Take a photo of a barcode or cover
194 reviews by:
jotundottir
It's been a while since I read thriller/crime book, overall this was a nice experience but I felt a bit disappointed too. I think this is a nice light read if you need/want something need, a change of pace or similar.
While the book generally has a good pacing that can keep you interested most of the time, and hooked in many occasions, at times it suddenly stops and adds lots of details, characters and information that I don't really think help develop the plot nor the characters. Some are minor details like mentioning someone got a house from someone from an old case, I don't know if this is meant for people that follow the series to feel there's a connection between the books/world, but to me it felt very random, and if it was just that then it's okay, but after reading many other things that seem to be there just to increase the page count, even minor things feel tedious.
Something I quite liked was how I felt like I had information to solve every mystery, or at least to feel it made sense because I remembered reading it before, things like the clothes people were wearing or how the behaved. This is something I hoped the book did well, because I really dislike mystery books that seem to make up half of the things at the end just so the story makes sense. There was only one thing I didn't fully like regarding the main plot/mystery, spoilers ahead.
SpoilerI likes being right about how the writer (I am really bad at names, sorry, and in this book they were specially confusing) stole the work from Lola, all the hints were there. But the fact it was actually his wife who killed Lola and how all that is explained feel way too convoluted for my taste, it makes less sense than if it was that he killed her for the books and done.
While the book generally has a good pacing that can keep you interested most of the time, and hooked in many occasions, at times it suddenly stops and adds lots of details, characters and information that I don't really think help develop the plot nor the characters. Some are minor details like mentioning someone got a house from someone from an old case, I don't know if this is meant for people that follow the series to feel there's a connection between the books/world, but to me it felt very random, and if it was just that then it's okay, but after reading many other things that seem to be there just to increase the page count, even minor things feel tedious.
Something I quite liked was how I felt like I had information to solve every mystery, or at least to feel it made sense because I remembered reading it before, things like the clothes people were wearing or how the behaved. This is something I hoped the book did well, because I really dislike mystery books that seem to make up half of the things at the end just so the story makes sense. There was only one thing I didn't fully like regarding the main plot/mystery, spoilers ahead.
SpoilerI likes being right about how the writer (I am really bad at names, sorry, and in this book they were specially confusing) stole the work from Lola, all the hints were there. But the fact it was actually his wife who killed Lola and how all that is explained feel way too convoluted for my taste, it makes less sense than if it was that he killed her for the books and done.
I am quite disappointed because my memory of his previous book was quite better. Although that was 2 years ago so maybe now I'll think differently.
This book has some nice ideas, some historical parts are really interesting to read and the same goes about psychological experiments. Sadly that's everything good about the book and that's basically retelling facts. I don't feel there's a deep understanding about most issues, and as someone really interested in philosophy and Stoicism specifically, I feel Manson doesn't really understand what he's talking about because he makes it sound almost like Cynicism or being stoic (not Stoic).
The biggest issue I have is the lack of nuance and analysis, some things extremely oversimplified and honestly this book feels like when someone says "don't be sad!" to someone depressed as if it was their choice. As other reviews mention, I do agree it seems this book is written from the perspective of someone with lots of privileges that didn't consider that other people have other issues and they can't just use such simple advice.
This book has some nice ideas, some historical parts are really interesting to read and the same goes about psychological experiments. Sadly that's everything good about the book and that's basically retelling facts. I don't feel there's a deep understanding about most issues, and as someone really interested in philosophy and Stoicism specifically, I feel Manson doesn't really understand what he's talking about because he makes it sound almost like Cynicism or being stoic (not Stoic).
The biggest issue I have is the lack of nuance and analysis, some things extremely oversimplified and honestly this book feels like when someone says "don't be sad!" to someone depressed as if it was their choice. As other reviews mention, I do agree it seems this book is written from the perspective of someone with lots of privileges that didn't consider that other people have other issues and they can't just use such simple advice.
I can only say more books like this one are desperately needed for society to improve. I was already aware of some of the things mentioned in this book, honestly I started it thinking I'd learn more about those things and how they happened but I'd not be surprised. I was so wrong about that.
I had never imagine history was so full of horrors and some are incredibly recent. In other cases it's not as sickening but still awful on its own way due to how long have women being ignored, mistreated, misdiagnosed and more.
This books is something I think is worth reading, but it's not easy to stomach, some parts are incredibly hard, upsetting and just disgusting. But it's thanks to books like this that I hope we can improve and treat everyone better. That maybe doctors pay more attention to female patients and that research is done properly without ignoring women in many cases.
I had never imagine history was so full of horrors and some are incredibly recent. In other cases it's not as sickening but still awful on its own way due to how long have women being ignored, mistreated, misdiagnosed and more.
This books is something I think is worth reading, but it's not easy to stomach, some parts are incredibly hard, upsetting and just disgusting. But it's thanks to books like this that I hope we can improve and treat everyone better. That maybe doctors pay more attention to female patients and that research is done properly without ignoring women in many cases.
When I first started reading this book I thought "I'm curious", then a bit more after "okay, it's good, but I don't think I'll give it more than 4 out of 5, I just can't see it". Honestly I have needed to think a bit to know why I ended up devouring it and giving it a 5/5 because it's not the type of book I'd at first call my cup of tea (tho I'm considering giving more similar books a chance), and at first I wasn't sure what was that got me hooked.
I think this book is a clear example of why the whole is greater than the sum of the parts. When I first starting reading this I saw the elements as individual things, the drama, the romance, the main questions of the book, each husband and character, and just like the ending, it all comes together.
I think another huge reason is the fact that the voice of Evelyn seems to command attention, makes you curious, makes you want more, something Monique does note about her in the book (at the very start, don't worry), which makes you feel like the book is real, because you also want to know more about Evelyn. Finally, this book has showed me there's more to Historical Fiction than what we usually think of, and just like with the other parts (mainly the drama) it can be really enjoyable.
I think this book is a clear example of why the whole is greater than the sum of the parts. When I first starting reading this I saw the elements as individual things, the drama, the romance, the main questions of the book, each husband and character, and just like the ending, it all comes together.
I think another huge reason is the fact that the voice of Evelyn seems to command attention, makes you curious, makes you want more, something Monique does note about her in the book (at the very start, don't worry), which makes you feel like the book is real, because you also want to know more about Evelyn. Finally, this book has showed me there's more to Historical Fiction than what we usually think of, and just like with the other parts (mainly the drama) it can be really enjoyable.