You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
710 reviews by:
kaylaramoutar
what am i supposed to do now?????
reread nov 25 2019: y'all i still love this book!!!!!!
/////
OKAY!!!!!!!!
I don't have a rating on this yet because it's so goddamn fresh in my mind that I feel like anything I choose is going to be a rash decision. But it's somewhere between 4-5. I might rate it after I read the third one (which I am picking up from the library TOMORROW aka TOO LONG FROM NOW) (edit: dec 4: 5!!!)
I don't want to spoil anything but like. Y'all. Y'ALL. The plot of this book was insanely good, eons and eons better than the first one, and the love story was.....sdfghjk !!! The slow-build, the flirtations... guuuuuuys. One thing - Maas' writing when the characters talk about sex or flirt is better than her actual sex scenes but like, they're fine. It's not really a complaint I'm just sayin'. Also books (especially fantasy) are generally better, to me anyway, when the main plot isn't the romance.
Feyre is an incredible character in Mist and Fury. She was... not bad in Thorns and Roses but she kind of lost herself (whether it was on purpose or Maas lost her, idk).
I like ... really really hate YOU KNOW WHO - again, don't wanna spoil anything - but oh my GOD. The parts he was in I was getting physically angry reading them. That's good writing.
I really enjoyed the new characters, especially Mor and Cass. Azriel is suuuper interesting and I gotta know more. I also somewhat wish the Bone Cleaver (was that its name?) shows its creepy head again because that whole scene was ... so good. Feyre's bravery!!!!!! My GIRL!!!!!!
Piece of advice: try to have the third book before you finish book two because while the ending isn't reeeeally a cliffhanger it's still.... a lot. And you're gonna want the next book right away. Trust me.
Okay bye I'm going to go suffer until tomorrow when I can reunite with these characters again.
/////
OKAY!!!!!!!!
I don't have a rating on this yet because it's so goddamn fresh in my mind that I feel like anything I choose is going to be a rash decision. But it's somewhere between 4-5. I might rate it after I read the third one (which I am picking up from the library TOMORROW aka TOO LONG FROM NOW) (edit: dec 4: 5!!!)
I don't want to spoil anything but like. Y'all. Y'ALL. The plot of this book was insanely good, eons and eons better than the first one, and the love story was.....sdfghjk !!! The slow-build, the flirtations... guuuuuuys. One thing - Maas' writing when the characters talk about sex or flirt is better than her actual sex scenes but like, they're fine. It's not really a complaint I'm just sayin'. Also books (especially fantasy) are generally better, to me anyway, when the main plot isn't the romance.
Feyre is an incredible character in Mist and Fury. She was... not bad in Thorns and Roses but she kind of lost herself (whether it was on purpose or Maas lost her, idk).
I like ... really really hate YOU KNOW WHO - again, don't wanna spoil anything - but oh my GOD. The parts he was in I was getting physically angry reading them. That's good writing.
I really enjoyed the new characters, especially Mor and Cass. Azriel is suuuper interesting and I gotta know more. I also somewhat wish the Bone Cleaver (was that its name?) shows its creepy head again because that whole scene was ... so good. Feyre's bravery!!!!!! My GIRL!!!!!!
Piece of advice: try to have the third book before you finish book two because while the ending isn't reeeeally a cliffhanger it's still.... a lot. And you're gonna want the next book right away. Trust me.
Okay bye I'm going to go suffer until tomorrow when I can reunite with these characters again.
Ahhhh. What a good book. I enjoyed it almost as much as Mist and Fury and was really happy with the ending.
It's hard to review the novel without spoiling anything so I'll just make a couple of points.
I absolutely loved Feyre in this novel. I think she wholly herself and I loved it. Cassien, as always, broke my heart again and again, and when he finally admits to Feyre how mad he was post-Hybern.. it felt so raw and real; I could understand his anger and hurt and also how Feyre felt. It just felt so real. What I like most about this series is how complex the characters are. Every single male is complex and brimming with some sort of ...emotion, and sometimes I find that a lot of fantasy novels have the male characters lack that. And every single female character is her own self. (Feyre was kind of lost in Thorns and Roses but I forgive her).
Anyway. Feyre's family felt like mine by the end. The speech before the battle actually reduced me to tears. The emotion in it and the way Feyre was feeling during it, just the way it was written, knowing that everything was on the line just got to me. Then once I kept reading I was on the verge of weeping for the rest of the book, which is like, mildly embarrassing, but definitely the mark of great writing.
Maas creates such well-rounded characters that, even now, I'm finding it hard to believe they aren't real people. That's what has gripped my mind/heart with this series. They're just so real.
I'm so excited to see what happens to Feyre and her family in 3.5. I am also devastated we have to wait until 2019 to get the fourth book - who is it going to be featuring???? - and will probably not make it. Wish me luck.
It's hard to review the novel without spoiling anything so I'll just make a couple of points.
I absolutely loved Feyre in this novel. I think she wholly herself and I loved it. Cassien, as always, broke my heart again and again, and when he finally admits to Feyre how mad he was post-Hybern.. it felt so raw and real; I could understand his anger and hurt and also how Feyre felt. It just felt so real. What I like most about this series is how complex the characters are. Every single male is complex and brimming with some sort of ...emotion, and sometimes I find that a lot of fantasy novels have the male characters lack that. And every single female character is her own self. (Feyre was kind of lost in Thorns and Roses but I forgive her).
Anyway. Feyre's family felt like mine by the end. The speech before the battle actually reduced me to tears. The emotion in it and the way Feyre was feeling during it, just the way it was written, knowing that everything was on the line just got to me. Then once I kept reading I was on the verge of weeping for the rest of the book, which is like, mildly embarrassing, but definitely the mark of great writing.
Maas creates such well-rounded characters that, even now, I'm finding it hard to believe they aren't real people. That's what has gripped my mind/heart with this series. They're just so real.
I'm so excited to see what happens to Feyre and her family in 3.5. I am also devastated we have to wait until 2019 to get the fourth book - who is it going to be featuring???? - and will probably not make it. Wish me luck.
3.5
I'm writing this review after finishing ACOMAF and ACOWAR - it's going to be difficult to write a review for this novel without spoiling anything so I'll keep it short.
A Court of Thorns and Roses is a loose retelling of The Beauty and the Beast and I think Maas did a great job with it. The reason my rating is only a 3 is because the plot was boring throughout the middle and because of how Feyre acted within that middle. After having some months to think about it - I read this book in November and it's currently January - I've determined that it was a good decision to have Feyre lose herself. Originally I thought Maas had lost her; she was doing things that felt out of character (ooc) and it seemed like all her spunk, all the stuff that made me want to root for her, disappeared. After reading the sequels and having some time to think about it, I realized there was a point to it, and it no longer bothered me.
The world-building is very interesting and pointed (especially in regards to the following books). Readers get just enough to intrigue them but not enough that they're inundated with knowledge and it overwhelms them.
The whole Under the Mountain scene was, to say the least, incredible. This is especially true when you look back - sorry, I can't help myself - and see how smart and strong, and scared, Feyre is.
Originally I was slightly disappointed - strong word, but can't find a better one - with this book but over time it's grown on me a lot. I'm planning on rereading it soonish; I'm interested to see how I find it after knowing what I know.
Final thoughts: If you find this book hard to get through or uninterested once you finish it, please at least try the second book. It was A LOT better and I absolutely loved it (and the third one!), so just... try them. They're worth it, I promise.
I'm writing this review after finishing ACOMAF and ACOWAR - it's going to be difficult to write a review for this novel without spoiling anything so I'll keep it short.
A Court of Thorns and Roses is a loose retelling of The Beauty and the Beast and I think Maas did a great job with it. The reason my rating is only a 3 is because the plot was boring throughout the middle and because of how Feyre acted within that middle. After having some months to think about it - I read this book in November and it's currently January - I've determined that it was a good decision to have Feyre lose herself. Originally I thought Maas had lost her; she was doing things that felt out of character (ooc) and it seemed like all her spunk, all the stuff that made me want to root for her, disappeared. After reading the sequels and having some time to think about it, I realized there was a point to it, and it no longer bothered me.
The world-building is very interesting and pointed (especially in regards to the following books). Readers get just enough to intrigue them but not enough that they're inundated with knowledge and it overwhelms them.
The whole Under the Mountain scene was, to say the least, incredible. This is especially true when you look back - sorry, I can't help myself - and see how smart and strong, and scared, Feyre is.
Originally I was slightly disappointed - strong word, but can't find a better one - with this book but over time it's grown on me a lot. I'm planning on rereading it soonish; I'm interested to see how I find it after knowing what I know.
Final thoughts: If you find this book hard to get through or uninterested once you finish it, please at least try the second book. It was A LOT better and I absolutely loved it (and the third one!), so just... try them. They're worth it, I promise.
WOW.
I don't want to say much because I don't want to spoil this but OH MAN!!!!!! If you're looking for a fantasy novel that has all the markings of a Good fantasy novel while being fresh and exciting, this is the book for you.
Adeyemi is an excellent storyteller. I was pulled into this world instantly and can't wait to go back when the sequel is out next year. I really liked that the reader learns about Orïsha and its history throughout the novel instead of getting a massive info-dump at the front. I found it helped create tension that furthered the plot. Also, quickly: this had a typical plot - going up against royalty to get back what is/was rightfully theirs - but it was done so well, so differently, that it wasn't tired or boring.
I absolutely loved it. I think technically maybe I'm rating it 4.5 (I finished it last night so it's super fresh in my mind and thus I'm like 5! 5! 5!) because there was one (1) tiny little plot line that I found weak, but, like, overall a 5. Read it.
I don't want to say much because I don't want to spoil this but OH MAN!!!!!! If you're looking for a fantasy novel that has all the markings of a Good fantasy novel while being fresh and exciting, this is the book for you.
Adeyemi is an excellent storyteller. I was pulled into this world instantly and can't wait to go back when the sequel is out next year. I really liked that the reader learns about Orïsha and its history throughout the novel instead of getting a massive info-dump at the front. I found it helped create tension that furthered the plot. Also, quickly: this had a typical plot - going up against royalty to get back what is/was rightfully theirs - but it was done so well, so differently, that it wasn't tired or boring.
I absolutely loved it. I think technically maybe I'm rating it 4.5 (I finished it last night so it's super fresh in my mind and thus I'm like 5! 5! 5!) because there was one (1) tiny little plot line that I found weak, but, like, overall a 5. Read it.