627 reviews by:

yrsbrn

Filter

I love Auster and his writing style. I can’t ever place my finger on why, but it’s addictive.

This one took me on a few different twists and turns, and it subverted my expectations for the rest of the story every time I reset them. The title fits, and I’m already excited to dig into more Auster.

Overall I really liked the story Iles tells of Penn Cage, even if a lot of the appeal from its predecessor is based more on the racial tension and history of Natchez, whereas this one relies on the town being brought into modern (at the time) issues. The historical alignment just packs more significance into what Cage does as a lawyer/investigator.

I’d give this a solid 4 stars if not for some of the random diatribes some of the characters went on throughout the story. I don’t have a problem with the specific views they throw out there, but it seems like Iles wanted to make *very* specific statements about the world and sacrificed some natural plot progression and character development to fit them in. It only happens 2 or 3 times throughout the 644 pages, but it’s enough (and by way of significant characters) to stick out.

Definitely bought the book because of its beautiful cover art, but I deeply enjoyed the story it conveyed and how deeply connected it was from start to finish. A lot of anguish and self-exploration happens pretty efficiently, as we only get snapshots of the Gold siblings’ lives.

Knew nothing about this book going into it, and I think that enhanced my experience overall. It’s not a “must” to go in blind, but this is the kind of story I’d usually not seek out, and it ended with me very entrenched in and attached to the lives of Jack and Wynn. The imagery used throughout is vivid enough to make you feel like you’re part of their journey, without trying to sound too scientific in the way much of the environment and ecosystems are.

The main storylines were gruesome and more topical based on when the book was released, but some key characters are written bizarrely, to an extent that can easily detach you from the riveting plot. I found the climax a little disappointing, based on the timing in which the story starts wrapping up. It felt a bit rushed at around the 550-page mark, even if we do get *some* satisfying closure by the end.

Short and sweet, but once you get past the clunky introduction, it’s a tight, interesting story that seems to have its roots in many real, accurate issues.