647 reviews by:

carolinewithane


to everyone who told me to read this:

thank you

i like the comedy in the textbook version, but the illustrations more than compensate for the steep price of this illustrated edition. highly recommend it to any potterhead. and it was a great book to start the year with

(yes, i read it from cover to cover in the new year. it was delightful, even without ron’s entertaining commentary)

i am—how do the kids say it—shook

so apparently now i read romance

to be fair, i don’t think you’re supposed to skim the sex scenes like i did, or get upset with some typical erotica tropes and descriptions, but i wanted to read about polyamory and that’s what i got 🤷🏻‍♀️

all in all, this was actually nice. who would’ve thought

same things i said about book #1 apply here. fast, nice, a bit problematic, a bit too superficial, i didn’t really read all the threesomes because sex scenes bore me, but we can’t ask much now can we

the weakest of all three, but it might be because i don’t care about pregnancy stories

nice message, clumsy execution. still, considering how long ago it was written, it is amazing (and amazingly scary).

this book ruined me

new favourite

i loved this book so much.

it’s a queer little thing—in both senses of the world (ha)—and has everything i love reading about. strong characters, lovely writing, intrigue, assassination plots, gruesomeness, the mafia, and magic.

plus, it features a genderqueer love story so carefully and respectfully written you can’t help but fall in love a bit too.

more, please ♥️

i started this book confused and ended it even more confused, but damn if it wasn’t amazing