194 reviews by:

jotundottir

Filter
adventurous lighthearted medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

The first half was quite slow, there was a lot of court things and not all in the good way. There was some intrigue, but also a lot of things that felt unnecessary and as if the characters ignored or forgot the situation they are in. The second half however was quite enjoyable, there were some great plot twists and I had fun.
adventurous funny lighthearted fast-paced
Loveable characters: Yes

A solid pick if you want something light, fast and entertaining. It's not perfect, I personally really don't like how the Masked Bandit is supposedly the best bandit in the Kingdom but all we see are basic plans that aren't even considered for 2 minutes and not even plans but random ideas obviously destined to fail. Maybe it is because the character is young, but I feel the plans/ideas are easy to improve to make it just a bit more realistic that the Bandit is that good. 

With that said, it's fun to read, the story (although a bit obvious) is fine, and I found the characters are interesting, some are even charming. I quite liked Rhen and Cai.
challenging dark reflective fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

 I started reading this book because someone recommended it saying it's similar to 1984 and while that's true in that they treat similar ideas and concepts, it's very interesting to see how they both develop in such different ways.

Sometimes the book can be a bit dense or hard to read, but I liked it anyway, it wasn't something I'd consider a big issue. The final part is rather philosophical but I really liked that part. 
adventurous dark mysterious tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

ARC review, this is my honest opinion.

This book is not what I expected, the same way the metal clam is not what Viv and Mick expected, because in both cases it's so much more. At first it can seem a regular book, with normal teenagers (with their faults, of course) living a normal adventure, but things change quickly and it's so much bigger, the same happened to me with the book. 

The first half felt closer to home, more normal and common. Just some teenagers trying to figure out a mystery. It's true in this part I noticed more the things I didn't like but they are just two and not really bothering honestly. One is that the action happens too fast and it's also described in a way that can make it hard to follow, it's a bit flashy, but it does keep you hooked. The second is that Mick and Viv, but specially Viv, are definitely normal teenagers, and they can be just as insufferable and silly at times. I got a bit frustrated I'll admit, but it also felt realistic in a way, because they're not stupid, they can think and solve mysteries and issues, but just as normal teenagers, they can miss the importance and the size of what they are dealing with. 

But the second half is totally unexpected, and it made me feel like the characters because it's also more than they expected when they started investigating the clam. I feel this book really makes you feel like you are there. It feels real, tense, and fascinating at the same time. I find it so interesting that this book explores the topic of what happens when you give absolute power to teenagers, does power always corrupt? Or maybe it is more that people can't really control it? Is there anyone capable and trust-worthy enough to hold such power? I want to read more, I want to see where this goes and more.

I'll warn this book is darker than it looks. To me it seemed like typical YA sci-fi at first, but the themes, the plot and more it's definitely darker, so keep this in mind when picking this book.
mysterious tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Este es el primer libro de la saga que leo (era el que tocaba en el club de lectura), y si alguien piensa en hacer lo mismo creo que es mejor empezar desde el principio debido a algunos spoilers de la trama de los personajes principales, pero personalmente no me ha molestado mucho, ya que voy a leer los demás pensando en cómo ha llegado la historia hasta ahí. Dicho eso, me ha encantado.

La trama nunca ha llegado a hacerse pesada ni lenta, y aprecio mucho que la autora deje pistas al lector como "esa conversación sería vital para el caso" o así porque hace que sea muy entretenido de leer y de intentar resolver antes del final. Además el final tiene todo el sentido, no hay giros repentinos sin sentido para complicar la trama que el lector jamás podría haber visto venir, es sincero.

Los personajes son bastante entrañables, hasta Sabadelle. Por supuesto tienen sus lados negativos, sus problemas y se dejan llevar, pero me parece que no llegan a ser irracionales. Tampoco pasa que mágicamente todo les salga totalmente bien pese a todo, hay peligro y tensión. Y el final es trepidante, leí como el último 30% de una sentada.
emotional funny hopeful lighthearted relaxing medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

This was my first pure romance book, I have read romance before mixed with other genres but that was it. I have to say I absolutely LOVED this book. It didn't feel cheesy, on the contrary, it felt kind of fresh to me due to the fact the writer seems aware of the romance stereotypes and some are used, but in a good way. The plot was simple but interesting, I wanted to know why that trip, why was Libby acting like that, but it didn't get in the way of the romance, yet it wasn't fully on the side or uninteresting.

The characters felt quite nice for more of the time. But the ending absolutely makes them so real and awesome, it's the reason I went from 4 to 5 stars. The way everything was tied, the motives, the fact they involved Nora's flaws and issues and explained them in a way that wasn't the obvious. I liked it all so much. I also liked how healthy the relationships and love turn to be, and although there are some quotes that are more cheesy or obvious, I think they felt quite real, in my experience they did sound like something a person could say and not like a perfect/dreamy version of a romantic interest. 
adventurous funny slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: N/A
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

ARC review.
There are some very nice things in this book. I like Josh's character, he seems pretty well defined and different from the rest. The magic is fun, there are different powers and the fact some seem to be common for everyone, while others are fully individual and others are shared among groups (Conquest has signaling for example) is quite creative, and allows for many combinations. I think the world in general has some great potential too. The book is consistent with some details like character's habits, which I really liked, and even secondary characters are seen as powerful which I like but this is a downside too (explained later).

Unfortunatedly, there are way more bad things for me and some are pretty important. I was thinking about hiding all the review for spoilers but... there's none, because there's barely any plot, but I'll get to that. 

First of all there's no info about the world at all, forget world-building, there's not even a little "we're in this country/planet and the Fireburst have been creating destruction for the last X years" and that made it really hard for me to care about anything because I lacked so much information. Why are the Fireburst causing so much destruction? This is even more important since they are described as very logical, and characters don't even consider this point. There's barely any information about the divisions, and it's a shame, it'd have made the book way more interesting for me. I also really didn't like how the information was delivered sometimes. Partially because they repeated information I already knew while leaving other information out, but also because some information is delivered almost at the end when there are chances to give it in a very natural way earlier.

The second thing that made me dislike the book the most is the lack of plot. I think this book feels like reading the second act of a story, the training arc. The ending is okay but I don't like finishing in a cliffhanger and due to the rest of the book it doesn't motivate me to keep reading the series, but rather the opposite.

Then there are many details that slowly but surely bothered me more and more about the book. While even secondary characters seem powerful, the protagonists are clearly the chosen ones, the ones that can't lose a single fight, at most they'll tie, and due to the lack of information they don't sound that experienced to justify this against people that it's said have a lot of training. They also recover from traumatic stuff overnight (literaly) and behave like nothing happened when they have been tortured for weeks. It made it feel so unrealistic to me, and I understand it's a Young Adult book, but I'd have liked it more if they were held for just a couple of days so it's more real that they are okay so fast. Also, to me every character sounded the same except Josh, and maybe Walter. The rest all seem like they are joking and bantering all the time and maybe that's why they all sounded so similar to me.

While there are other details and things I disliked I think this gives a good overview of the book and my experience reading it.