Take a photo of a barcode or cover
obscurepages's reviews
410 reviews
Diving back into the world of Raybearer universe was so interesting. Not only because I loved the Raybearer duology, but also because it would be fascinating to see what happens after the world has toppled the exploitative governments and people in power. Like yes, common people have taken back what's theirs and have ridden nobles. What's next after the revolution? Will they flourish? Will it stay the same?
Here in The Maid and the Crocodile, we have Small Sade and the Crocodile. Small Sade was such a compelling main character. And she's not a Chosen One, she's not a queen. She's a maid, an orphan. And I love that her journey perfectly showed us that we can choose to be something else or more. And that we deserve something better. Small Sade's story is a tale of discovering self-worth, allowing yourself to be angry at the system not designed to help you win, and still looking out for others and remaining grounded.
As for the Crocodile, Raybearer fans will know who he is! And yet, we still have a lot to know more about him. He was already so charming in Redemptor, but this story, I think, really built up his character and allowed him to fully complete his arc. Because while I liked him in Redemptor, there were some things about him that bothered me thenโthings that we could still see in him in this story. It was nice to see him realize those on his own.
Now, the story might be an extension of the Raybearer universe, but the problems were very much a reflection of the real world. Ableism, child labor still happening in different parts of the world, violence against women and pregnant women from their very own partners, class discrimination, and laborers being exploited and treated badly despite their significance in societies. It was all so real. And we see Small Sade live in a world where she has experienced and seen all of this, and we see how these have shaped her as a person and how these will impact her decisions in the future. Of course, it was also a good way to highlight how horrific these are in the world, bringing awarenessโand angerโto every reader.
As for the romance, this was just perfection. Because while Small Sade and the Crocodile had immediate chemistry, it took a while for their romance to simmer. And you know what? I'm quite alright with that. Sometimes, romance doesn't need to be flashy and bold; it needs to be patient. And that's what this was. Also I love that this book is being marketed as "romantic fantasy" and not romantasy. I think "romantasy" comes with both expectations and implications that wouldn't have fit The Maid and the Crocodile. Yes it did have romance, but it wasn't a big part of the plot that could alter the story altogether. And I don't know about others, but I really love my fantasy novels that way. ๐
And of course, let me mention the writing style and the overall storytelling, because this was just exquisite. This had minimal action (maybe even less action in Raybearer and Redemptor, nothing more than small instances of rioting and a building crumbling down, really). But the story held so much substance that you're never really bored. The way the author knows how to pull emotions out of you and steer you in the next direction after a plot twist is just so freaking good. Because how do you go from feeling giddy to feeling remorseful in one scene? ๐ And how do you write such a great plot twist in a fantasy, but it's like the calmest scene ever?? The author really knows how to tell a good story, hands down. So, hats off to her. Another thing, second person POV was also used here in a very unique way, and I think it really worked. Not only did it add to the storytelling, but it also had impact and significance in the right moments. I thought that was really clever.
If I had anything to nitpick, maybe I just wished that more justice was brought upon the villains of this book, particularly the ones who hurt Sade. But I kind of also understand why that wasn't part of the book. That wasn't the focus or the essence of the story. (I will hold a grudge for Sade lol, I hope [redacted] and [redacted] rots in hell).
Overall, this is such a powerful standalone fantasy in the same universe as Raybearer. I am so glad to have read it. ๐ฅน
(ALSO, SAPPHICS STAY WINNING YES)
Thank you so much to Abrams Books/Pique Beyond for sending an advanced copy my way! This, of course, did not impact my overall opinion of the book.
CW: pregnancy, childbirth, domestic violence, ableism, limb injuries, child labor, death of a parent, suicidal ideation, suicide attempts (off-page)
Moderate: Ableism, Domestic abuse, Death of parent, Pregnancy, Injury/Injury detail, Classism
Minor: Suicidal thoughts, Suicide attempt
Graphic: Child death, Death, Violence, Murder
Moderate: Panic attacks/disorders, Injury/Injury detail
Minor: Pregnancy
Graphic: Child death, Death, Death of parent, Murder
Moderate: Child abuse, Violence, Grief, Gaslighting, War
Also we see Human Inuyasha again! YES THANK YOU.
Graphic: Death, Violence, Blood, Murder
Minor: Homophobia
Moderate: Child death, Death, Mental illness, Grief, Death of parent
Minor: Violence, Blood, Injury/Injury detail
Love the character development in this ofc. The Red Tetsusaiga, Sesshomaru "saving" Rin, Inuyasha trying to protect Kohaku still.
There's also the underlying theme about humanity again. Naraku wants to cast out his human self so desperately. But we're (readers + Inugang) starting to see that being human is a different kind of strength, not something to be ashamed of.
And we finally meet the Band of Seven! Some of them at least. Jakotsu is finally here! And omfg I remember being confused if they're a boy or a girl, but I just know I really love the character design ๐ Of course now, I get my answer that he's a "flamboyant gay" (according to Google. Still, my headcanon is they're genderfluid/genderqueer ๐
Excited for the next volume!
Graphic: Death, Gore, Violence, Blood, Murder
Graphic: Body horror, Death, Gore, Violence, Murder, Fire/Fire injury, Injury/Injury detail
Moderate: Homophobia, Misogyny, Racism, Transphobia, Xenophobia
Minor: Bullying, Sexual assault, Sexual content
Three things stand out to me particularly: the poetic prose, the neurodivergent and mental illness rep, and the discussions on gender identity.
The prose is just amazing, and the writing style is so vivid. This book not only gives you incredible imagery (especially when talking about the lake and its magic), but also delves deep into the characters and their thoughts and emotions. I think the narrators also had a part in that, because they really did bring their characters to life. I could feel every emotion in every word as I was listening to the audiobook version. These two nonbinary, neurodivergent, brown kids are so precious and I loved reading/listening to their journey. In more ways than I imagined, I was able to relate to them throughout the book.
The neurodivergent and mental illness rep, I didn't really expect? Or maybe it's just been a while since I read the synopsis ๐ Either way, I thought these were so written so well. I could particularly relate with Bastian and their anxiety. And maybe that lead me to see the plot twist/moral lesson early? But I am definitely not complaining ๐ญ If anything, it just gave me more affirmation with how I try to deal with <i>*my*</i> own anxiety and stress. And I really really love that.
And of course, the queer rep in this book is just magnificent. There were discussions about gender identity, dysphoria, and experiences. And it just made me appreciate how there's really no singular experience or guideline in being queer or trans or nonbinary. No one can really tell us about our gender except ourselves โit's a spectrum, it comes in waves, and it's beautiful. (My favorite part definitely has to be Lore and Bastian talking about "gender forecasts", and in one scene Bastian says theirs is "nonbinary with a chance of stars" ๐ฅน)
This book is just really precious ๐ญ and it made me feel tons of emotions, so yes 5 stars ๐
This is also my first audiobook with Vico Ortiz!? Oh my beloved ๐ญ
Moderate: Ableism, Bullying, Racism, Transphobia, Dysphoria
Love Inuyasha's arc here. His demon self saves him in times of need, but he also realizes he loses himself (and his soul) every time he transforms. And then he realizes he doesn't want that, especially if he can't protect Kagome ๐ญ I think he's come a long way, and we see just how much Kagome has changed him and how he realizes what he wants because of her.
One of my favorite arcs in the anime is Kagome being controlled by the Dark Priestess. Making Kagome kill Inuyasha, nostalgic of how Kikyo was made to kill him? Priceless ๐ญ but also it shows how strong and how different Kagome is, and how she's her own person. Not a reincarnation, not a twin, or whatever.
Also I'd like to add! Found family is kind of a big theme in this installment as well! Like the characters are realizing how much they've changed and how they're not alone anymore because they have friends now. I love that.
Graphic: Gore, Violence, Blood, Murder
For one, Rumiko Takahashi keeps making hot villains and monsters omg how am I supposed to NOT root for them ๐ Kidding aside, the art and character design just slaps.
Another is that, apparently this is the volume that hurt me the most as a kid in the anime ๐ I'm talking about Inuyasha "choosing" Kikyo and Kagome accepting that she will always come second and staying beside Inuyasha's side even though it hurts her. Like that hurt me as a kid/teen. Unrequited love is so fcking painful, I don't wish it on anyone. Still I remember being a bit mad at Kagome for being a martyr and a masochist. But I was also mad at Inuyasha for not being straight with Kagome.
HOWEVER, reading the manga now, I keep wondering, does Inuyasha even love Kikyo? All his thoughts and POV seem like he feels immense guilt and moral responsibility or obligation to Kikyo so he needs to protect her, rather than needing to protect her because he loves her. And this guilt and responsibility definitely clouds his judgement. Apparently he would "go to hell" with Kikyo if that's what she wanted? That doesn't sound like love to me ๐ญ and yet, he also admits, he feels "calm and light" with Kagome. Tell me right now who is he really supposed to be with ๐ญ๐
What happened to Kikyo and Inuyasha fifty years ago was tragic and disgusting (on part of Naraku manipulating the whole thing). But it's clear that this will affect their actions and decisions further, and create a truly complicated situation between Inuyasha, Kagome, and Kikyo.
Also demon Inuyasha finally appears in this volume! ๐ Human Inuyasha still has my heart tho. Oh and more Kohaku arc in the next one!
Graphic: Gore, Violence, Blood