I loved seeing these characters again and i loved the christmas elements of this read!! It was a quick read and loved seeing all the characters again!! I also felt like the start of tihs book was a tad rushed but overall i enjoyed the plot and loved how each book changed the game a bit.. i did not love this book as much as the first two but for christmas themed mystery it was very fun.

This again feels like i read a small town chirstmas romance and it just put a smile on my face again, I loved seeing the characters from book one and loved the self disvery path that was present for the main character and i also again loved the romacne and the animals at the heart of this read, this feel like such a real town and loved the chrismtas elements at the heart of this read!!

I think this was such a unqiue read and very well told. I was really captrued by evelyn hugo and at moments felt for her and other moments was so angry at her. I just really enjoyed the large cast f characters and how this story was told. Monique parts was not super memorabe and felt like that part could have been expanded about what. What really did feel like i knew evely and i just was captured by her story!!

* I got this book for review from the publisher*
I loved this book and found it to be a super unque read and one that a flew though. This read as def higher Ya to me. It also screamed regency romance and brigerton to me with a magic twist. This story had some many gohtic elemetns that captured me from page one. I also loved the death magic element and how that was crafted throuhgout this novel. I also really loved how this book built a found family element it and also was super captured by the mystery at the heart of the read!! I did not predict the ending and so excited for book 2!!

Merged review:

* I got this book for review from the publisher*
I loved this book and found it to be a super unque read and one that a flew though. This read as def higher Ya to me. It also screamed regency romance and brigerton to me with a magic twist. This story had some many gohtic elemetns that captured me from page one. I also loved the death magic element and how that was crafted throuhgout this novel. I also really loved how this book built a found family element it and also was super captured by the mystery at the heart of the read!! I did not predict the ending and so excited for book 2!!

I am so happy i tackled this book!! I love the friends to hate to more dynamics in the story. It was a unqiue read with a fun twist on fairies and aso seers and gods.It was a super fast pace read and i loved the mai character and also was super invested by the characters in the plot and i loved al the potical elements in this read and did not see all the random twsits coming and i really love the morally gray lead!!

I really enjoyed this read. I loved the ASL rep and loved seeing the world through jessie eyes. We had some minor plot elements that i wish were tied up but it was a great balance of info a about the deaf commmunity and a fun look at how dance impact jessie life!! def a new favorite in the seires

I think was def a unique read in this series. I liked the new setting and enjoyed it but also missed the NYC setting. I also liked how found family elements were very presdent in this one. I also really liked the road trip elements in this read!! I don't think was new favorite but it was a very heartwaring read for sure!

I thought this was fun, next volune in this series. I also am wowed by the pretty graphics and drawing in this vol. I also enjoyed not only the dynamics between the characters but also the harder topics i book 2 included abuse and rape, the topics were adressed in book 2 and liked how the fallout was there. I also liked seeing the new characters and new god dynamics!! It was very nice edion!!

This was a super cute read. It had prefect holiday vibes and gruff/sunshine romance. It also had so much small time drama and also my favorite small town troupe of baking. This also had a ton of small town and family elements. It was quick read not super memorable but if you want cute christmas themd romance this is prefect!!

I really enjoyed this book and am so excited to read book 2 soon!! This was such a soild read. I love the mytholgy tinge this book had to it and also the competioon at the heart of it. I normally struggle with smaller casts of chracters and thik some of the characters could have been expanded on a tad. I also think the world building had some confusion points but i am so excited to see where book 2 goes!!