jamgrl's Reviews (197)

Excellent! It is short but it packs a punch. Maybe more because of the shortness? The style also lends itself well to an audiobook since a lot of it sounds like listening to spoken word poetry, though I am curious to see how the poetry is laid out on the pages!

First off, I want to say: it is awesome to read/listen to a fantasy book so imbedded into a Latin American country’s culture: despite taking place entirely in Florida (when they aren’t in a magical realm), Argentina is very present in this story.

On the book: This book is not very subtle, but it is pretty interesting! I enjoyed the parallels of the fantasy world and the real world, the conversations about identity and belonging, the commentary on why categorizing people is bad (is this a response to the Hogwarts house system?? Because Garber is right.) and about immigration (being an immigrant and the immigration system and what it means to be an outsider). I just adore the fun of teenagers being together and doing fantasy stuff while also plotting plots. Also, all the Spanish! The fantasy world itself is lush and interesting and I love that everything in both the fantasy and real world societies has a dark political undertone. The romantic subplot was generally uninteresting to me, but I am aware I am not the target audience for adolescent lust/romance 😅.* 

Warning: There is a large amount of Harry Potter references (named references by the protagonist) in addition to other books, like Pride and Prejudice and 100 Years of Solitude. This is something I don’t love in general/find awkward (think Bella Swan talking about Wuthering Heights and Romeo and Juliet all the time), but the amount of Harry Potter specifically was a bit uncomfortable-  be warned if reminders of Harry Potter are upsetting.

*

Though, I did in fact whoop audibly when Manu walked in on Saysa and Cata 😂.