Take a photo of a barcode or cover
529 reviews by:
shona_reads_in_devon
Showing DNF reviews ·
Clear filter
19 reviews
I think Tolstoy is not for me. I really enjoyed Ivan Ilyich but Anna Karenina was a slog. Life is too short to slog through 1200 pages. I think it might be the end of the road for me and Leo.
This book was fine. If I got to end, I feel like it was likely going to be a 3★ read.
But. It was a book club read. I didn't get to the end before my book club and I'm not really bothered to carry on after my book club tonight. It's super readable but I'm not that bothered by learning about what happens to her, I think I kind of know. It feels to me that she is one of those female characters written by men who are just a bit of a fantasy. I know the woman is several decades older than me but I just don't think she's a realistic woman, she's a man's ideal woman. The photos in this book are terrible and if she actually took photos that rubbish it's not a surprise she didn't do very well. I'm fed up reading about all her stupid decisions and not learning from her mistakes and also how every choice in her life appears to be related to a man. Dull and dull.
But. It was a book club read. I didn't get to the end before my book club and I'm not really bothered to carry on after my book club tonight. It's super readable but I'm not that bothered by learning about what happens to her, I think I kind of know. It feels to me that she is one of those female characters written by men who are just a bit of a fantasy. I know the woman is several decades older than me but I just don't think she's a realistic woman, she's a man's ideal woman. The photos in this book are terrible and if she actually took photos that rubbish it's not a surprise she didn't do very well. I'm fed up reading about all her stupid decisions and not learning from her mistakes and also how every choice in her life appears to be related to a man. Dull and dull.
I just can't do it.
I have been dragging myself through this series, it gives just enough to keep you interested while disappointing you enough to promise not to read the next one.
Well, I've reached my limit.
I'd have said, they got marginally better from first to third. I really hated the first one and then disliked the second one slightly less. The third one I disliked less than the first but more than the second.
As I suspected, all the plot drive that finally came to head in book three has disintegrated yet again into nothing in book four.
These books need some *serious* editing. I opened this one on Borrowbox and it's 700 pages long. I've managed probably less than 100 pages and I couldn't care less about any of these characters any more. NOTHING HAPPENS. I've had 10 chapters of Slade berating himself and whining and swearing. I literally couldn't care less.
You could have fit the last 3 books into one action packed book and still managed the same character development. It's so repetitive. I have definitely given this series enough of my time and so I'm out!
I have been dragging myself through this series, it gives just enough to keep you interested while disappointing you enough to promise not to read the next one.
Well, I've reached my limit.
I'd have said, they got marginally better from first to third. I really hated the first one and then disliked the second one slightly less. The third one I disliked less than the first but more than the second.
As I suspected, all the plot drive that finally came to head in book three has disintegrated yet again into nothing in book four.
These books need some *serious* editing. I opened this one on Borrowbox and it's 700 pages long. I've managed probably less than 100 pages and I couldn't care less about any of these characters any more. NOTHING HAPPENS. I've had 10 chapters of Slade berating himself and whining and swearing. I literally couldn't care less.
You could have fit the last 3 books into one action packed book and still managed the same character development. It's so repetitive. I have definitely given this series enough of my time and so I'm out!
DNF for me. I read about 80 pages. I don't want to read about a self centred, narcissistic, mysognisitic rich white man wallowing in self pity about his own self made disaster. Which isn't really a disaster at all and happens all the time. Maybe there is some great character arc, who knows. I'm not sticking round to find out.
I really tried to finish this. I was listening on audiobook but I am basically zoning out every 5 minutes because it's SO boring. How do you make a book about female pirates boring? I'll tell ya.
1. You spend almost as much time talking about men.
2. You also spend a lot of time with pointless filler about masts and boats. Did I come for a history of boats? No.
3. You undermine every story with a caveat that it was probably exaggerated or didn't even happen.
4. You struggle to decide what the tone of book is. Am I reading a serious scholarly work that's been well researched or am I reading a blog about the authors general guesswork and story telling?
I'm not sure what this was trying to be or do. There were points where it could have been something more interesting. Instead it's just a 'they did this and then they did that'. There is no real attempt to do anything useful with the information uncovered. It takes no time to reflect on any of the stories and when it does it's clumsy and poorly nuanced. It doesn't make any real commentary on sexism or the systems within which these women were operating. It doesn't feed into larger discussions about society or anything.
Really rubbish actually.
1. You spend almost as much time talking about men.
2. You also spend a lot of time with pointless filler about masts and boats. Did I come for a history of boats? No.
3. You undermine every story with a caveat that it was probably exaggerated or didn't even happen.
4. You struggle to decide what the tone of book is. Am I reading a serious scholarly work that's been well researched or am I reading a blog about the authors general guesswork and story telling?
I'm not sure what this was trying to be or do. There were points where it could have been something more interesting. Instead it's just a 'they did this and then they did that'. There is no real attempt to do anything useful with the information uncovered. It takes no time to reflect on any of the stories and when it does it's clumsy and poorly nuanced. It doesn't make any real commentary on sexism or the systems within which these women were operating. It doesn't feed into larger discussions about society or anything.
Really rubbish actually.
A DNF for me. I couldn't get into this. I gave it 81 pages. The writing didn't pull me in. It felt really contrived. I didn't find any of the characters interesting. Potentially a decent plot but I couldn't wade through the painful characterisation of Mary Cyr.
This book was absolute drivel. Reminded of The Pilgrims Progress a bit and that's all I need to say about that.
I don't feel like I can give this a bad review really. I don't think there was anything wrong with it. In fact it's well researched etc. Maybe I'm not in the right place for reading it just now. I found it a bit dull. Not usual for me. Perhaps I'll try it again another time.
I didn't get a chapter into this book before I stopped reading it. Why does she call everyone by their full name the whole time. Apparently, that's a bug bear I can't get past.
I've ummed and aahhed about finishing this and giving it a chance but, fuck it, life is too short.
The main character is a misery. I can get past that with good world building and maybe a dollop of psychology to let us know why on earth he's such a sodding moaner. But no. Everyone is like it for no seeming reason.
The world building started off interesting but is increasingly dull. It's suffering from the same sort of problems I had with Patrick Rothfuss in that teenage wank bank fantasy kind of thing where everyone's utterly miserable and worried about failure despite the obvious knowledge that they are all really good at what they do. Blah blah, no time for it.
And I don't need to have it pointed out to me that women have tits every single time one appears on the page. Yes, we do. Move along with your little spell please.
The main character is a misery. I can get past that with good world building and maybe a dollop of psychology to let us know why on earth he's such a sodding moaner. But no. Everyone is like it for no seeming reason.
The world building started off interesting but is increasingly dull. It's suffering from the same sort of problems I had with Patrick Rothfuss in that teenage wank bank fantasy kind of thing where everyone's utterly miserable and worried about failure despite the obvious knowledge that they are all really good at what they do. Blah blah, no time for it.
And I don't need to have it pointed out to me that women have tits every single time one appears on the page. Yes, we do. Move along with your little spell please.