590 reviews by:

salema

Filter
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

I spent the majority of the book frustrated with the characters. I didn’t enjoy any of them. The world building felt very incomplete and things were just happening and never being referenced again. Why was the dad so powerful? When did she dispose of Rami’s body? Who killed Layla? Was Rami a villain or nah? Maybe it would have benefited from multiple POVs. I was anticipating more of a payoff from the ghouls. Someone mentioned this being inspired by persephone and demeter but I’m not familiar with the story so all and all everything she did felt unnecessary and selfish. 

Womb City

Tlotlo Tsamaase

DID NOT FINISH: 8%

Lord of the Fading Lands

C.L. Wilson

DID NOT FINISH: 34%

This book hits all the points I was looking for. Sebastian is the perfect book boyfriend. And I love a mature couple who can express themselves! No third act break up is chef’s kiss. 

A good read but I was frustrated with a few aspects. A lot of time is spend rehashing the old books to jog our memory. It gets repetitive. I think fantasy books should have a nice synopsis of what’s happened in previous books that we can refer back to (like the Ending Fire series). Every description of a character having to repeatedly focus on gender was also repetitive. If Namina simply referred to them as “they” I think everyone would understand (I liked how it was done in Black Sun/Fevered Star- that felt natural and seamless) Also  the amount of “mind reading” that characters were doing with each other to move the story along felt lazy. I did enjoy the ending to this series overall. 

I’m an adult that reads a fair amount of YA but I don’t read middle grade books. This was listed as YA but is written how I imagine a middle grade book might be. So I may be looking at it through the wrong lens. Spoilers- 30% in and so far it’s very slowly paced for a fantasy. The first chapter is just describing a room. The second describes the castle/clothes/food. The third a garden. When something does happen it happens with very little actual conflict. Oh no I don’t have a name for the baby- I’m rescued from dealing with that by a man that spends a couple of paragraphs sending me on a quest that he knows will take exactly 10 years to prepare for-now I’m safe and I’m training but none of the training is described and I’ve got my found family and we didn’t have to go through any conflict to bond they just see me and decided we’re bffs now. 

After finishing-it just continues on its low stakes super convenient path. Just not for me.