I was disappointed in this title. I liked the idea of a dead school of ghosts connecting to the living world and a girl stuck being on the wrong side of where she wants to be. It just never cam to fruition. The writing was ho-hum and so was the story line.

I liked it, but not enough to read the rest of the sereis. Would be better as a Saturday morning TV Series.

I loved this entire series. I can not wait to read the next series by this author.

Loved this book. Reminded me too much of my own extended family.

This is by far my favorite John Green. A geeky teenage boy trying to find the perfect mathematical equation for love, when all he has ever loved has been girls names Katherine (17 total so far). Maybe its because my cousin keeps dating girls named Brandi that I find a close connection to this book. It will make you laugh, think, and maybe even cry (depending on how much of a sap you are).

I read a review that said this book was Gossip Girl 100 years in the past, and that was a perfect description. While the story moved quickly and kept you wanting to read til the end, I found it too formulaic and I had the ending guessed before the title was 1/3 of the way through.

I read this book and had high hopes, but they were dashed. The ending came to quick and I wished the author had dug into this society she created more then what was done.

Apparently this is an old story with new pictures. I have never heard of this story, so I have nothing to compare it to (trust me that’s a good thing). This is a story of a little girl who is picked on by a mud puddle. She gets to take so many baths and it is all the mud puddle’s fault. I thought the story was cute. I love how she gets back at the mud puddle. This is a title I will have to put in my library.

4 Stars

This book had some neat ideas, and simple instructions. I hope the real book has a different cover from the galley.