955 reviews by:

lslanker

Filter

Nimona is the story of a hero, a super villain, and a new sidekick told in the form of a graphic novel. Originally published as a web comic, the story tells of a spunky girl and her unusual powers to shape shift. Nimona is introduced to the story as she finds Lord Ballister Blackheart, a villain whose original plan of becoming a hero was foiled when he was shot in the arm by his best friend, Ambrosius Goldenloin. With themes of friendship, loneliness, and the blurred lines between good and evil, this story goes much deeper in its plot than many other graphic novels. The book contains illustrations that are detailed without being too overwhelming and uses the pictures to advance the story and give clues to the reader. For example, pink is Nimona's color, so you are always able to tell which animal she's shape-shifted into by looking for the color pink.

This is a longer graphic novel with many important themes, which makes it appropriate for middle school students. Lord Blackheart is a scientist at heart, and the book touches on genetic modification and mutations, making it easily integratabtle into a science classroom. I would also use it to introduce the idea that good and evil can sometimes be relative terms. I found this book because it is a National Book Award Finalist.

While we certainly need to understand that Little Red Riding Hood was written in a much earlier time and therefore may not match today's quality standards for a story, I do not think that this version is one I would share with my students. In the story, the girl meets a wolf in the woods and he tricks her into challenge that he knows he will win. The story does not have the happy ending of many modern tales, and the wolf ends up eating both the grandmother and the girl.

While I do not have an issue with this ending, I do have an issue with the moral of the story. The moral is explicitly stated and starts out by saying, "Children, especially pretty, nicely brought-up young ladies, ought never to talk to strangers." While this sounds innocent, I think it reinforces the idea that young ladies should be taught to be as vulnerable as possible and fear all large men, especially if they are not as nicely brought up as they are. At its worst, the story comes off as discriminatory based on class and reinforces the ideas that the classes should never mix.

The story is extremely short (three pages) and has themes on naiveté and fear of strangers.