1.09k reviews by:

mathildur

Filter

Suddenly Ijichi became a much more complex character! I really enjoyed these short stories. They read like fanfiction in a sense, they sort of fill out the characters a bit more and allow us to see them goofing around and going about their lives. Definitely enjoyable! The character art added a lot as well. 

I'll admit crime isn't my cup of tea normally, but this just felt so dull? The thrill that I've come to associate with the genre wasn't there for me, and there were wayyyy too many characters to try and remember. Maybe I'm just too forgetful a reader for stories like these, idk. It didn't quite work for me. 

I can see what this was trying to do, but it just didn't work. I did enjoy the twist towards the end, but man oh man did it come way too late. I'd been struggling through several hundred pages of "what's the point??" with three romances happening at the same time. It was just chaotic and impossible to keep the characters straight. Maybe it would have worked better with "just" two romances? Idk. It didn't work for me. The ending was clever, but it couldn't make up for the rest of the book. 

My experience could also have been colored by my expectations though, to be fair. I was excited to read a romance mystery with a missing man and three dates looking for him. This was not that. 

This was phenomenal! I was teary-eyed through the entire book. It's not quite as out-of-this-world as the first one, but it's definitely not far off. I loved Ari's friendships and the way his relationship with his parents grew throughout the book. I hate hate hated the thing that everyone who read this knows about, I cried so much. Ari has my entire heart. I can't wait to reread these books in a few years time. 
emotional inspiring reflective

Second time reading:

I've read this before and I still cried at the end. This is such a lyrical masterpiece of a contemporary YA novel! I feel so strongly for Ari, probably because I would have related to him in a way when I was that age. Now I'm so stoked for the sequel, which I haven't read before!! I cannot wait to spend more time with Ari and Dante, enjoying Sáenz's wonderful writing. 

I'M NOT CRYING, YOU'RE CRYING!!! aasdjabgabogphnj 

Okay fine, I admit it. Tendo is very cool. Also, the suspense is KILLING ME! I need breathing exercises to get through this. Pls come back Tsukishima I miss you. 

The backstory!!! Okay I'm getting hooked now, I wanna know more about Ryang-Ha The First and the guy now carrying the name, what happened there?? 

Hmmmm okay the story is picking up! Interesting to learn a little more about Ryang-Ha and his backstory, he somehow became even more mysterious. 

We-ell, that got dark. I kind of feel like this isn't really progressing though? Like, they keep being kidnapped by random people and then in the next volume they'll get out and we're back to square one?