710 reviews by:

kaylaramoutar

Filter

Idk about the rest of you but I'm really ... tired. Specifically tired of the fact that main female characters in YA (written by men) are all the same. Two things: 1) I find they usually lack any sort of actual complexity because woman are one-dimensional apparently, and 2) they are always the outcast. They always only have one, mAYBE TWO friends. They're ""weird"", they have "quirks" that make them Oh So Cool (ALL GIRLS HAVE QUIRKS!!!!), but they're Distant. Her best friend is a boy and he's in love with her. Another boy speaks to her once and is now also in love with her because she's suddenly the most beautiful girl in the world. Girl doesn't know her best friend is in love with her. Girl suddenly starts seeing other boy as Potential Love Interest despite knowing him (more than another face in class) for .6 seconds. Love triangle ensues. It's TIRED. I'm TIRED. And while I'm on the topic - how come every. single. other. female character (the girl's peers, not parents) is a bitch? Is super pretty and super bitchy and super popular? WHY. WHYYYYyyyy. (And also, we're told: the "chubby" girls are "plain" looking, and all the "skinny" girls are "pretty". Come on.)

ANYWAY. Min isn't the worst I've seen, but she's not great. There was so much promise going into this novel as well because of the plot!! I thought, "I'm so excited to see how she deals with dying every 2 years and how she deals with the fact she can't tell anyone!" and what I got was... not exciting. She deals with it okay, but that seems to be all she has? And I get that like, it's a huge issue. It's massive. Some dude shows up and murders her on her birthday, I get that it would be a main focus of her character, but besides that she was completely flat. She had no other characteristics imo. I found her bland, and I found she lacked a real personality.

Although, if I'm being honest none of the characters were complex, none of them had a real personality to me (except maybe Ethan actually? And Tack.) so maybe it's not just Man Can't Write Teenage Girl. Who knows. Anyway I had hope for Noah but he.... went downhill fast. I guess you could call him complex because he was "living two different lives" but... yeah it wasn't great. I found that a lot of his decisions towards the end didn't even make sense for who he was as a person.

The big reveal was disappointing to me and I found that it didn't explain to the readers enough of what was happening even though it seemed like the characters suddenly knew everything. It seemed very rushed. I've see a lot of reviews saying that didn't know it was part of a series and I say: I'm so sorry. I would've been even more annoyed if I had read this not knowing there were going to be more. I don't know if I'm going to read the sequel. I want to because I'm curious to see if any of these characters become likable and the plot OVERALL is very interesting, but I also don't because of everything I've said above.

Also another quick lil mention - the fact that there's a part that goes (paraphrased): "The four black kids in our school. Yes, we all know the count. Welcome to Idaho." This is stupid and lazy. I can't even begin to explain this because I just.. can't... but it's lazy and annoying.