Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
Wandering Stars
by Tommy Orange
challenging
reflective
sad
slow-paced
I haven’t read There There yet, but I understand this is kind of a loosely related novel. I don’t think you need to have read Tommy Orange’s first book to appreciate it though.
Wandering Stars is a bit of a tragic meander through the history of one family traced from the Sand Creek Massacre of 1864 to Oakland 2018 in the aftermath of a mass-shooting at a pow wow that devastates the Redfeather family—sending one teen into a reliance on pain pills, his little brother into self-harm and their grandmother desperately mining her own culture for answers.
We come to realize addiction, hand in hand with the trauma of genocide and residential schools, the loss of cultural knowledge and family support, has been passed down generation to generation and finds a new form in every iteration like a many faced devil. It’s a challenging read, and sad, I appreciate that Orange kept a lot of the trauma that leads to the escapism of addiction at arms length, behind the glass of language and prose, it’s there but we’re not knee-deep in it. But, in doing so I often felt I was looking at these characters behind the same glass, never quite touching them.
I think he’s a beautiful writer, and I could see what he was aiming at with this book, but it was a slow process in mapping the constellations. I think this could have been a 5 star read for me if it felt tighter and more propulsive. If maybe a change in POV and less characters total would have allowed me to really feel connected to them. But, regardless it was an ambitious and beautifully written book that made me think about how far we’ve come as indigenous people just in surviving. And the way he wrote about addiction and recovery felt very real, insightful, and in a way, hopeful for the future too.
I’ll definitely be reading There There soon, too.
Thanks so much to @mcclellandstewart for the #gifted copy in exchange for my honest review.
Wandering Stars is a bit of a tragic meander through the history of one family traced from the Sand Creek Massacre of 1864 to Oakland 2018 in the aftermath of a mass-shooting at a pow wow that devastates the Redfeather family—sending one teen into a reliance on pain pills, his little brother into self-harm and their grandmother desperately mining her own culture for answers.
We come to realize addiction, hand in hand with the trauma of genocide and residential schools, the loss of cultural knowledge and family support, has been passed down generation to generation and finds a new form in every iteration like a many faced devil. It’s a challenging read, and sad, I appreciate that Orange kept a lot of the trauma that leads to the escapism of addiction at arms length, behind the glass of language and prose, it’s there but we’re not knee-deep in it. But, in doing so I often felt I was looking at these characters behind the same glass, never quite touching them.
I think he’s a beautiful writer, and I could see what he was aiming at with this book, but it was a slow process in mapping the constellations. I think this could have been a 5 star read for me if it felt tighter and more propulsive. If maybe a change in POV and less characters total would have allowed me to really feel connected to them. But, regardless it was an ambitious and beautifully written book that made me think about how far we’ve come as indigenous people just in surviving. And the way he wrote about addiction and recovery felt very real, insightful, and in a way, hopeful for the future too.
I’ll definitely be reading There There soon, too.
Thanks so much to @mcclellandstewart for the #gifted copy in exchange for my honest review.