Take a photo of a barcode or cover
tashreads2manybooks's Reviews (1.06k)
Full review to follow: Some readers have classified this book as YA. It is NOT, I repeat, is NOT suitable for young readers. It is extremely dark and deals with some very disturbing adult themes. But riveting and haunting too.
I really wanted to love this book. The premise appealed to me. A teenage girl gets diagnosed with terminal cancer and decides to complete a ‘bucket list’ to pack as many new experiences into her tragically short life as possible. So although it is a depressing subject, I expected the book to be full of the joy of life.
Um, no. Do not be fooled. The bucket list was hardly featured in this novel at all. You never really get to see what made the list, and the things she does tick off mostly concern petty teenage revenge on her ex-boyfriend and ballet ‘frenemy.’
I don’t know about you, but my bucket list would include more of: “try every flavour Ben and Jerry’s ice-cream and make amends to those I have harmed” and less: “humiliate my ex-boyfriend and steal the dreams away from my high-school nemesis.”
Which brings me to the character of Alice (said bitter and petty teenage girl). She was horrid, horrid, horrid. I have not met a character that so annoyed me since the whiny and helpless Bella Swan of Twilight fame. I expected to have a degree of sympathy for Alice, considering her awful situation, but she was the most spiteful and selfish creature in my experience of YA fiction.
The way she uses (and abuses) her ‘love interest’ – Harvey, is appalling. She leads him on then blows him off. He is good enough to drive her places and keep her company when she is dying, but as soon as she finds out the cancer is in remission she feels too much pressure over his love for her and drops him like a hot potato. Not cool Alice!
And that is another thing – when any normal, sane person finds out their cancer is in remission, I expect there would be much whooping and cheering and happiness all around. But Alice seems disappointed she is going to live. Rather then seeing this as a second chance at living a better life, she sulks and moans and skips school. I really felt like slapping her and screaming: “Be grateful, you undeserving bitch!”
While I think my position on the main character is pretty clear, I liked Harvey. His only fault was loving Alice.
The story had so much potential, I am still reeling from my disappointment.
Um, no. Do not be fooled. The bucket list was hardly featured in this novel at all. You never really get to see what made the list, and the things she does tick off mostly concern petty teenage revenge on her ex-boyfriend and ballet ‘frenemy.’
I don’t know about you, but my bucket list would include more of: “try every flavour Ben and Jerry’s ice-cream and make amends to those I have harmed” and less: “humiliate my ex-boyfriend and steal the dreams away from my high-school nemesis.”
Which brings me to the character of Alice (said bitter and petty teenage girl). She was horrid, horrid, horrid. I have not met a character that so annoyed me since the whiny and helpless Bella Swan of Twilight fame. I expected to have a degree of sympathy for Alice, considering her awful situation, but she was the most spiteful and selfish creature in my experience of YA fiction.
The way she uses (and abuses) her ‘love interest’ – Harvey, is appalling. She leads him on then blows him off. He is good enough to drive her places and keep her company when she is dying, but as soon as she finds out the cancer is in remission she feels too much pressure over his love for her and drops him like a hot potato. Not cool Alice!
And that is another thing – when any normal, sane person finds out their cancer is in remission, I expect there would be much whooping and cheering and happiness all around. But Alice seems disappointed she is going to live. Rather then seeing this as a second chance at living a better life, she sulks and moans and skips school. I really felt like slapping her and screaming: “Be grateful, you undeserving bitch!”
While I think my position on the main character is pretty clear, I liked Harvey. His only fault was loving Alice.
The story had so much potential, I am still reeling from my disappointment.
I think I set myself up for a bit of a disappointment with this one. I LOVED the first two BJ books, they were some of the only books I re-read every now and then, so I expected a lot from Mad About the Boy.
I don't think I can ever really forgive Helen Fielding for killing off Mark Darcy . I don't think it was necessary. However, it was fun getting to know Bridget as a mother and 'cougar' in her fifties. In some ways she was the old Bridget, but I don't think the book reads like the 'old Fielding.' Some parts were just overly sentimental (esp bit at the end about the Owl) and the romance at the end of the book seemed a bit rushed (although I knew where it was going from the beginning)
Overall, I really enjoyed it - It made me laugh out loud a couple of times - but it won't be placed on the pedestal with BJ 1 and 2.
I don't think I can ever really forgive Helen Fielding for
Overall, I really enjoyed it - It made me laugh out loud a couple of times - but it won't be placed on the pedestal with BJ 1 and 2.
