506 reviews by:

thoughtsfromtheafro

Filter

I did an audiobook for this, with great anticipation. I wish I had read it instead. It annoys me that a white woman narrated such loaded works without the strength and emotion they deserved (given the content).

The content itself was quality, and reflects on everyday life and thoughts. She weaves black vs. white perspectives into many of the pieces, which adds a different depth, but isn’t jarring.

[Audiobook]

I spent a lot of tome going “yaaaas” as I listened to this book. I wish I had read it (listened to it) before ‘Everything is Trash’, but I still appreciated it greatly. Her infusion of data was unexpected, but seamlessly done, and never throwing off the flow of her experiences. As someone who has had and still has interesting interactions with others in regard to hair (I still duck and swerve when people raise their hand to reach out to my hair), this book hit the nail on the head — even when talking about other things. Ending with letters to her niece was a nice touch, and was very Phoebe; her personality comes through them in a different way than the rest of the book.

[Audiobook]
The pieces about scrabble threw me off like no other, but they did at least help me understand more about her and her personality, which then helps understanding her POV. She is blunt, and likely what some people would consider vulgar, but in reality, raw is probably more accurate. She is careful about her word choice, and her large vocabulary shines.

Overall, I enjoyed the latter half of the book more than the first half. I had different takeaways from each work, but the ones more explicitly about feminism and intersectionality gave a lot to chew on. I also greatly appreciated her book analyses; some of the books I had heard about, read, or plan to read, and I’m sure my subconscious will be working in the background as I read them and takes notes/reflections.

I loved this book more than I thought I would. The nerd in me loved how she weaved in policy possibilities at the state and national level. Even though she would discuss other concepts and initiatives, she was always able to bring it back to family leave.

Robin has packaged all that black women have been saying and experiencing for generations, into a palatable format for white women. She gives proper acknowledgement to her sources (shoutout to using so many POC/WOC), includes studies and empirical evidence, and references her first-hand experiences as a white woman calling out other white people on their [conscious and subconscious] complicity in racism.

Everyone needs to read this. Full stop.
People of color (black people specifically, of course), especially BW will feel validated, and WW especially, will (hopefully) unearth why they likely have very few (if any) deep, authentic friendships with WOC, and why we don’t see many who claim to be allies, as allies.



[Audiobook]

It’s possible that I would have marginally enjoyed this book more with a different narrator.

I anticipated relating to more in this book than I actually did. I attribute that to it being so white-centered (I mean, the author is white, but still); it gave me white feminism vibes the whole time. I thought there’d be more statistics and information, and would maybe be a more vulgar and dark/heavy read (listen), but alas that wasn’t the case.

It’s fine for background noise/reading while doing other tasks.