374 reviews by:

hongjoongie

Filter
adventurous challenging dark informative reflective sad tense
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

Oh the potential this had. I was hesitantly excited to read Babel; although I normally don’t read fantasy, I thought the subject matter (language, colonialism, etc.) and the time period would make it enjoyable. Unfortunately, it fails because it handles these topics so poorly and shallowly. There are many issues here, and luckily other people have felt the same and discussed the issues already, so I’m going to quote other reviews. 
 
First, this book is literally written as if didacticism, repetitiveness, and over explaining had a child that was allergic to subtlety and nuance. I don’t think I’ve ever read a book that did so much telling and so little showing. By the end I actually felt insulted by how condescending this book is. Kuang must think her readers are either idiots or racists. But rest assured, by the end you will definitely know racism, colonialism, and imperialism are bad!!! I found this issue happened most frequently in the footnotes, which annoyed me so much I started skipping them altogether. While some footnotes do offer additional information that is insightful and helpful, many of them are used to further beat the reader over the head and ensure they know racism is a big no no. Take these for example: 
 
Robin tried to befriend a Japanese third-year student named Ilse Dejima, who spoke with a faint Dutch accent (Footnote: “Like Robin, Ilse was known to the English not by her birth name but by an adopted name; a combination of a chosen Anglicized name (Ilse) …
 
Isle isn’t a Japanese name? I had no idea! 
 
And even more insulting: 
 
"But I don't want to die, Robin …  I don't want to die. I don't want to be their Imoinda, their Oroonoko. I don't want to be their tragic, lovely lacquer figure. I want to live." (Footnote: In (the white Englishwoman) Aphra Behn's 1688 romantic novel Oroonoko, the African prince Oroonoko kills his lover Imoinda to save her from being violated by the English military forces against whom they are revolting. Oroonoko is later captured, bound to a post, quartered, and dismembered. Oroonoko, and its theatrical adaptation by Thomas Southerne, were received at the time as a great romance.
 
Why is “the white Englishwoman” necessary? Even if someone doesn’t know Aphra Behn was white and has not read Oroonoko does Kuang not trust her readers to maybe do more research on it and learn the author is white and then maybe question for themselves why the portrayal of Oroonoko is troubling? Does she really not think we’re capable of understanding stuff on our own? 
 
As other reviewers said: 
 
But instead of using [the footnotes] to carry on a fascinating magical history … the author uses the footnotes to TELL the reader exactly what to think … the footnotes read like parody and made me dislike the author as someone who is pathologically self-congratulatory.
 
[The footnotes] were either pieces of information that were critical to the story and therefore should not have even been footnotes, or extraneous pieces of backstory that should have been cut but RF Kuang just could not help herself from making this book as long as possible, or condescending "IN CASE YOU DIDN'T REALIZE, THIS PERSON IS RACIST" diatribes. RF Kuang writes as though she thinks her readers are children who can't tell that she's writing purposefully racist dialogue so she needs a footnote to explain.
 
I'm also just not a fan of the author inserting herself into the fictional narrative via footnotes. I feel the footnotes could've been used better by a fictional editor or if its revealed that one of the students was actually writing the story itself. 

This didacticism also makes the characters one-dimensional tools for, yet again, hammering in what the author wants us to know and feel. Each character just felt like anti-racism talking points. The worst of this is Letty,
who is portrayed as a bigot and simply not understanding any form of racist oppression because she’s white and then very unexpectedly (to me) shoots and kills Ramy to let us know that she is in fact a bad person. Ramy, who was actually an interesting character, dies suddenly and we lose the potential queer side-plot just to demonstrate a person of color experiences more hardships than a white woman….
Yes... we get it. 
 
Despite these flaws, the book does discuss very relevant issues, such as Robin’s simultaneously benefiting from and being used by the empire and how most people don’t recognize the harmful impacts of racism etc until it impacts them directly. I was invested for most of it until I started feeling insulted.

Ultimately, this could’ve been written so much better and it makes me not want to read Yellowface, but maybe I’ll hate read it. 
adventurous dark hopeful informative mysterious reflective
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I felt in a near constant state of reorienting which, rather than exhausting me, merely served to put me at a calm sense of remove from my own reality. It seemed to me that few things I'd done or would do could ever truly matter, and I'd come to enjoy this feeling, and take comfort in it, wondering how long I could float above the world until someone called me down with the answer of how to spend my years.
adventurous dark emotional informative reflective sad tense
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

I grew up in these hills and they raised me: the streams and rock shelves, the valleys where scrub oaks bunched so thick they seemed one mass but allowed me, skinny and swift, to slip between trunks and pierce the hollow center where branches knit a green ceiling. If I had a people, then I saw those people in the reflecting pools, where water was so clear it showed a world the exact double of this one: another set of hills and sky, another boy looking back with my same eyes. I grew up knowing I belonged to this land, Lucy girl. You and Sam do too, never mind how you look. Don't you let any man with a history book tell you different.

Maybe the travel goes quicker on account of Lucy feeling a sorrow kin to love. Because though these dry yellow hills yielded nothing but pain and sweat and misplaced hope— she knows them. A part of her is buried in them, a part of her lost in them, a part of her found and born in them—so many parts belong to this land. An ache in her chest like the tug of a dowsing rod. Across the ocean the people will look like them, but they won't know the shapes of these hills, or the soughing of grass, or the taste of muddy water— all these things that shape Lucy within as her eyes and nose shape her without. Maybe the travel goes quicker on account of Lucy mourning, already, the loss of this land.

Really enjoyed learning more about the untold stories of the American gold rush. A great exploration of the immigrant/Indigenous experience, belonging, and the mutability of history. I also enjoyed the overall atmosphere. I do think the sexuality/gender of the characters could have been explored more. This was a finalist for the Lambda bisexual fiction award when that aspect seems to play a small role in the story. 
challenging dark emotional funny hopeful inspiring mysterious reflective sad tense
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

… he felt powerful, that is, he felt light, and in charge, and free, and expansive: he felt the future - which for so long he'd thought of as immutable - he felt the future amorphous, ethe-real, waiting for him to decide its shape. 
 
I suppose that’s what everybody wants, isn't it. To be like everybody else. But nobody is like everybody else. That's the one thing we have in common. We’re all different, but we all think everyone else is the same, he said. If they taught us that in school, I feel like the world would be a much happier place. 
 
It's just a part of being modern, she says. Like, it just means you don't have to accept what society presents you and that's that. You can choose. 
Try things out. 
Right, you say. 
It's just the modern world, she says again. 
You imagine being modern: someone unafraid, unabashed, browsing the endless midnight warehouse of desire, its shelves piled high to the roof, to pick out the package that is uniquely and comprehensively you. 
 
How did it come to this? You look back at the past and you can't tell here exactly you went wrong. Was it a single misstep? … Or is it every-thing: Your years raising a family, running a business, your little loves, your thwarted desires, your whole innocuous life, has it all been leading up to this moment? And if it has, what does that make you?

Definitely a standout in the dysfunctional family saga canon. This story was so well crafted and multilayered while being surprisingly intense and propulsive. It lowkey reads like a thriller, and I was surprised multiple times while reading. It does a great job examining shame and perceived truth, the (generational) consequences of small actions, how our choices or inaction impacts both our own lives and the lives of others, how the past can’t be erased but the present and future can be changed, and how coming together for a common cause will help us all. 

I also appreciate how the ending is open to interpretation, challenges the reader to think through different outcomes for the characters, and determine whether we too can make change in our world through collective love. Although it wasn’t quite a home run for me, this is a high 4.5 and could easily be a 5 for many people. 
challenging dark mysterious reflective tense
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

This book is a good depiction of codependency, obsession, and manipulation. It also does a good job with an unreliable narrator. I was engrossed for most of the book. But it was also frustrating at times, and there were some things that could’ve been done better. For example, some more backstory to make how they fell for each other so quickly more believable, cut down some of the same scenes about their toxic relationship that repeat a lot, and some more detail about what motivated them to commit their violent act. But when I think about the story more, maybe the lack of lead up to their relationship (and what happens after the relationship ends) works bc for Paul that’s all his life was—his relationship with Julian. And maybe we don’t get the details about motivation (especially from Julian) bc it’s from Paul’s unreliable pov. Maybe Paul is the issue, but we’re not supposed to like him. Overall I enjoyed this propulsive, tense read. 
mysterious reflective sad
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I wake all of a sudden. I must have dozed off in the chair here, and now I have that heavy feeling I sometimes get when I drop off during the afternoon, as though something existential, fundamental, has risen to the surface and lies just below, about to reach my consciousness. But the only thing I feel is sadness. And I can't manage to grasp what was almost so clear to me as I was on the verge of waking, and consequently there is nothing I can do about it, no way to make it disappear again.
emotional funny hopeful inspiring reflective sad
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

What we had that day was our story. We didn't have the other bit, the future, and we had no way of knowing what that would be like. Perhaps it would change our memory of all this, or perhaps it would draw from it, nobody knew. But I'm sure I felt the story of that hall and how we reached it would never vanish.

‘What a weekend.'
‘You in your Marilyn Monroe T-shirt,’ he said. ‘Tully with his black creps and white socks. There are moments from that weekend, I mean... we're talking over thirty years ago. I can be standing at the shaving mirror or sitting at my desk, deep in some corridor of the internet or whatever, trying to do some work, and it'll come into my head - something funny from that weekend in Manchester.' 

This was a conflicting read. The first part left me disappointed, not because of bad writing, but because I didn’t get a lot of the Scottish references and thus couldn’t relate with the characters. I enjoyed the second section significantly more and really connected to the themes of nostalgia and wanting to re-live the past. I enjoyed how the novel was structured, how each section builds to very different but equally significant moments in the main characters’ lives. And the ending is very good. But it definitely would have resonated more if I would have connected with the characters more in the first half. Overall a pleasant read that will probably be better for readers who understand the cultural references. 
hopeful reflective sad
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

‘Let's not name it. Once you name something, you have to define it: say what it is and isn't. Not to mention maintenance.
All the relationships with names - parent, sister, husband, lover - come with maintenance. All that effort keeping it to what it's supposed to be. Shouldn't we allow ourselves at least one unnamed, undefined close relationship in our lives? A free-standing, wild-card arrangement. How about it, Joseph? How about you just try to make me happy, and I'll try and do the same for you?'

This felt incomplete, like it couldn’t decide if it was a novel or a short story. The writing is decent and I think I like the overall message, but at the basic level it’s about a guy who couldn’t get over a mistake he made during a soccer match 35 years ago… ? I wish this was grounded in a more poignant scenario and other ideas/points were explored and developed more. 
dark funny reflective
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Sacrifices lovable characters and a memorable story for an experimental form. Liked a sentence occasionally. 
challenging dark emotional mysterious reflective sad tense
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I hope that when we return them to their homes along the river they will have many far-fetched stories to tell their neighbours. I hope that the history of their captivity enters their legends, passed down from grandfather to grandson. But I hope too that memories of the town, with its easy life and its exotic foods, are not strong enough to lure them back. I do not want a race of beggars on my hands.

What has made it impossible for us to live in time like fish in water, like birds in air, like children? It is the fault of Empire! Empire has created the time of history. Empire has located its existence not in the smooth recurrent spinning time of the cycle of the seasons but in the jagged time of rise and fall, of beginning and end, of catastrophe. Empire dooms itself to live in history and plot against history. One thought alone preoccupies the submerged mind of Empire: how not to end, how not to die, how to prolong its era. By day it pursues its enemies. It is cunning and ruthless, it sends its bloodhounds everywhere. By night it feeds on images of disaster: the sack of cities, the rape of populations, pyramids of bones, acres of desolation.

It would be best if this obscure chapter in the history of the world were terminated at once, if these ugly people were obliterated from the face of the earth and we swore to make a new start, to run an empire in which there would be no more injustice, no more pain. It would cost little to march them out into the desert (having put a meal in them first, perhaps, to make the march possible), to have them dig, with their last strength, a pit large enough for all of them to lie in (or even to dig it for them!), and, leaving them buried there forever and forever, to come back to the walled town full of new intentions, new resolutions. But that will not be my way. The new men of Empire are the ones who believe in fresh starts, new chapters, clean pages; I struggle on with the old story … “

Outside of time and space, this story could take place in the past or the present, in apartheid South Africa or Trump-consumed America, as it details the barbaric relationship between colonizer and the colonized. A tense and gritty depiction of empire, paranoia, isolation, xenophobia, and the struggle to resist imperial oppression if it means letting go of the power and privileges it awards you. This novel begs to be analyzed and is full of allegory and symbolism. A must read edition to the post-colonial canon that encourages us to challenge our complacency and question who the real barbarians are.