You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

hongjoongie's profile picture

hongjoongie 's review for:

Babel by R.F. Kuang
2.5
adventurous challenging dark informative reflective sad tense
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

Oh the potential this had. I was hesitantly excited to read Babel; although I normally don’t read fantasy, I thought the subject matter (language, colonialism, etc.) and the time period would make it enjoyable. Unfortunately, it fails because it handles these topics so poorly and shallowly. There are many issues here, and luckily other people have felt the same and discussed the issues already, so I’m going to quote other reviews. 
 
First, this book is literally written as if didacticism, repetitiveness, and over explaining had a child that was allergic to subtlety and nuance. I don’t think I’ve ever read a book that did so much telling and so little showing. By the end I actually felt insulted by how condescending this book is. Kuang must think her readers are either idiots or racists. But rest assured, by the end you will definitely know racism, colonialism, and imperialism are bad!!! I found this issue happened most frequently in the footnotes, which annoyed me so much I started skipping them altogether. While some footnotes do offer additional information that is insightful and helpful, many of them are used to further beat the reader over the head and ensure they know racism is a big no no. Take these for example: 
 
Robin tried to befriend a Japanese third-year student named Ilse Dejima, who spoke with a faint Dutch accent (Footnote: “Like Robin, Ilse was known to the English not by her birth name but by an adopted name; a combination of a chosen Anglicized name (Ilse) …
 
Isle isn’t a Japanese name? I had no idea! 
 
And even more insulting: 
 
"But I don't want to die, Robin …  I don't want to die. I don't want to be their Imoinda, their Oroonoko. I don't want to be their tragic, lovely lacquer figure. I want to live." (Footnote: In (the white Englishwoman) Aphra Behn's 1688 romantic novel Oroonoko, the African prince Oroonoko kills his lover Imoinda to save her from being violated by the English military forces against whom they are revolting. Oroonoko is later captured, bound to a post, quartered, and dismembered. Oroonoko, and its theatrical adaptation by Thomas Southerne, were received at the time as a great romance.
 
Why is “the white Englishwoman” necessary? Even if someone doesn’t know Aphra Behn was white and has not read Oroonoko does Kuang not trust her readers to maybe do more research on it and learn the author is white and then maybe question for themselves why the portrayal of Oroonoko is troubling? Does she really not think we’re capable of understanding stuff on our own? 
 
As other reviewers said: 
 
But instead of using [the footnotes] to carry on a fascinating magical history … the author uses the footnotes to TELL the reader exactly what to think … the footnotes read like parody and made me dislike the author as someone who is pathologically self-congratulatory.
 
[The footnotes] were either pieces of information that were critical to the story and therefore should not have even been footnotes, or extraneous pieces of backstory that should have been cut but RF Kuang just could not help herself from making this book as long as possible, or condescending "IN CASE YOU DIDN'T REALIZE, THIS PERSON IS RACIST" diatribes. RF Kuang writes as though she thinks her readers are children who can't tell that she's writing purposefully racist dialogue so she needs a footnote to explain.
 
I'm also just not a fan of the author inserting herself into the fictional narrative via footnotes. I feel the footnotes could've been used better by a fictional editor or if its revealed that one of the students was actually writing the story itself. 

This didacticism also makes the characters one-dimensional tools for, yet again, hammering in what the author wants us to know and feel. Each character just felt like anti-racism talking points. The worst of this is Letty,
who is portrayed as a bigot and simply not understanding any form of racist oppression because she’s white and then very unexpectedly (to me) shoots and kills Ramy to let us know that she is in fact a bad person. Ramy, who was actually an interesting character, dies suddenly and we lose the potential queer side-plot just to demonstrate a person of color experiences more hardships than a white woman….
Yes... we get it. 
 
Despite these flaws, the book does discuss very relevant issues, such as Robin’s simultaneously benefiting from and being used by the empire and how most people don’t recognize the harmful impacts of racism etc until it impacts them directly. I was invested for most of it until I started feeling insulted.

Ultimately, this could’ve been written so much better and it makes me not want to read Yellowface, but maybe I’ll hate read it.