👌🏻

Some may find the stylistic mismatch between parts one and two jarring, but I strongly suspect you're meant to. This book is witty, critical, and incredibly self-aware, leveraging the humanity found in part two to show how fundamentally soulless and pompous part one is, while also allowing you to learn why the narrator is Like This. 

I'd definitely like to reread this at some point because I think its verve and wit deserve to be fully absorbed. Plus, it's wonderfully written even if the ostentatious academic flourishes will (deliberately) make you grind your teeth. 

Thanks to Doubleday for my proof copy!