1.1k reviews by:

wart

Filter

Things I Find While Shelving

I received a free ARC via NetGalley

I will say this for Kris Ripper, zir writing is really good and ze knows how to tell a story!

Overall I really enjoyed this one. I could see myself in Ed in a lot of ways - sometimes painful ways, especially when it came to his situation with his family. It's painfully similar to my own and was hard for me to read, which I count as a point in this book's favor.

As far as the story itself goes... I felt like Ed and Alisha were a bit over the top with their respective obsessions. Not to say people can't get caught up like they were but it felt like the story pushed it to the max simply so they could have that conflict. Which now I think about it is a very rom-com trope and maybe not actually that big of a problem.

Two nitpicks from me:

1. there's a tendency for authors not to mention if a character takes their binder off or not before they go to bed and it bothers me because sleeping in your binder is really dangerous and if they are sleeping in it I WANT CONSEQUENCES and if they're not please tell us so we know they're okay?!!

2. The scene with Ed's dad felt so unnecessary. It was brief and felt like it only existed so we could learn Ed's dead name? I couldn't figure out a reasoning beyond that. But like. Give me trans books where we never learn a character's deadname! Please? It's not necessary. it doesn't add anything. I kind of get that we needed Ed to have that after freak out, but I feel like there could have been a way to do it just as naturally without deadnaming him.

Overall, super cute romance.

Things I Find While Shelving

I received a free ARC via netgalley, forgot about it, and wound up getting this out from the library...but the point is I did have an ARC at one point...

There is a common misconception among cis people that if they want to understand the trans experience they must try to imagine what it would be like if they had always felt like the gender they are not. A better way to grasp it would be to ask what if you knew your gender but everyone else insisted you were wrong?

I feel like Dreadnought illustrates that masterfully because the first thing that happens to Danny is she gets the body she always wanted in the first place, but that doesn't change everyone else's perception of her. Parents and friends continue to act under the assumption that Danny is a boy. So Danny has to deal with coming out after transitioning - magical though that transition may be - which is an interesting path to navigate and one I think Daniels handles very well.

Overall I really enjoyed Dreadnought. Some things were frustrating, but they were frustrating because that's what they are: Danny's parents, her best friend, one of the superheroes being trans exclusionary. It's a book full of super powers and impossible technology, but it is also so relatable and real.

And I also just really loved it because superheroes.

The rep in this book is exactly what I want. Casual queerness. Non binary characters, binary trans characters, gay characters. Just. Characters who HAPPEN TO BE QUEER and it's NBD. It's exactly what I want, especially in speculative fiction.

Unfortunately the book itself fell flat for me. I could not immerse myself in this world. I was bored from the start and I couldn't get into it the entire time. I don't know if it's the POV-shifting - so much head hopping - or what but as much as I wanted to like this book because yes please give me casual queerness...I couldn't.