Take a photo of a barcode or cover
506 reviews by:
thoughtsfromtheafro
I Think You're Wrong (But I'm Listening): A Guide to Grace-Filled Political Conversations
Beth A. Silvers, Sarah Stewart Holland
Disclaimer: I received an advance copy from the publisher/authors.
It reads just like the podcast sounds. Some parts I read in Beth's voice, some in Sarah's. I'm not big on Christianity, but the way it is incorporated is true to their personalities, and didn't make me feel like it was being impressed upon me. Those who don't already listen to the podcast will likely still feel a similar connection as they read.
I foresee the guiding questions at the end being helpful to many; They give good starting points, and to an extent, have some flexibility for adaptation to communication style preferences. A lot of what is said as far as how to go about conversations harkens back to people needing to take a good look at themselves, and do not only an initial "inventory" of themselves, but continuous reflection, so that they can have fruitful discussions.
It reads just like the podcast sounds. Some parts I read in Beth's voice, some in Sarah's. I'm not big on Christianity, but the way it is incorporated is true to their personalities, and didn't make me feel like it was being impressed upon me. Those who don't already listen to the podcast will likely still feel a similar connection as they read.
I foresee the guiding questions at the end being helpful to many; They give good starting points, and to an extent, have some flexibility for adaptation to communication style preferences. A lot of what is said as far as how to go about conversations harkens back to people needing to take a good look at themselves, and do not only an initial "inventory" of themselves, but continuous reflection, so that they can have fruitful discussions.
[Audiobook]
I loved this more than I though I would. I had heard about this book in my political circles, which struck me as a bit odd since it’s a memoir, and not one of a politician. It isn’t explicitly an academic book in regards to politics and the economy, but a social analysis, through a reflection on his own life. I would’ve liked more statistics and information, but I’m also a nerd; I could see discussions benefitting from a follow-up workbook/reading guide (like there is for The New Jim Crow).
This would be an eye-opening read for people of color, especially black people, who live on the east coast in metropolitan areas. It would add to the understanding of “types” of white people they (we) know of — since in our areas there are few who are low-income/poor in relation to POC. It would also help in understanding how someone like our current president, won that demographic’s votes in the 2016 election. A thought I had while listening, and one Vance comments on (overtly and not): exposure is so important.
I loved this more than I though I would. I had heard about this book in my political circles, which struck me as a bit odd since it’s a memoir, and not one of a politician. It isn’t explicitly an academic book in regards to politics and the economy, but a social analysis, through a reflection on his own life. I would’ve liked more statistics and information, but I’m also a nerd; I could see discussions benefitting from a follow-up workbook/reading guide (like there is for The New Jim Crow).
This would be an eye-opening read for people of color, especially black people, who live on the east coast in metropolitan areas. It would add to the understanding of “types” of white people they (we) know of — since in our areas there are few who are low-income/poor in relation to POC. It would also help in understanding how someone like our current president, won that demographic’s votes in the 2016 election. A thought I had while listening, and one Vance comments on (overtly and not): exposure is so important.
Something to pick up again and again. It brings a lot of calmness, and peace to my soul.
I also love the layout of the book (with her notes alongside text).
I also love the layout of the book (with her notes alongside text).
I love Pheebs and her podcasts, but this book/essay collection is NOT meant for reading, it's meant for listening. She wrote it the way she speaks, which is awkward to read on paper. I loved gettihg to learn more about her though, and read a biographical/journal/self-help type of book.
I felt extreme discomfort, sadness, anger, I'm not entirely sure, when I started the book. There's sonething about seeing what you have heard from oral histories from elders, in black & white. Reading this was like experiencing a hug filled with pain, from the ancestors. The word enjoy isn't entirely accurate, is it has a completely positive connotation - the closest thing I can say is that I *felt* thia book. Deeply.
Not what I expected, but a fine book nonetheless
This may be a good read for someone younger (which says a lot, given my age) and less associated with politics. There were some statements she made about Hillary being the first, that well...I wouldn’t say are entirely accurate. There’s definitely some “hat tipping” she could have done to women [of color] who broke ground and cracked ceilings, before Hillary was a household name. I think that’s what annoyed me the most about bits and pieces of it.
She included basic advice – lessons you’ll learn as you spend time at the grunt level and management level of politics. It’s also written very informally, so it doesn’t come across much like a teaching tool.
This may be a good read for someone younger (which says a lot, given my age) and less associated with politics. There were some statements she made about Hillary being the first, that well...I wouldn’t say are entirely accurate. There’s definitely some “hat tipping” she could have done to women [of color] who broke ground and cracked ceilings, before Hillary was a household name. I think that’s what annoyed me the most about bits and pieces of it.
She included basic advice – lessons you’ll learn as you spend time at the grunt level and management level of politics. It’s also written very informally, so it doesn’t come across much like a teaching tool.
My first audiobook (listened to at 1x speed). Narrator choice was perfect for the content.
This was good. An immense amount of detail and description for each person, relationship, and situation. It was hard at times to fully envision (which may have had to do with me listening to it and not reading it), but I appreciated the detail all the same. I found Gogol’s journey interestingly similar to some of the anecdotes I hear from my friends who are the children of immigrants here in the US, in regards to their attachment (and/or rejection) of their family’s cultural heritage. I do however, wish there had been just a bit more about Sonia’s life, more fleshing out of their relationship as siblings, and differences in their relationships with their parents.
This was good. An immense amount of detail and description for each person, relationship, and situation. It was hard at times to fully envision (which may have had to do with me listening to it and not reading it), but I appreciated the detail all the same. I found Gogol’s journey interestingly similar to some of the anecdotes I hear from my friends who are the children of immigrants here in the US, in regards to their attachment (and/or rejection) of their family’s cultural heritage. I do however, wish there had been just a bit more about Sonia’s life, more fleshing out of their relationship as siblings, and differences in their relationships with their parents.
The layout wssnt exactly how I anticipated, but I got so much out of it. I got many recommendations for other books and authors, and policies to look into. I think people forget that racism plays a huge role in the economy, and that pretty much everyone and everything had more value than people of color; Hopkins and his peers being responsible for a lot of the development of the city, means they are also responsible for putting profit before people.
As locstions are discussed, their current names are also identified, which is helpful for those who don't have a multigenerational view of thr city.
As locstions are discussed, their current names are also identified, which is helpful for those who don't have a multigenerational view of thr city.
1: I actually listened to the Epilogue. I [pretty much] never entertain the epilogue of books.
2: I teared up upon the end.
This was a closure that I didn’t know I needed, to the Obama presidency, and to their transition back into civilian life. Unlike some of my peers, I enjoyed the first sections about her childhood, young adult life, and her relationship with Barack pre-presidency, more than I did the time period of presidency and forward. There are so many thoughts, recollections, and details. Even Malia & Sasha’s personalities shine through, as she talks about them. I could picture many as I read, having been to some of the same areas and places; during other times, I think I subconsciously envisioned just sitting in a living room listening to her talk, like I used to do with the elders of my family.
2: I teared up upon the end.
This was a closure that I didn’t know I needed, to the Obama presidency, and to their transition back into civilian life. Unlike some of my peers, I enjoyed the first sections about her childhood, young adult life, and her relationship with Barack pre-presidency, more than I did the time period of presidency and forward. There are so many thoughts, recollections, and details. Even Malia & Sasha’s personalities shine through, as she talks about them. I could picture many as I read, having been to some of the same areas and places; during other times, I think I subconsciously envisioned just sitting in a living room listening to her talk, like I used to do with the elders of my family.
Hmm
I think I expected more from this, but it falls in line with the two documentaries I've seen regarding life in North Korea. Parts sound extreme and made up, but given even how the regime is now, I wouldn't be surprised if they were true (and what reason would he have to lie?).
This was a heartbreaking read; I hope that one day he'll have some peace.
I think I expected more from this, but it falls in line with the two documentaries I've seen regarding life in North Korea. Parts sound extreme and made up, but given even how the regime is now, I wouldn't be surprised if they were true (and what reason would he have to lie?).
This was a heartbreaking read; I hope that one day he'll have some peace.