You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

755 reviews by:

lindajyyc

Filter

this is second time I started this book. I found it difficult in first chapter to figure out who the key characters were. stopped reading on page 19

A believable read...I was surprised by my assumption that there wasn't suburbia living around NYC. Family dynamics with an interesting twist. I know I will do anything for my children now all adults.

A well told story that had me cringing, crying and celebrating. Marvelous description of the geography along with strong characters. I give it a strong recommendation to read!

For me this book had to be read slow and carefully because of the many cultural differences to understand and the many landmarks with significance to the story line that have to be remembered. I am glad I took the time though - the story is powerful regarding internal family dynamics in a very strict cultural world; yet there is a story line of women breaking with their traditional roles. I believe this is the first time I read a book set in the Ming Dynasty - the inclusion of this political background to the family decisions made added to the depth of the story. Well done!

enjoyed the strong friendships of the students and the evolving adult relationships.

an ordinary read with over-thinking main character. I was not convinced of how the club tried into the plot line.