I am obsessed!!

Man, I am completely in love with this series and all these characters. A perfect cozy read. If you want a cute fantasy/romance, pick these books!!

P.S. The audiobook narrator is a queen.

Loved the baking show aspect of this. But the murder mystery was lacking something. I still have so many questions about the multiple plot holes, but it was a fun, cozy read for the most part.

3.5 rounded up to 4

A really cute, whimsical book that I loved reading for the most part, because who wouldn't want to become the sidekick of their favourite author from childhood? Enjoyed the Wonka-esque character of James Masterson, the Clock Island, the riddles, and the adorable characters. But the book as a whole lacks depth, the characters are all wayyy too nice, the way everything wraps up is too far-fetched, and it was pretty predictable.

Probably would have been obsessed with this book as a pre-teen

Started off so well, but went downhill somewhere in the middle.