You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
HOW IS THAT IT?!
*insert gif with Castle being like "I have things to say...but no..."*
Seriously.
Okay.
I liked it, but it just kind of ends. Abruptly.
How can this possibly be the end?!
*insert gif with Castle being like "I have things to say...but no..."*
Seriously.
Okay.
I liked it, but it just kind of ends. Abruptly.
How can this possibly be the end?!
The good: interesting characters and world of which I would love to see more.
The bad: too much info dumping and summarizing of events. And then there were the pronouns. Frequently "He" meant Kaede, but sometimes "he" would crop up after a sentence with another male character as the subject and I would be like "Wait, what?!" for a few seconds.
PSA: if the subject of your new sentence is a different character than that of the previous sentence, just use their name. It's okay, readers don't mind.
The bad: too much info dumping and summarizing of events. And then there were the pronouns. Frequently "He" meant Kaede, but sometimes "he" would crop up after a sentence with another male character as the subject and I would be like "Wait, what?!" for a few seconds.
PSA: if the subject of your new sentence is a different character than that of the previous sentence, just use their name. It's okay, readers don't mind.
1.5 stars
There are quite a few good ideas here - the fantasy element could have been really interesting if developed a bit more, same with the relationships, the characters, and the De Vries issue.
But this story was really poorly written. It's almost entirely telling rather than showing with frequent summarizing of events. The dialogue was painful to read. The characters just kind of were, I didn't feel like there was any connection to them.
So, with a lot of work, this could be really great. Unfortunately, as is, it...isn't...
ETA: If you're just coming here to tell me that I'm ungrateful, please don't. I'm glad Roger was inspired by my prompt, I'm thankful to him for taking the time to write something based on it, but that doesn't mean I have to be dishonest about how I feel about his story.
But this story was really poorly written. It's almost entirely telling rather than showing with frequent summarizing of events. The dialogue was painful to read. The characters just kind of were, I didn't feel like there was any connection to them.
So, with a lot of work, this could be really great. Unfortunately, as is, it...isn't...
ETA: If you're just coming here to tell me that I'm ungrateful, please don't. I'm glad Roger was inspired by my prompt, I'm thankful to him for taking the time to write something based on it, but that doesn't mean I have to be dishonest about how I feel about his story.
That was better than anticipated.
And by "better" I mean "author has grasp of English language".
There isn't a ton of story here, just Aislinn being a wild child and needing to escape and be free with her Satyr love. But I didn't expect much story. It's erotica. With a satyr. I got what I expected.
With added hilarity due to Aislinnbeing eaten out while talking to her father's steward and trying not to give any clue that there's a Stayr under the table
So. Yeah. That was good for what it is.
And by "better" I mean "author has grasp of English language".
There isn't a ton of story here, just Aislinn being a wild child and needing to escape and be free with her Satyr love. But I didn't expect much story. It's erotica. With a satyr. I got what I expected.
With added hilarity due to Aislinn
So. Yeah. That was good for what it is.
I really wanted to love this. It's got everything I want: an interesting, well crafted steampunk world. Interesting characters. Mystery and murder.
But omg this is way too short. This whole idea needed to be a novel. A short story isn't enough space to fully develop everything that happens, and things wind up feeling rushed instead if intriguing and well developed.
Also, there're a lot of typos. Just misplaced words and missing words, but they're jarring, especially when it's more than occasional.
I will definitely check out more in this series.
But omg this is way too short. This whole idea needed to be a novel. A short story isn't enough space to fully develop everything that happens, and things wind up feeling rushed instead if intriguing and well developed.
Also, there're a lot of typos. Just misplaced words and missing words, but they're jarring, especially when it's more than occasional.
I will definitely check out more in this series.
A delicious taste of some colorful characters and the interesting lives they live. And by "interesting" I mean "piratical!" :)
Very well written. Sadly shorter than I'd have liked, but it's not rushed or anything, so the length isn't so much a problem as it is me wanting more of these characters.
Could use some careful line editing.
Definitely going to read more by this author!
Very well written. Sadly shorter than I'd have liked, but it's not rushed or anything, so the length isn't so much a problem as it is me wanting more of these characters.
Could use some careful line editing.
Definitely going to read more by this author!