345 reviews by:

apricotjoy

Filter

I took a break shortly after beginning this book and put it down for almost a year. But then once I picked it up again I had finished it in less than a week. What a joy of a book to read! I wish I could dive back in and that the story didn't have to be over. The 2005 movie adaptation has been one of my favourite movies for a long time, and this is now one of my favourite books.

Also. Did I fall in love with Mr. Darcy myself? MAYBE.

Everyone should read this. I think a lot about how grief and pain manifest themselves in the body, and she gave me such a hopeful way of looking at it; I'm still thinking about it even a couple months after reading it. A strong, beautiful, and necessary book.

To start off, this book is very beautifully written. It really pulls you in and there were many sentences I re-read simply because they were so lovingly put together. However...sometimes it could be too flowery and it would distract from a scene. You don't need to wax poetic during a dangerous stand off, in my opinion. Get to the bones of what's happening! I think there can be an ebb and flow in a novel and it doesn't always have to be the same level of metaphors and deep thought all the way through in every scene.

It was so nice to read a story about a biracial main character (and a woman at that!), and to also have multiple BIPOC characters in the book. (side note: a few times someone was described as "brownish" and that was a bit annoying. you could say light brown? or many other descriptors? IDK.) I also really appreciated it dealing with issues of racism, wealth, and privilege.

I forced myself through the second quarter of the book but it really picked up in the second half as others have already mentioned. Once I got past the middle I couldn't put the book down and stayed up until 2AM so I could find out what happened!

But I wasn't particularly crazy about the ending, or the unexpected emphasis on romance -- it felt like it really undermined the whole message (or what I thought was the message) of independence, family, discovering yourself and the world.
Spoiler Is it really destiny to find yourself in someone else who you...barely know?? Bleurgh. And I was very annoyed by her writing the book for Samuel and the epilogue focusing on him when it had been her story the whole time.
The romances just weren't for me; they felt underdeveloped and a little forced.

Overall it was beautiful. I rolled along quickly until I finished and there were some very inspiring ideas and descriptions. I liked it; just not my favourite of all time.