328 reviews by:

birdykinsreads

Filter
adventurous dark medium-paced

The Book of Doors was a fun adventurous ride about magical books falling into the wrong (and sometimes right) hands and changing lives forever. Exactly the escapism I needed.

I think the world building was excellent and I loved how thoughtful the plotting behind the magic was. Where I felt this book struggled a bit was in the sheer amount of characters we were introduced to and how at times they felt a bit shallow for it. I personally didn’t think he wrote his female characters and their friendship as believably as he could have. But, that was small potatoes for a book that was otherwise filled to the brim with wonder, magic and pure evil. I did get annoyed with how often characters made choices and dumb mistakes that felt like they were there to be convenient in moving the plot forward but the end came together in such a moving way that I’m willing to forgive that. Especially for a debut, this was a really well done fantasy-thriller and I’d definitely read what he puts out next.

adventurous lighthearted mysterious

Ahhhh The Ghost Bride… the one pretty much everyone hated but me lol. Bookclub was not a fan of this one. Maybe it was the shallow characters, or the seemingly no personality or inner life of the MC Li Lan. Maybe it was the various plots that just got abandoned willy nilly throughout the book with no explanation. Or maybe it was just that the story told was not the story we expected at all. 

I think only one other member liked this one and we both liked it for the mythology and the folklore throughout the book. I also got very attached to the sassy spirit Er Lang who becomes a love interest half way through—he was doing it for me lol.

The Ghost Bride is about Li Lan, a woman from a once prosperous family now on hard times bc of her father’s opium addiction. When a rich and influential family offer her the chance to marry their late son and become a ghost bride she can’t think of anything she wants less, despite the safety it would afford her and her family. But, the son is a childish baby man who haunts her dreams demanding she be his. Soon she’s pulled into the world of spirits and hungry ghosts driven to extremes looking for any way she can to make her own decisions and live her own life before it’s too late. She also gets entangled with a hot watch tinkerer, heir to the rich family’s fortune and pulled into a mystery surrounding her own mother’s death. There’s a lot going on. 

What I liked most was the Chinese mythology of the dead and the afterlife. It was completely fascinating. And even if Yangsze Choo didn’t execute her many ideas efficiently in this book, that was enough for me to stay engaged and enjoying this book until the end. I liked it enough I’m planning to read more by her and definitely pick up more books that feature Chinese mythology and folklore about ghosts and the afterlife. Another bookclub member suggested Six Crimson Cranes by Elizabeth Lim as a good place to start.

Majority of members rated this book 2-3 stars. I originally gave it 4 and then came down because yeah, you right. lol 3.5 stars is still a good rating from me though.

lighthearted tense

A bit of a rambling narrative that wanders in a few different directions, I can see why Come & Get It by Kiley Reid hasn't been getting the best reviews, but I enjoyed it. I think that's mostly down to the talented narration of Nicole Lewis, who also did The House of Eve by Sadeqa Johnson which I listened to and really liked last year as well. 

Her narration feels very warm and inviting with a healthy amount of dramatics. I love all the voices and accents she did with this one, and I think that helped keep the myriad of characters straight, and injected them with personality that maybe was missing from the actual text, hard to say. To be completely fair, Nicole might have been doing the heavy lifting here.

Come & Get It is about Millie Cousins, RA at the University of Arkansas and the students and visiting professor that she gets entangled with. Plot-wise, this one is a little weak, but I found the comedy of errors, college slice-of-life, at times somewhat absurdist backstories and morally grey characters really engaging here, so it was easy for me to forgive it. 

I think people who loved Such a Fun Age felt a little letdown with this follow up, but I found her debut just alright, so it felt on par for me. There IS just something about her writing style though that is so tasty, I just eat it right up. 

Both books have their issues but on the whole, are easy to read and sink into. Did she manage to execute all the moving pieces perfectly here? (Commentary on race, money, class, indiscretion, power in relationships, etc.) Not quite, but it was fun and kept me entertained—blitzing through this. So, I'm a fan! 

And more than anything, I'll be seeking out more audiobooks narrated by Nicole Lewis, queen.

Thanks to @librofm for the review copy.

dark mysterious medium-paced

I’m now part of two bookclubs and my new one met for the first time the other night—it was just the best. There’s nothing like eating nachos and talking books! We read The Centre and the discussion was SO GOOD! Multiple people came with notes (I love an impromptu book report) and there was so much stuff to unpack with this one.

The Centre is about a Pakistani woman who finds out about a secret exclusive language learning centre when her new boyfriend manages to learn Urdu in 10 days in preparation of meeting her family on a trip home. An aspiring translator she decides to partake and from there falls into an almost obsessive relationship with a woman at the centre, and begins to suspect something nefarious is afoot.

To avoid spoilers we’ll just say the twists were TWISTING with this one and we were all surprised to some degree in the end. This was a well liked book, getting mostly 3-4 stars but there were alot of things that bugged us. Namely, the very unlikeable main character and maybe not enough answers by the end of the book. The writing style was super engaging though, and for me at least, I was hooked all the way through. Surprisingly, despite what we learned about it, a decent number of us felt we would partake in the language program at the centre anyway. 😬

A dark book to start off a bookclub, but it was my pick so not surprising at all 🤷🏻‍♀️.
adventurous funny mysterious fast-paced


Women of Good Fortune by Sophie Wan is like if you took Crazy Rich Asians and mixed it with a little Ocean’s Eleven and Counterfeit by Kristen Chen—which is to say cinematic, surprisingly touching and super fun.

Lulu is engaged to the most eligible bachelor  in Shanghai—but between how fast the relationship is moving, her heinous mother in law to be, and the expectations of her own overbearing family to “marry up” and take care of them, she’s searching for a way out. When her best friends with their own money-problems (Jane, desperate to divorce her husband and get plastic surgery and Rina, tired of being looked over for promotion at work and facing a fertility situation she can’t afford) offhandedly suggest stealing the veritable fortune that will be gifted at the high society wedding, it sparks something in them all.

Next thing you know they’re all using their own special skills to assemble a crew and plan an outrageous heist on her wedding day. But of course, things won’t seem to go to plan and hearts get tangled up and broken in the process. Will their friendship survive the pressure? 

I really enjoyed this vengeful team of conwomen who were fed up with society’s narrow constraints for them and decided to do something about it. They were funny, brash and clever and never had a dull moment. I liked how their personal situations each had their own twist by the end and though I wish the characters had more depth to them, I was still into it and rooting for them. Rina and Jane each had their own side-love stories that were actually so much better than Lulu’s main one so I wish they had got more playtime, too.

All in all a quick fun read for fans of lying stealing ladies and female friendship.

Thanks to @netgalley and @harperaudio @harlequin_audio for the arc in exchange for my honest review.
funny informative reflective

A really great collection of pop-culture essays about Grace Perry’s coming-of-age and interrogation of her own sexuality and identity as a millennial searching for queer touchstones in media before the representation was representing. 

Perry writes about such canon events as listening to Katy Perry’s “I Kissed a Girl” for the first time; the rise and fall of Lindsay Lohan, teen tv like The OC, Disney shows and Gossip Girl; furtively watching The L Word; Taylor Swift’s early eras and obsession with kissing in the rain; celebrities and public coming out; the identity politics of Butch and Femme and how it factors into the movie Best in Show… and more! 

This book was an equally fun and vulnerable ride and I appreciated the way she guided us through these cultural touchstones and the impact they had on making her as she puts it “gay as hell.” 

How she illustrated intimately the way her mind would do mental gymnastics to explain away her feelings, desires and deep truth was super relatable—it’s comforting to see how much more Gen Z is able to express themselves and accept each other, and the progressive pop-culture they’ve been lucky enough to consume has likely been a big part of that. It’s not where it needs to be, but it’s better than it was and Perry makes that so clear in her reckoning with millennial nostalgia.


Acerbic essays with an off-putting tone only magnified when listening to the audiobook read by the author. She feels like the type of person who would corner you at a party and talk at you for hours, uninterested in anything but the sound of her own voice. I believe that she believes she’s the smartest person in the room. I fell asleep once listening to this, oops, and found myself tuning out a lot despite making an honest attempt to focus and give it a shot. We did not vibe. 

In one of the essays she discusses review culture and Goodreads, (hiiiiiii) and uses the book American Dirt to illustrate how elitism and bad reviews in certain spaces didn’t translate to sales. Felt a bit egregious to discuss this book while completely ignoring the reason it received such backlash in the first place—the author misrepresented herself. She identified as white only until she started marketing this book and then mentioned a Puerto Rican grandmother when she realized it might be a problem. The book was called out for problematic storylines and stereotypical characters by Latinx authors and readers to rightly point out the problems with platforming and supporting a white author writing a book about Mexican migrants instead of choosing to support #ownvoices books with the same vigor and marketing budget. It was a big part of an important conversation and feels strange to talk about it in this capacity without any mention of that. It wasn’t elitism that was trying to discourage reading and platforming this book as much as it was marginalized voices expressing their discontent with the status quo, and actually it’s not a surprise at all that those issues would be ignored by most readers and do nothing to prevent it becoming a bestseller. I never read it for that reason.

This was towards the beginning of the book and was the moment I realized oooooh I’m not going to enjoy this one, nope nope nope! Especially when she writes with what feels like a very condescending air. I found the essays about review culture (minus the above) and auto-fiction interesting but not enough to balance out the tedious more personal ones about her life in Berlin, the movie Tár (haven’t seen it) and her anxiety. And I did not appreciate her opinions enough to make up for the general (for me) ick of her tone.

I’m sure there’s plenty of people who this collection might appeal to, but it was not for me. If you plan on reading it, you might want to avoid the audiobook.
emotional funny reflective fast-paced

Completely unputdownable. I now worship at the shrine of Anita De Monte. Forever obsessed. 

It’s been a minute since I’ve read a book that I haven’t wanted to put down and never wanted to end. I kept checking the time stamp bc no surely this can’t be almost over! I’m not ready! 

I was hooked, deeply invested in the lives of 80s Cuban artist Anita De Monte and 90s art history student Raquel. Both Latina women brilliant in their field but pulled into the orbit of privileged white male artists. Both seduced by the access and interest but soon pushing, resisting, contorting themselves to fit inside the gold encrusted bars of a gilded cage. When Anita falls from her NY apartment window, pushed by her art-titan husband Jack Martin, there is no justice. No, the ranks close and he is protected as so many men are, barely registering a blip in his career—while Anita is forced to watch in the afterlife as her artistic legacy languishes at his hands, and her memory fades. 

Meanwhile, in the late 90s, Raquel is working on a thesis on the same Jack Martin to impress her fanboy professor. When she learns about Anita and her work she begins to draw conclusions not just in Jack’s work, unable to escape his wife’s spectre, but also in the person she is becoming, the subject she really wants to study and invest in, and the vision of her future. How she plans to make her mark.

Anita De Monte is living, breathing, leaping off the page. I wish I could give an Oscar to this character, to Jessica Pimentel who voiced her in the audiobook, because damn. The passion! The commitment! I will hear her voice in my head for years. She was so funny, over the top, her rage was all our rage. I’d have followed her anywhere—spirit, ghost, bat, and back again. I haven’t loved a character this way in years.

Xochitl Gonzalez reimagines the life and afterlife of real artist Ana Mendieta here and her tragic death likely at the hands of Carl Andre. I only wish this had been made clear in the book itself, as I only found out from other reviewers. 

But, this book was everything. Absolutely fantastic. Favourite of 2024, this is the one to beat. Immediately buying the physical copy to keep.
challenging reflective sad slow-paced

I haven’t read There There yet, but I understand this is kind of a loosely related novel. I don’t think you need to have read Tommy Orange’s first book to appreciate it though.

Wandering Stars is a bit of a tragic meander through the history of one family traced from the Sand Creek Massacre of 1864 to Oakland 2018 in the aftermath of a mass-shooting at a pow wow that devastates the Redfeather family—sending one teen into a reliance on pain pills, his little brother into self-harm and their grandmother desperately mining her own culture for answers.

We come to realize addiction, hand in hand with the trauma of genocide and residential schools, the loss of cultural knowledge and family support, has been passed down generation to generation and finds a new form in every iteration like a many faced devil. It’s a challenging read, and sad, I appreciate that Orange kept a lot of the trauma that leads to the escapism of addiction at arms length, behind the glass of language and prose, it’s there but we’re not knee-deep in it. But, in doing so I often felt I was looking at these characters behind the same glass, never quite touching them.

I think he’s a beautiful writer, and I could see what he was aiming at with this book, but it was a slow process in mapping the constellations. I think this could have been a 5 star read for me if it felt tighter and more propulsive. If maybe a change in POV and less characters total would have allowed me to really feel connected to them. But, regardless it was an ambitious and beautifully written book that made me think about how far we’ve come as indigenous people just in surviving. And the way he wrote about addiction and recovery felt very real, insightful, and in a way, hopeful for the future too.

I’ll definitely be reading There There soon, too.

Thanks so much to @mcclellandstewart for the #gifted copy in exchange for my honest review.

funny lighthearted

This book has some scaaathing reviews on goodreads, but I actually enjoyed it. 

The Breakup Vacation is about 20-something college student Grace who has been broken up with her first serious boyfriend but remains in a situationship with him. When her two best girlfriends want to go on a trip together she manipulates them into picking Cancun so she can try to win him back since he’ll also be there. But, once there she meets local Daniel who also happens to be half-Taiwanese like her and a romance sparks, along with a whole lot of spicy encounters. Grace has to decide what her heart wants and needs while also trying to hide her manipulation from her friends. Hijinks ensue.

So let’s go over what other people hate about this book.

First, there’s a lot of complaints that the characters are shallow but, I feel like that’s romance par for the course, they usually are on the shallow side and that’s not often a problem for romance readers. So why be up in arms about it here? 

Second, they found the love story unbelievable. It’s over 5 days and there’s no crazy proposal or anything so I’m not sure why it’s an issue. I actually find it super believable as I am a mixed-indigenous person who also fell very fast in love with another mixed-indigenous person after never having dated someone like me before. Grace and Daniel are the same—and if you’ve never experienced that specific feeling of safety and coming home that comes with dating someone who understands your life story, references and experiences to a tee then no you probably wouldn’t get it. It’s instant intimacy. And I believed it wholeheartedly.

Third, they didn’t like how she manipulated her friends and/or the friend dynamic and/or the stereotypical representation of one of her French friends. I can understand the criticism here, but I felt the dynamic real to me—it felt very early-20s coded instant best friends but you don’t know if they’ll be in your life forever, sort of thing. When your friendship is based on drinking and going out together. I remember that! Millennials know! Drinking culture was huge!

This book was spicy spicy!! 🥵 I blushed so much! I’m not a spice girlie! I didn’t hate it tho 😏