190 reviews by:

emory

Filter
dark slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No

I had my doubts in the middle to late part of the book about the way the suspense was built, but the ending came together in such a jawdroppingly foreshadowed way it erased all my concerns. I think the epistolary format could've been done better, as it makes a certain reveal seem a bit silly if you buy completely into the idea thst our main character is writing to a man who would already know, but it's also a huge aspect of what makes the story so hard to file away as just another thriller.
A particular passage near the end about the father's crookedness aligning with the house's will stay with me for quite some time.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Some of the best writing I've seen in my adventures through middle to low quality thriller books recently. It was especially refreshing to read a book with multiple POVs that was able to keep them distinct and the characters moving through independent investigations. It had a very nice flow and tone to it (although one of my complaints is that this tone, while compelling at first, never changes and grows a bit flat).

The plot itself is pretty decent (even if I found it a bit annoying to make the case a cold case but then have three different characters discover the culprit independently through three different extremely simple investigative avenues); however, it lacks the suspenseful turns of a gripping thriller and also the character interiority that drives a tragedy about grief. Since I'm not sure exactly which one this book is going for, I'm not sure which to be more disappointed about. Hannah's character shone through (I would assume the series will follow her investigations, with this installment serving as a bit of an origin story), but even in her segments of narrative, we're told her emotions bluntly and clinically rather than shown through actions or relayed with any kind of warmth. Though emotional turmoil makes up a large part of each character's story, both the narrator and the characters themselves talk about them in the same flat tone as the rest of the novel. The death of
the main investigator in the case had absolutely no emotional impact, trimmed of all detail or decorum
. It just felt empty and one note. Time and space are nebulous, with little description of any space the characters inhabit and random moments within a chapter that mention it has now been weeks or months worth of time since an event. I think if the story leaned a bit harder into its characters rather than formulaic thriller speak--the killer actually says "your precious Megan" at one point--it really couldve shined! I especially would've liked more focus on Hannah's OCD(?)(that isn't represented for once as a nagging desire to wash her hands and nothing else; it's a miracle, even if the depiction could've been better in other ways), or Tom's feelings of guilt over "causing" his daughter's disappearance. As it was, though, the characters felt a bit cardboard.

One last little reservation I have is a bit of an odd tone surrounding vigilantism and the PIs using aggressive tactics that cops cannot. It's nothing you won't see in a typical police procedural, but still leaves a bitter taste in my mouth.

Overall I had my criticisms, but I did like the style of writing even with my reservations about the details it chooses to give or withhold. I wouldnt rule reading out more of the series.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
funny slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Complicated

I thought the premise was great, and it's a perfectly nice story, but I wish it had more to carry it than flat dialogue and extreme detail about each restaurant's menu. The story being written in vignettes worked against the main idea of the plot to me, making the unique characters feel disjointed from the story and forgettable. Nothing really stood out and the ending came with no real reflection at all. I would've liked more showing rather than blunt telling. It all felt very blunt throughout, which isn't my cup of tea in storytelling.

The main character exists in a sort of paradox of having an extremely distinct voice, but the voice in question is almost indistinguishable from a snarky Saturday morning cartoon character. There are so many moments of cleverness and wit that have to fight past the disaffected class clown voice to shine through. They do though, anyway, and there's quite a lot of great humor in the form of quippy anecdotes and callbacks.

I didnt dislike it, but it felt unfinished. Nice concept but somehow even with a rotating cast of characters and quippy anecdotes, the story felt empty. Would love to see it get its feet under it.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
adventurous dark slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated

Very disappointed in the ending. I found the story to be compelling at first, but it never stopped being driven mostly by lectures from one main character to another over and over again about the same topic. I don't like the turn the narrative took from run of the mill dystopian sci-fi into
  appeasing an ancient god
that is not even mentioned until over halfway through all of the books; she is not even explained as such until this installment. The long monologue in which the main character explains all this was beyond annoying; out of nowhere he receives a flash drive full of research a man he met previously just miraculously knew, and we take a whole chapter dedicated to him regurgitating the information point by point. It was such an out of left field final act to a story that has been begging to be wrapped up for 4 volumes. Unfortunately, my disappointment with the latter half of the story overshadows my enjoyment of the beginning sections. I don't know if I'll be reading the extras volume or not. :/
funny reflective relaxing sad slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Diverse cast of characters: No

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark emotional reflective slow-paced

Very insightful read on a cultural phenomenon that, as someone who was born after it's conclusion and canonization as a nationwide misstep, I have only just recently learned about. I do wish certain topics had been given more discussion, or alternate theories introduced; namely in regards to why the daughters of this man would have made such accusations if there were no truth to them at all. A few different causes were proposed (including a wholesale endorsement of the Oedipus complex theory, which I find a bit distasteful), but I feel as if this point was almost entirely passed over. Additionally, I think some postulation on why the identities of the accusers and those accused followed specific trends would strengthen the narrative; just saying women are starting witch hunts against their male family members left a bad taste in my mouth. There was almost no reference to the role misogyny almost certainly played within these events. The lack of this kind of analysis especially stood out as the author took us through the ways that the dynamics and authority of the church influenced Ingram's false memories; with the place women are given in the hierarchy within Christian fundamentalist sects, I feel like some consideration into the effects of this would've been a good addition to the breakdown of this event.

I did not know that the concept of repression itself was so contentious; I had assumed only hypnosis-based recovered memories were what was under fire at the time. The examination of this method of psychological understanding was very concise and thought-provoking. 

The writing was at once intelligent and easy to follow. The amount of care and research put into creating this account are very apparent. 

On a very personal note, even if most of these accounts of abuse appear to have been entirely fabricated false memories or wholesale lies originating from a comedy of investigative errors, quite a few of them did leave me shaken and disgusted. At a certain point I had to start skimming or skipping them entirely, as they contained a level of detail I couldn't stomach. Adds to the completelt bizarre feeling that this whole event is steeped in.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
mysterious slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Reads more like the screenplay for a two part episode of a police procedural than a novel. Mostly driven by one note dialogue (which would be fine if this were not 400 pages), and the writing in between is lackluster. 

Our first person narrator has the same voice as a thousand other thriller protags, and I would have liked to see
more focus put on her descent into covering for her son's crime
as well as on the role reversal she faces. The setting in Thailand could've aided this well, since both her role as the mother of a suspect and the scene of the crime itself were foreign grounds; however, all that really came from the crimes'  setting in Thailand were weird undertones about how skeezy everyone there was, and a completely out of place subplot about the Thai police refusing to cooperate with the British investigators and being completely incompetent in their findings. This story could've taken place in the UK and it would've changed next to nothing and saved us about a hundred pages. I was disappointed as I found the premise of investigating the archetypes of the genre and how the main character would cope with this role reversal to be very interesting, but nothing came of it.

The plot was fine, but predictable; from the first time
Alex refers to Jamie as 'JW' in her email it's fairly obvious that there's going to be a case of mistaken identity somewhere down the line.
And while I also dislike mysteries in which the stakes are upped needlessly, this was so low stakes it was almost incredible. It isn't even revealed to the characters that they are looking into a murder until over halfway through the book, I believe. The shifting POV amounted to nothing, as everyone is always on the same page, and if they're not, get that way in about 3 pages (coincidentally the length of the average chapter).

Fine but unremarkable writing, decently engaging but ultimately run of the mill mystery plot, and main characters that felt extraneous. Fine read for killing time but I definitely wasn't a fan...

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
reflective sad medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes
challenging dark reflective sad
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
adventurous dark reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Again not sure how I feel about the developments in this one. By this volume the "Shion felt sorry that he had lived a privileged pampered life. He was ashamed to be a burden" and "Nezumi was disgusted by Shion's naivety and ideas that it could all be better. He would protect him but he also couldn't stand what a baby he was. He wanted revenge" schtick is veryyyy repetitive. The scifi developments get less and less serious as it goes on but I'm willing to stick it out because I do really enjoy the concept itself. Writing is of the same quality and the characters are just as charming.