710 reviews by:

kaylaramoutar

Filter

3.9

The issue with this book is that it would have been better off being a duology. I think it's a decent attempt at a debut; the writing is good, most of the characters are fleshed out (well enough), and there were enough twists that it can keep people guessing without being ridiculous. The plot itself, and the romance specifically, felt very rushed. I felt little to no chemistry between the characters which was a shame because they were interesting on their own - it would have been great to feel their yearning for each other.

Part of the reveal was ... meh, and the other part was cool. I think that's what's keeping me from rating this higher: had a lot of potential, fell a little short of the mark.

Regardless, I'll be checking out what Astrid Scholte writes in the future!

SPOILER:
I will not be putting this on my lgbt shelf because we never see the lgbt characters together/alive.


Thanks to NetGalley and G.P. Putnam's Sons Books for providing me with a copy in exchange for an honest review.

I think this book would have been better off being longer at times and shorter at other times.

To explain: we got a lot of information about this world very quickly and it made it hard to follow. Whose decision was it to separate the countries(?) the way they were, where did the ability to have gifts come from, how often did this auction happen and how long had it been going on? And then in the other countries: this places seems just the same as the other one, why are they different places? Who decided to put Sifters in charge when they were clearly the most dangerous ones? Etc etc. I wanted more information and I wanted it to make sense. The climax of the story itself was incredibly rushed and I felt like I was cheated out of a proper villain-goes-down scene.

The insta-love was bothersome. Sometimes it works! But in this novel it felt like Etta hated him and then very suddenly with absolutely no warning she loved him. I think his reaction to her reveal was childish yet accurate and was disappointed in how quickly he got over it.

I found Etta's personality all over the place; sometime she was likable and other times she was annoying and immature. She was 17 and had been on her own/taking care of an orphan for years, she should have been more mature.

The basic idea of the novel (memories as currency) is definitely intriguing but ultimately the execution of it left a lot to be desired.


Thanks to NetGalley and Blink for providing me with a copy in exchange for an honest review.

I flew through this! THE ESCAPE ROOM is a thriller/mystery set in two sections: third person which features four (despicable) people stuck in an elevator escape room, and first person featuring Sara Hall, who worked with said four despicable people. The novel goes between the sections; I liked the way we didn't get too much in the elevator at once. It felt apt for a thriller: will they or won't they get out?

Most of the characters were unlikable as hell, but that felt right for the novel. They are Wall Street bankers. I liked Sara, and I quite liked Lucy. I wish we had got more of the latter, but alas. It wasn't meant to be.

This novel isn't particularly new or fresh, but it was enjoyable. If you're looking for a quick thriller that is a little different than the rest, check it out.

Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for providing a copy of THE ESCAPE ROOM in exchange for an honest review.