emory's profile picture

emory 's review for:

The Suspect by Fiona Barton
2.0
mysterious slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Reads more like the screenplay for a two part episode of a police procedural than a novel. Mostly driven by one note dialogue (which would be fine if this were not 400 pages), and the writing in between is lackluster. 

Our first person narrator has the same voice as a thousand other thriller protags, and I would have liked to see
more focus put on her descent into covering for her son's crime
as well as on the role reversal she faces. The setting in Thailand could've aided this well, since both her role as the mother of a suspect and the scene of the crime itself were foreign grounds; however, all that really came from the crimes'  setting in Thailand were weird undertones about how skeezy everyone there was, and a completely out of place subplot about the Thai police refusing to cooperate with the British investigators and being completely incompetent in their findings. This story could've taken place in the UK and it would've changed next to nothing and saved us about a hundred pages. I was disappointed as I found the premise of investigating the archetypes of the genre and how the main character would cope with this role reversal to be very interesting, but nothing came of it.

The plot was fine, but predictable; from the first time
Alex refers to Jamie as 'JW' in her email it's fairly obvious that there's going to be a case of mistaken identity somewhere down the line.
And while I also dislike mysteries in which the stakes are upped needlessly, this was so low stakes it was almost incredible. It isn't even revealed to the characters that they are looking into a murder until over halfway through the book, I believe. The shifting POV amounted to nothing, as everyone is always on the same page, and if they're not, get that way in about 3 pages (coincidentally the length of the average chapter).

Fine but unremarkable writing, decently engaging but ultimately run of the mill mystery plot, and main characters that felt extraneous. Fine read for killing time but I definitely wasn't a fan...

Expand filter menu Content Warnings