3.5 out of 5
I LOVE Finlay Donovan, so I was so excited about this. It was cute. Simple. Still had the personality that I love from the Finlay Donovan books. It's a novella, so it's short, but it felt rushed.

Awesome world. Awesome characters. I was drawn in right away, and really enjoyed every moment of this book. The main character was amazing!

I was looking for a book on Libby and came across this one and decided to give it a try, and I'm so happy I did! This book transports you to the 30's. The characters are wonderful and the romance warms my heart.

A SQUEAL?!?! UGH! It was so good. So dark and creepy. And that end? How am I supposed to last until the next book?

This breaks my heart. I love this series so much, but this book is NOT it. It's somehow too short? Everything happens so quickly that there feels like there's no tension. The antagonist wasn't strong. The multiple PoVs just didn't work and weren't needed. I'm so sad.

I'm listening to the book, and after 16 hours of listening, I couldn't tell you what the plot of this book is, so I decided to give up. I hate giving up on books because I feel like the book won, but I was just so bored, and I felt like the story was going nowhere, and I just couldn't keep going. I understood what each character was doing, but I had no idea what the over-arcing plot was or would be.
I really wanted to enjoy this book because I know that all my friends love it, and I do feel like I'm letting them down by not enjoying it, but I can't keep going on with this book. I'm so sad to be stopping, but I gave it a lot of time and have other books to read and listen to instead.

I'm hoping his other books are better because he is the most popular author amongst my friends, and I can't be the only person who doesn't like his books.

3.5
I'm so unsure how to feel about this book. It's good, with AMAZING writing, but it is slow and boring. It has a good plot with a very interesting main character, but the pacing just felt so slow.

WOW! Ouran High School Host Club! But with a main character that kinda annoys you. There's a talent show in this book, and it was not good. Plus the lack of communication got to me. Cute premise, at least.

I super enjoy this series. It's just a really good time. I think it's so funny with a great plot and great characters.